Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

A Replacement Name For Bipolar: The Bipolar Question of the Week

By John McManamy, Health Guide Sunday, May 13, 2012
I hate the word, “bipolar”. This is a label imposed on us by outsiders, people utterly lacking in taste and imagination, with no sense of grace or proportion, with all the aesthetic sensibilities of Mao Zedong’s tailor.   Keep in mind, this is the disease of Byron, Van Gogh, Wo...
5/13/12 6:41pm

You're right.  Computers are bipolar.  I don't have a word.  I use two pieces of "flair" from Facebook.

 

One is a person with frantic face, holding onto his head with his two hands, with the caption, "Brain Breakage."  I guess that's my PTSD/Anxiety Disorder NOS (depending on who is diagnosing me).

 

The other is the bare feet of somebody at the edge of a tightrope, just about to step on.  That's my BP2 Dx. Sometimes it's a thing of grace and beauty.  Sometimes I wobble.  Sometimes I flat out fall on my ass.  Mostly I wobble, symptoms present but manageable.

5/13/12 9:41pm

I prefer Drain Bamaged, Manic Without the Highs or simply Whack-a-Noodle.

5/14/12 9:20am

I call it "being uniquely unique".. refer to it as such anyway

 

I DO NOT call myself Bipolar.  I don't.  I seldom even tell folks and even more seldom, do I tell medical folks (have been "overlooked" because of it).  I do not want everyone to "see" me ONLY as mentally ill.

 

I am a person, a human, an individual.  I have many failings but also, many attributes.  If all one sees is "Bipolar", that is - from my personal and intimate past experience with people - ALL THEY see.

 

I just refer to myself, during my "bipolar episodes"... as being "uniquely unique" or "the cashew found in a can of Planter's can of plain nuts"... or, "i'm just wired a bit differently and a light popped on."

 

 

no, Bipolar has so far gotten away from where it originally initiated from.. description wise

I cycle... between "highs" and "lows".  I have more "lows" than "highs".

 

The cycles come on their own, without provocation, without trigger.  That being said, you add in a provocation - a trigger, and the cycles can be - oh so intensified, oh so mixed up, at times hairy scary and nightmary, oh so rapidly changing from one to another.  Otherwise... it's the "ebb" and the "flow" of my illness that I ride.

 

if it weren't for life intervening so dang much... it wouldn't be 1/2 bad

5/14/12 2:51pm

How about "Restless Brain Syndrome" (Playing off of Restless Leg Syndrome).

Our brains have a difficult time finding stasis or being relaxed.

5/18/12 9:29am

I like the Restless Brain thing... except for when the depressions hit

 

then it's Brain Sludge

Anonymous
Alfredo
5/15/12 4:20am

 

 

Dear John,

 

I think that in order to answer this question, we have to begin to separate those who are humanitarian gifted people from those who just have bipolar disorder. Both have the same symptoms but they are different. Humanitarian Gifted people do suffer with bipolar but for some reason continue to develop in a very positive way, with the disorder, to become humanitarian gifted people. When this happens the bipolar symptoms slowly vanish to give life to an exceptional individual. And what does it mean to be a humanitarian gifted person? According to me, this article that I have written a while ago best explains it:

 

http://alfredo123.wordpress.com/2011/10/04/anthony-minghella-and-humanitarian-gifted-people/

 

It is very likely that this is just my delusion of grandeur, that I see myself as a humanitarian gifted person just as I think that you (John McMann) are a humanitarian gifted person. However wild this idea there is a possibility, however remote, that I could be right.

 

Gifted people need to experience the same moods of depression experienced by people with bipolar. Once we understand these emotions and moods we begin to control them and use them to our advantage. All people who suffer with bipolar have the potential to become humanitarian gifted people but not many succeed.

 

To succeed in controlling and transforming bipolar disorder takes years of making mistakes, even big mistakes but to never give up and continue the journay towards the Light. This is something that Kazmierz Dabrawski proposed in his theory of positive disintegration. Here is a wonderful dissertation on the increadible life of Dabrawski a humanitarian gifted person, a psychiatrist, psychologist, schizophrenic and poet:

 

http://scholar.lib.vt.edu/theses/available/etd-04082002-204054/unrestricted/Dissertation.pdf

 

 

 

 

Anonymous
Alfredo
5/15/12 4:37am

Do I think that I am so special? Not really. But I need to nurture my delusion of grandeur because it is a source of much creativity. Many good things come out of this delusion of grandeur just like the music found at the link below:

 

http://www.jamendo.com/en/list/a100258/hope

 

Which I have composed a while ago and which can be freely downloaded.

 

If such good things come out of my delusion of grandeur, why should I dislike it? And why should anyone else dislike it? It is a source of something good.

 

The thing is that I think completely differently from the norm. In my different way of thinking there is room for delusion of grandeur, bipolar disorder and all other differences and disabilities.

 

If we learn to truly value bipolar disorder and delusions of granduer we not only eliminate stigma but we gain a real lot because the kind of art and science that we would get in return would be something truly increadible not yet seen or experienced.

 

5/15/12 7:02am

My mum told me when I was first dianogsed with depression as a teenager, that mental illness is "extreme normal" she gave me the example of illnesses such as schitzophrenia,in our concious mind, we all hear voices, it is an innate part of our conscious mind, it helps us to go about our daily routines and decision making, but when that part of us takes on a life of it's own that is seperate from us that then becomes "illness" a delusion a hallucination that is destructive and takes us away from our reality.

 

Regarding bipolar, we all have our up's and downs, but when it becomes an extreme that is beyond our grasp then it becomes "illness"

 

I don't consider the extremes that I can control an illness, rather a tool to help me get things done, a tool to aid my creativity in my art and writing.

 

With my downs, I feel nothing, I am nothing, I am completely disconected with the world around me, my ups however are glorious, I feel everything, I am everything, and everything is within me, the universe is connected and the most obscure things are beautiful! It almost seems like a gift at times because I am at my most productive when I'm "unwell" I get things done, I am creative, I am open minded, non judemental or if I'm down I merely stop thinking and take a rest which doesn't happen in the general hum of todays busy world... "normal" people don't have the ability to merely stop thinking and feeling like I do when I'm depressed... depression does serve a purpose I find... even if we fail to recognise it when we are experiencing it.

 

Bipolar seems like such an institutional term, I prefer my mum's term "extremely normal" (which has carried me through years of depression) what we feel and do, is normal, but just in levels that are extreme...

 

I am me and I am proud of my unique mind!

Anonymous
guest
5/18/12 12:42am

I believe my mom has been diagnosed with "bipolar" but she also has the Drug-treatment resistent aspect to her major depression as well.  I lean toward her interpretation of bipolar - a manic or extreme state of emotion.  Although not diagnosed "bipolar," only major depression (controlled) I, too, have similar traits. 

 

My mom seems to have manic or extreme lows.  It's rare that she's "really" happy.  So maybe it's all perspective.  Maybe when I actually hear her laugh or she jokes around she's actually not "normal" but in a manic high state?

 

My mania tends to manifest itself as very impulsive.  A lot of times it's impulsive idealism/optimism (I'm usually a pessimist/realist).  I may make an impulse purchase or eat uncontrollably or insist on going out/doing something with friends (I'm a homebody).  I tend to take positive things too far.

 

Like another commentor wrote, my low is when i feel completely disconnected from the world.  I can sit and do, think, etc. nothing.  My brain does not connect with any stimuli.  There is a book called, I think, Out of the Black Hole.  My mom has read it; I can see her black hole.  I haven't read it, but I think this is my black hole when I'm disconnected - everything is absorbed, nothing is emitted.

 

I believe it is true that we are all extremely gifted, talented, genius, in some way. Therefore no one understands how productivity/inspiration can come out of an illness.  Even my mom says I think completely backwards from her and everyone else.  It is rare that someone can follow my connections, randomness, stream of consciousness.

5/18/12 9:28am

Mania is not, not always necessarily anyway... what folks typically think it is... you know, the HIGH FLYING "I'm Superman here watch me fly" type.

 

For many of us it is high agitation, impulsiveness, over abundance of positivity when it's not necessarily appropriate or "accepted"... lots of drive and energy... sometimes, it's a feeling of rising pounding pressure within to talk more - move faster - scour the entire house from ceiling to floor a entire night and not yawn a single bit, etc..

 

IF it is not our "normal" state of being

 

If you are "normally" a homebody, isolated, and withdrawn.... and suddenly, you feel highly sociable, giggly, joking about, wanting to go and do and see and feel... dance on the table tops, enjoy the night life... high energy.... OR suddenly you are MOST productive at work and can't understand what the hell is wrong with everyone else that they can't keep up with you?...

and then you return to the homebody, isolated, withdrawn

 

you (and others) would note that the "oddness" would be the high sociability, etc..  right?

 

you can also be manically depressed...  or a "high mixed" episode where you have mania and depression at the same time

 

those... those are not pretty... no, no ... not pretty.. highly uncomfortable.. eww... not pretty... I have them quite often and it feels like my brain is splitting in 2 sometimes.... not good... hmmm.... not good

 

oh... and I too... am told that I think "differently" and "see things differently" than everyone else surrounding me... an acuteness to my surrounding environment at times

I do, at times, enjoy being "uniquely unique".

Anonymous
Alfredo
5/18/12 4:01pm

I agree with your explanation of mania. My mania is similar to yours when it comes. But I do think that all people with bipolar, whether they admit it or not, do suffer with some delusion of grandeur. I am not sure that it is a delusion either because we experience states of being that take us closer to something really huge, an energy that we feel and that is very real. Perhaps the Light or great wisdom and knowledge.

 

Over the years I have learned to channel this energy (that springs from both mania and depression) and use it to improve my creativity and art. Many artists would love to experience mania and depression because they know that that is where the creative genius comes from. Without experiencing these moods the expression of art is not complete and certainly not as powerful. That is because real art comes from emotions and moods and appeals to peoples' emotions, moods and feelings.

 

And it is because of these experiences that we think so differently from people who do not suffer with bipolar. We are different, there is no doubt about that but whether we define this difference as positive or negative is up to our society. In our society it is negative and so that we also feel about our bipolar in a negative way at least most of the times and if not consciously then subconsciously. But in some cultures it is a positive. Many Shamans consider bipolar to be a true gift, the gift of vision which needs to be nurtured and developed. For me it is also a gift that I am learning to control and integrate positively into my personality. I think that I am succ3e3eding in this.

 

Anonymous
Alfredo
5/18/12 4:07pm

the gift can be destructive or constructive and it largely depends on how we see bipolar and what we do to control it. It is a dangerous and very powerful gift that needs constant attention. Those who learn to control it become outstanding people who have great wisdom, knowledge and are in touch with wonderful emotions. I think that we are REAL people not robots: we are individuals.

5/27/12 2:08pm

Looking for summing up this awful condition, an image comes to mind. Icarus staring defiantly at the sun. He jumps up to fly but realizes he only has one wing. Furious, he rips his one wing off. "I am vainglorious & godlike, but I know I am trapped." He lies down, wailing.

_________________________________________

 

The manic phases are generally the most dangerous, partly because it's hard to know that you are manic because up to a point, one doesn't know that anything is wrong due to how much fun it seems to be; in retrospect, bad judgment, indulgence in bad behaviour for the fun of it, lots of drinking, artistic ecstasy (more than usual), explosive anger, spending sprees, etc. etc., grandiosity, lots of energy, hyper-sexuality. Easy to lose friends & jobs while manic. Kinda like cocaine.

 

But the depression is the part that can be debilitating. Every night I tell myself, I'll feel better tomorrow & get some work done. Many days just a waste. Nothing seems to be worth doing. Much suicidal rumination. No energy.

 

Anonymous
Alfredo
5/27/12 3:37pm

Dear Captain,

 

for me and my wife bipolar is not a negative experience: to the contrary, it is source of much creativity and inspiration. Both my wife and I have learned, over the years, to recognise our triggers. You may not be able to control Mania once it has taken hold but one can recognise triggers like high energy, no sleep, and a general overwheling brain activity. If we do something about it when this happens then we can control the Mania and prevent it from taking hold. It has happened that we have had a relapse. For example, a couple of years ago I lost many friends to suicide all in a very short period of time. This was enough to trigger the worst symptoms of my bipolar2. I became unwell and had to go temporarily on medication for a short period of time. Usually I control my bipolar2 without medication jjust like I do now. Yeet I didn't let this relapse stop me from being optimistic. You got to forgive yourself, understand that you have a seriious condition and move on. In twenty years both my wife and I have been reasonably well with only 2 relapses each. Everytime we helped each other because we understand bipolar well.

 

There are two very good medications that work in the long term and these are Lithium and Epilim. Unfortunately not everyone tollerates these drrugs but many people do. These drugs have a good track record for long term treatment and they are older, first generation, drugs. The second generation drugs are not as good with more side effects and are less realiable particularly in terms of long term treatment. For long term they are not good. My wife with bipolar one has been first on Lithium for 15 years and then switched to  Epilim and has been on this drug for many years now. She only takes ONE medication for bipolar and the rest is hard work ensuring adequate sleep, no drugs, no alcohol, a good diet, a reasonably happy and trouble free life and lots of creativity, art and reading books. The few times that I have taken medication it has been Epilim all the time and nothing else.

 

As John always says knowedge is absolutely necessary.  It is important to have enough knowledge of the beast so that we can keep it on a leash and control it. Is it possible to fully control it? Yes but as John also says it takes years. I am learning to control it and it is a struggle. If I have had 2 relapses in 20 years that is not the end of the world and it does not prevent me from having a reasonably good life.

 

Yes, bipolar is serious and it can be terrible but it does not need to be if we learn strategies. There are many other conditions that are just as bad. Most peoople on Earth have some sort of mental or physical disorder: cancer, high blood pressure, respiratory and heart problems, diabetes, and so on. The list is endless. These other condition also impact on emotions, feelings and the quality of life. But a good life and happpiness are not just present in the absence of disability or illness: to the contrary in many cases illness and disabilities can be the key to a better lifel to greater knowledge and wisdom.

 

I am currently reading a book on some indigenous people in Taiwan who have both catholic spiritual priests and missionaries and Shamans to help them. They rely on both Western medicaine, catholicism and Shamanism but, as I am reading, when it comes to mental illness they prefer the Shaman because a Shaman can often help the person with a mental illness achieve a more permanent recovery. I think it is all up to how we see the mental disorder and what kind of help we get. I don't know if John knows anything about Shamans but it wouuld be interesting if he wrote something about how honest and respectable Shamans treat mental illness. I think that it is important for us to know how other cultures tackle the problem.

 

 

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2577) >
By John McManamy, Health Guide— Last Modified: 03/06/13, First Published: 05/13/12