Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Behavior Management 101: Why Yelling doesn't Work

By Merely Me, Health Guide Monday, November 16, 2009
If you have a child with ADHD or related special needs I can guarantee that at some point during your parenting you have felt so frustrated that you wanted to yell at your child.  Perhaps you have done so.  Don't worry I am not here to judge.  I have been in the same boat.  Behavi...
11/16/09 4:59pm

Thanks for the gentle reminder - all of us with children who have ADHD tend to fall into yelling mode at one time or another and it does us no good.

Merely Me, Health Guide
11/19/09 7:43pm

Hey there!

 

I hear ya.  I know from experience that it really doesn't work to yell however enticing it may seem. 

 

Thanks so much for your comment!  Hope to hear more about your experiences in parenting.

11/18/09 3:08pm

This worked for my children, mostly :)  For every action, there is a consequence and it had to be taught when the behavior was incorrect or dangerous. A child needs to be taught most everything. They just are not born programmed to fit into the society in which they find themselves. They know nothing about our expectations and rules, a blank slate.

 

I yelled more than I should have, but it was usually to get attention, then I pretty much followed your recipe for guidance and learned behavior. To explain why I didn't want them to do, that. And why. If it made sense, the problem stopped, although a few reminders were necessary, along with consequences for continuing the action.You're pretty smart!

Merely Me, Health Guide
11/19/09 7:45pm

You are so right Paul...

 

It is true...some things we take for granted that kids should know...they need to be explicitly taught and they will test the limits for sure.

 

I appreciate your comments and insights...keep 'em coming!

Anonymous
shirley jones
11/21/09 6:46am

This year, however, due to illness, I haven't even yet begun and may have to end up with shopping at the crowded malls.

 **********************
   shirley jones
   *********

<a href="http://www.legalx.net" rel="dofollow">attorneys</a>

Anonymous
twoeyoutofcontrol
11/21/09 12:36am

yelling definatly does not work . specially since i've found that i myself am adhd . yelling just makes me want to yell more and louder than what the other is yelling. well it eventually just turns into one huge temper tantrum. many times i've come away extremly emotional from all the yelling and what i said. cause things are said without thinking and later on i regret majority of what was said . really learn your childs triggors that jump start a temper  tantrum for example . a long car ride, your mood, overtiredness, hungry , those are a few of mine and if you find a way to deal with each of these triggors it can be much easier

Merely Me, Health Guide
11/21/09 8:25am

Hi there!

 

You give some very good advice here.  I do agree that it is very effective to figure out the triggers and patterns for your child's behavior and for your own. 

 

Thanks so much for reading and commenting...I do hope you will come back to site to participate more.

11/ 4/10 7:53pm

I agree, in theory, but sometimes saying things quietly, politely, after I have gotten his attention does not work.  He seems to not listen until I seem "really mad" and begin to yell.  Then I sometimes, foolishly ask "Why cant you listen to me before I get mad?" He says, "I was too busy". I think he waits it out until i really mean business.... so we talk about this when we are both calm, and agree on cooperation, and all is fine, until the next time, and he ignores me again, and I repeat and repeat, and when I get loud, he gets loud back and then complies. It's a bad cycle, and i want out of it. So I have put parental controls on the computer that kick him off at 8 pm, and I can avoid that "directive" and then he is mad at the computer instead.  As for the ball throwing, and me taking the ball, that would probably result in kicking, hitting, and biting around here,  (him, not me). 

11/ 4/10 7:53pm

I agree, in theory, but sometimes saying things quietly, politely, after I have gotten his attention does not work.  He seems to not listen until I seem "really mad" and begin to yell.  Then I sometimes, foolishly ask "Why cant you listen to me before I get mad?" He says, "I was too busy". I think he waits it out until i really mean business.... so we talk about this when we are both calm, and agree on cooperation, and all is fine, until the next time, and he ignores me again, and I repeat and repeat, and when I get loud, he gets loud back and then complies. It's a bad cycle, and i want out of it. So I have put parental controls on the computer that kick him off at 8 pm, and I can avoid that "directive" and then he is mad at the computer instead.  As for the ball throwing, and me taking the ball, that would probably result in kicking, hitting, and biting around here,  (him, not me). 

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2205) >
By Merely Me, Health Guide— Last Modified: 06/08/11, First Published: 11/16/09