As Care Options for Elders Multiply, Problems Need to be Addressed

  • While I was growing up, I'd hear, occasionally, about someone having to go to a "rest home" or an "old folk's home." As the decades slipped by, the term "nursing home" came into vogue. Regardless of the name change, they were all warehouses for those tough folks who actually survived a stroke or who had extremely crippling arthritis. Some were suffering from the effects of polio and could no longer be cared for by family. Of course, some had "senile dementia" and needed to be "put in a home."


    As people's life spans increased, and more people lived through strokes and other ailments that had killed people just a few years earlier, these homes came under closer scrutiny. I noticed, at least up here on the high plains where I've spent a great deal of my life, that nursing homes started to lose some of their hospital like features. They took on a more home-like feel.

    Add This Infographic to Your Website or Blog With This Code:


    In the late 60s, my grandmother, who was crippled with severe rheumatoid arthritis, needed more care than we could be provide at home, so she moved to a brand new facility in town called Bethany Towers. Grandma had lived with us for seven years, and we weren't going to put her just anywhere. Bethany was nice, and they had a newer concept of what nursing homes should be like. As I recall, they also had big plans for expansion, and some of those plans included lower levels of care for those who didn't need full-blown nursing care. Bethany Towers was considered "progressive."


    I don't remember exactly when assisted living facilities became a part of the caregiving landscape. Surely, it was long after my grandmother's death. I became acutely aware of that option during my own caregiving years, as my own mother became more disabled with her arthritis. Together, we toured these new assisted living places. They were expensive, and they didn't accept Medicare or Medicaid. Before I could talk Mom into moving from her apartment to assisted living, her health declined to the point that assisted living could no longer take her. She needed the twenty-four hour nursing care that nursing homes provide.


    Now, assisted living facilities are popping up all over, and many larger nursing homes have expanded to include the option of starting out in their assisted living area, and then, "when the time comes," moving to the nursing wing. I've encouraged a few people who have sought my advice to look at this option. They've had elders who were in their 80s, yet still only needed minimal assistance. In-home care wasn't enough or wasn't working, for one reason or another. If people are still doing fairly well at that age, they are likely to keep on going for awhile, and the eventual need of more nursing care looms on the horizon. And it's important to remember that it is easier to move within a facility than from one to another.


    With more people using assisted living, it's inevitable that problems will arise. Some organizations will see the opportunity to make some quick money. Places that only offer assisted living don't fall under the same rules as nursing homes, and inspection of these facilities isn't as well regulated, so it's easier to pull of a business with less than optimal care.


    Add This Infographic to Your Website or Blog With This Code:

    The Tulsa World recently ran a story titled, "Number of homes cited for problems," which is a rather chilling indictment of assisted living in the Tulsa Oklahoma area.


    The article begins by saying, "More than half of the assisted living homes inspected in Oklahoma last year were cited for medication problems, violating patient rights or housing patients whose needs exceed the level of care the homes are licensed to provide, a Tulsa World analysis shows."


    It goes on to say, "Dorya Huser, chief of long-term care for the state Health Department, said the department's inspectors have been finding more cases of neglect and other serious issues as they work through a backlog of overdue inspections. Because assisted-living centers do not accept Medicare or Medicaid, there is no federal reimbursement for state inspections. Regulations are also much less specific than those nursing homes must follow."


    Under the sub-head "A system coming of age," the World says, "Two decades ago, most elderly or disabled people who could no longer stay home went to a nursing home. The homes, based on a medical model, weren't designed for residents who could do most things for themselves...Kathleen Cameron, chairwoman of the Consumer Consortium on Assisted Living's board of directors, said assisted-living centers evolved 25 years ago 'for people who didn't necessarily need the level of care that is provided in nursing facilities but needed some assistance with activities of daily living.'''


    This excellent article addresses the idea that regulations and inspections need to evolve along with these newer facilities. Since assisted living doesn't fall under Medicare and Medicaid law, it is up to state or local government to look for answers in areas where facilities fall below acceptable standards.


    Any facility that serves as housing for elders, or other vulnerable adults, needs strict oversight to ensure the health and safety of the residents. If staff isn't available to inspect these homes, then funding needs to be earmarked for this important role in caring for our elders. No one should suffer from neglect or abuse because they are in a facility that isn't properly inspected.


    To learn more about Carol, please go to or

Published On: August 23, 2007