Monday, February 13, 2012

Wednesday, November 04, 2009 NC asks

Q: Is nursing home so bad?

Is nursing home really a reluctant choice? Often many people told me that they would never go to a nursing home unless it is necessary. It labels nursing home as some bad place to go. Like it is a prison. There are bad homes and good homes. Sure it is bad for antisocial folks who would hate to be in a group home. But is it really a bad choice? It is not as cozy as a good private home. What do you think? I wonder about those folks who go to the nursing home. Maybe it is good for them. Should we really feel sorry for them because it is the ONLY choice they may have??

 

Nina

Answer This
Answers (3)
11/ 5/09 1:01pm

Decisions for long term placement vary and are determined based on individual needs.  Many families choose to investigate nursing homes because their loved ones need care and supervision that are too difficult to manage at home as the disease progresses. Many nursing homes provide an aesthetically pleasing environment, have a multitude of care options to meet the needs of residents, and provide stimulating activities. In addition, some long term care residences have special Alzheimer's or Dementia Care units within the facility, where the staff may have more dementia-specific training. 
 
Like anything else, facilities range in quality of care for a number of reasons.  The best way to evaluate a facility is to do as much research as possible.  When looking for a facility, it is important to visit both by appointment and unannounced, at different times throughout the day and evening.  During the visit, use your senses to evaluate the facility, i.e., smell (Do you smell anything offensive?); touch (Are the tables sticky or wet); sight (How do residents appear to be cared for?).  Ask for a recreation calendar to see what types of activities are offered and how often they are available.  Once the individual is placed in the facility, it is just as important to remain involved in the daily routine to ensure the best quality of care.  In addition to visiting, you can find out more about the facility’s reputation by reviewing their ratings.  Nursing homes are licensed health care providers, and so they are regulated, inspected, and there is a public listing of complaints and inspection results.  Once a person had a facility in mind, they could view the inspection results by visiting the web site www.Memberofthefamily.net.  This site provides information about 16,000 Medicare/Medicaid-certified nursing homes in the United States.  The ratings can also be reviewed at http://www.medicare.gov/Nursing/Overview.asp.
 
The decision for nursing home placement is a very personal choice.  Some facilities are good for one person and not good for someone else.  Most importantly, the individual needs to be happy, comfortable, safe and well taken care of on a daily basis.

Reply
11/ 6/09 12:36pm

Thank you so much for the websites. They are very very helpful.

 

Regards,

Nina

Reply
11/ 4/09 10:39pm

Well, Nina... To be honest, there are "better" facilities and "worse" ones.  My dad finished out his life in 1999 at what turned out to be a "worse" one.  I hesitate to use the terms "good" and "bad", because I am convinced that there are no "good" ones, even if you are fortunate enough to find a "better" one.  Due to the lack of sufficient caregiver staff and training, many mistakes were made and many bad attitudes developed among the caregivers.  You can't always judge how competent the place is by the smell or by touring it, either.  I found that the day shift was hand-picked to provide the appearance of caring, capable, and friendly staff.  The night shift is where things were terribly wrong.  Patients were being dropped on the floor during transfers (my dad and others).  They would move the call button out of the patient's reach and place the telephone where it couldn't be used to call for help.  Patients would be left lying in their own waste for hours while hollering for help to no avail.  We had our supplies stolen (borrowed?) to be used (loaned) for other patients.  I had to buy numerous universal TV remote controls because they were (stolen?) lost.  Dad would ask me to feed him in the dining room because he couldn't lift the utensils to feed himself.  If I wasn't there, they would have tossed his food and wheeled him back to his room.  It was a horrible experience and dad died there with little assistance from anyone.  By the time that we realized just how horrible things were there, he was in his final few weeks of life.  Hospice was called too late, but did provide some comfort items.  It's from experiences like ours, that nursing homes are viewed with such dread. 

Reply
11/ 5/09 1:08pm

Hi, N.C,

 

I'd suggest that many factors play into the decision. My mom never wanted to be placed in a nursing home. However, that was really the only option open to me because of her medical condition (she had both Alzheimer's and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease) and my own life situation which prevented me from having the time/energy to keep her at my home. I think her quality of life was much better there than I would have been able to provide for her since her lungs were really, really bad. And there were some good people on staff and some residents that she enjoyed being with.

 

And I agree with the previous answers - quality of nursing homes vary greatly. It's up to states to ensure that nursing homes reach a good level of service.

 

Finally, I think that we as a society don't like to think about  person's final years, which often is the case when placement in a nursing home is being considered. So that, too, contributes to the reluctance.

 

Take care!

 

Dorian

 

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of The HealthCentral Network. The HealthCentral Network does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (1454) >