My mother, may she rest in peace, strongly resented this kind of methodology.  I think deep down inside she knew that at one point she was capable of doing so much more than matching colors or fitting two puzzle pieces together (before, she was a one-woman office manager that had a myriad of things to keep track of, and did so successfully).  My father, who does not suffer Alzheimer's, on the other hand, is happily doing these exercises, to the point that the occupational therapist has requested more difficult projects for him to keep his brain stimulated at a higher level.  I guess every individual reacts differently.  But the important thing, as you stated, is to respect the patient for what he/she was and not be condescending in the approach.

Carol Bradley Bursack, Health Guide

11/12/08 7:45am

Thanks for the confirmation of my thoughts. My mother would have been deeply offended. Probably my dad would have been, too, unless they gave him things about science or something. But, apparently for some, it works. And you are seeing results from both angles.

 

Your feedback is so valuable. Thanks so much.

Carol

I'm neither an expert in Alzheimer's care nor teaching but I do see the value in knowing that this technique may work, even if it's just a certain percentage of cases.  As an agency caring for seniors and rolling out an Alzheimer's training program for our employees do you know of any resources in the Mesa, AZ area that can help me learn more about these techniques with families interested in considering this tool? 

SYNERGY HomeCare of the East Valley

Carol Bradley Bursack, Health Guide

11/21/08 6:20pm

It's good that you are interested in exploring all avenues. Good home care experts should have an open minded approach.

Best,

 

Carol

I am very familiar with the Montessori approach (and with caregiving), and just wanted to say that it is not "childlike" at all, even when used in schools with children. Montessori schools often enroll the entire family and the concepts of respect, dignity, and interesting learning (not dumbed-down, but rather serious) are relevant for all ages and relationships.  To bring these concepts of MORE independence and respect to our elders is a step in the right direction, in my opinion.  In some families and cultures, the Montesorri approach would be considered normal everyday living, but in others, the concept of basic respect for all members of the community has to be taught.  The kinds of things Montessori advocates are simply a "given" to me, with the children, teens, adults, and elders in my life, thankfully. There is no drawback to this that I can see. 

Carol Bradley Bursack, Health Guide

2/ 6/12 11:43am

Thanks for this enlightening look into the technique. Respect is lacking for many segments of our population, but our society is particularly weak in that respect. Elders should never be treated as though they are children, but respect is something we need to offer.

Take care,

Carol