• Peggy Peggy
    January 06, 2009
    how much does a person with late stage alzheimers understand about their situation
    Peggy Peggy
    January 06, 2009

    My friend is in a nursing facility, moves uncontrollably, stays in a fetal position most of the time, has a feeding tube and in diapers.  However she'll frequently criy or even smile at times that seem to be appropriate (i.e. as I talk to her or she'll become agitated after she unsuccessfully tries to communicate or mumbles for a long stretch of time.)  At one point a few months ago she said very clearly "I can't live like this anymore".  I'm wondering how cognizant she may be about her condition, if these moments of clarity are just fleeting or if she's really suffering with the knowledge of her decline most of the time.  Can you point me to any studies on this subject?



  • Carol Bradley Bursack, Minding Our Elders
    Health Guide
    January 07, 2009
    Carol Bradley Bursack, Minding Our Elders
    Health Guide
    January 07, 2009

    Each person is different, and moments change. I don't know that this can be quantified by a study. When I was speaking to a gerontology class that uses my book as a text, a young woman told me that she had never known her grandma without Alzheimer's. Her grandma didn't know anyone, anymore. But once, as the girl was hugging her grandmas goodbye, and the girl said, "I love you, Grandma," the grandma said, "I love you, too, Anna." It was out of no where.


    My dad had surgically induced dementia. He often seemed to know nothing about his condition, yet once he looked me straight in the eye and I knew it was coming from the "real" him - he said," My universe has gotten so small." Then he went right back "in."


    Personally, I believe that there is awareness of their condition, at least at times, and frustration and anger as well, but it depends a lot on the stages of the disease. I feel, from what I've read and observed, that toward the end, they may be seeing things we don't even know about. It is a process. Death is a process, for people suffering from disease. I think they can be "in and out" for a long time. And the times we can't reach them, they are reaching beyond what we see.


    At all stages, touching and talking and doing what you are doing - it's all so important. Whether the person responds or not, they are aware on some level that someone cares and is there for them. Please keep doing what you can. You sound wonderful.



You should know Answers to your question are meant to provide general health information but should not replace medical advice you receive from a doctor. No answers should be viewed as a diagnosis or recommended treatment for a condition. Content posted by community members does not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media, which also reserves the right to remove material deemed inappropriate.