Saturday, May 25, 2013

Friday, November 05, 2010 Michelle asks

Q: My Mother-in-Law has been diagnosed with Dementia. She is currently under Hospice care as well and her husband insists we exercise her so she can WALK in the near future. I strongly oppose this.

For obvious reasons (like recently having a stroke, her age "88", loss of muscle-tone, having a Pacemaker put in last month, etc) I don't feel my Mother-in-Law will EVER walk again. In the long run, wouldn't having Dementia worsen under her condition, thus she would FORGET how to walk and could fall and seriously injure herself??? (even with a walker I strongly oppose her attempting to walk). Thank you for your time~Michelle
Answer This
Answers (3)
Dorian Martin, Health Guide
11/ 8/10 1:26pm

Hi, Michelle,

 

I do think walking may be problematic at this point. However, you might suggest to your father-in-law that chair exercises may be a good option. These can include alternately lifting each leg up and down while seated as well as doing arm exercises.

 

Take care!

 

Dorian

Reply
11/ 5/10 5:14pm

Hi Michelle,

 

Usually it is good to exercise. I cannot say for her because I don't know if her health allows her to exercise or not, but I can explain a little bit about how walking works for dementia elders.

My father-in-law has late Alzheimer's. This is a slow process. Long before late 2006, my FIL was able to jog for a long distance all the way to the beach and campus that is 30 minutes  or an hour away from his old house everyday. Starting in 2007, he could no longer jog but he tried to walk a block. I think he had a cane already in 2007 but he used it only sometimes as he tried to be normal without a cane. Starting in 2008 after he got sick once and his cognition level dropped a little bit, he needed a cane for sure. He could not use a walker as he cannot drive anyway. A walker is harder because it needs the drive which he can no longer understand how. Now it is 2010. He fell once or twice so someone has to be next to him this year. He still uses his cane and it is better if someone is next to him to make sure he does not fall - the difference is he uses it all the time for walking. It is a very slow process and it took 4 years! He still does not need any wheelchair at all.

 

So if your MIL can exercise if the doctor allows it, it is OK. Yes she would forget how to walk but it is not a drastic change. It is a very slow change. So you can certainly give a trial to see how she can walk. But a walker is not a good idea if she does not drive anymore. A cane is good. Make sure someone is next to her.

If the doctor allows it, some little exercise or even physical therapy is good.

I don't think having dementia means no exercise anymore. In fact, it is the other way around: more walk or exercise helps. The director of the home where my FIL is encourages him to walk more without a wheelchair.

 

Hope this helps,
Nina 

Reply
11/ 5/10 5:23pm

By the way, my father-in-law is to be 90 years old end of Nov.


Nina

Reply
11/ 6/10 3:10am

Hi Nina, thank you so much for your kind and informative response! (and Happy Birthday to your FIL). I am concerned about my MIL because she can barely stand, and even then it's only for a few seconds and WITH support from someone on both sides. Her left foot does not lie flat on the ground (due to a stroke) and she has very weak knees/hips. Both her doctors and the nurses from Hospice have told my FIL that trying to walk her is a bad idea. The family is now fighting and divided on this matter, and all I want to do is make the rest of her life comfortable. I will just be there for her when I can, and let the rest fall into place. Thanks again, and have a wonderful Holiday season~Michelle

Reply
11/ 6/10 7:03pm

Hi Michelle,

 

So sorry that she cannot walk anymore. I think in this case she should just get comfort care like you said. Probably her husband has a hard time to accept it given it is hospice. He must feel very sad. If she is not willing either, I don't think it is a good idea she should walk. Sorry her stroke is so bad. Dementia alone does not drop like a stroke or a bad car accident.

 

Thanks for wishing us well. Happy Thanksgiving!

Nina

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

By Michelle— Last Modified: 10/26/11, First Published: 11/05/10