Sign in

or Register now

BipolarConnect.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Friday, November, 06, 2009
  • Font size
Exclusive savings on ADHD products and much, much more!  Start saving today!

The Bipolar Spectrum

John McManamy
John McManamy
Close
Author and Advocate

John McManamy is an award-winning mental health journalist and...

John McManamy

Wednesday, October 01, 2008
View All of John McManamy's Posts
The term, manic-depression, was coined by the pioneering diagnostician, Emil Kraepelin, back in the early twentieth century. There is a common misconception that manic-depression is simply the old fashioned term for bipolar disorder, but Kraepelin applied that term to plain vanilla depression, as wel...
  1. I agree with you.
    http://www.bipolar-symptoms.info/
    Wednesday, October 01, 2008 at 04:03 PM

    I agree with you. It is really hard to define clearly when we still know so little about this disorder. In any case, you must know that sometimes you will have to be your own doctor...Wink
    http://www.bipolar-symptoms.info/

    Reply
    re: I agree with you.
    John McManamy
    Wednesday, October 01, 2008 at 07:03 PM

    Definitely. And we need to know more than our doctor.

    Reply
  2. call me irresponsible
    bipolarbear
    Wednesday, October 01, 2008 at 04:37 PM

    I am a firm believer in not really caring what they call me if they can just find a combination of meds to bring me some relief. I spent several years being called schizoaffective and this still today seems a fuzzy category. Yes, I was psychotic when they saw me but once I came down from the mania, I no longer saw things. And it really seemed that some doctors seemed to think that SA was more the diagnosis to give a female and I have never been sure if I was just paranoid at the time. But in the end, I don't care if I am "really" bipolar I because this combo of meds seems to be doing okay for me.

    Reply
    re: call me irresponsible
    John McManamy
    Thursday, October 02, 2008 at 01:27 AM

    Hi, BipolarBear. The important thing is to know what's going on. Diagnostic labels can give an approximation, but sometimes they are plain wrong, which is probably why it takes so long for bipolars to get a bipolar diagnosis. We tend to get misdiagnosed with unipolar depression and put on an antidepressant which makes us worse. A spectrum approach would have doctors asking different questions - which would help get us on the right treatments, which is your point.

    Reply
  3. Amen!
    cretin
    Wednesday, October 01, 2008 at 04:42 PM

    Your ending with "Know yourself" is so apropos. This is coming from one of those nebulous bipolar NOS types. Only looking outside of the box and really keeping track of what treatments worked and which don't, did my doctor (who doesn't follow the DSM too much) and I find finally the treatment that work. It took 10 years to do so. But by knowing myself paid off. For those still on the hunt for the best treatment, keep good records of what hasn't work and what has partially worked and keep trying.

    Reply
    re: Amen!
    John McManamy
    Thursday, October 02, 2008 at 01:50 AM

    Hi, Cretin. Glad you brought up NOS. Imagine if NOS applied to other areas, such as law. Imagine being charged with "Assault NOS." You wouldn't know whether you were facing 20 years or community service. "Bipolar NOS" can apply to someone who is up all the time as well as someone who is down all the time. How crazy is that? The same diagnosis for two opposite states.

     

    To readers: NOS (not otherwise specified) is used in the DSM for every psychiatric illness. Thus, if your symptoms are not an exact DSM match, the psychiatrist has NOS to fall back on. True, this does add flexibility in making a diagnosis, but this type of imprecision would not be tolerated in any other field.

     

     

    Reply
  4. Untitled Comment
    Joicie
    Thursday, October 16, 2008 at 07:26 AM

    Thankyou. I can't help but write. The information you shared was great. Knowing thyself is a real hard job for some of us or probably most of us. I have a DX of bipolar, rapid-cycling. Unless there is some severe stress I cycle about 4 times a year, sometimes almost like clockwrk. When it's like that I always know in my mind that it will 'GO AWAY" at least for a while. Whwn that's coupled with divorce or illness like I just went through it's a different ball-game. I just had surgery on my back. The pain befor and after was excruciatingand I was put on painkillers which have their side effects. My symptoms went crazy, crazy, crazy. I was extremely confused and my bipolar decided to change to a weekly schedule. Help. This has been one of the worst experiences inn my whole life and i'm in my 50's.  Doctors and patients, Beware. The doctor needs to know this, medication probably needs to be adjusted, mucho extra support is needed. I've just recently come out of it but am not back to work yet. I do know my bipolar is severe but this is my experience and I wanted to share it. Thanks. Joicie

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    MissE
    Monday, January 26, 2009 at 11:19 AM

    hang in there. How long have you lived the medication game? most meds did not work for me...they made me have no emotions at all & I noticed w/age, im 31, they seem to be more predictable & after living this way for years, you kow you will come out of the down & be on a manic again...I can almost deal w/the depression, knowing Im going to feel that euphoric feeling again & w/age came a degree of control over the mania. I dont spend $$ I dont have on rediculas things anymore, usually able to talk myself out of it or know to go home & think about it for a couple of days & then usually make the right decision. I was diagnosed BP in 2004 but recently got rediagnosed as have borderline personality disorder...the mood swings still apply w/BPD rapid cycling normally but have been told Therapy is their main focus, not meds. Even when I thought i was Bipolar, which still may have b/c it coinsides w/BPD I began looking at the brighter side...its kinda a blessing to feel such intense emotions that most ppl never experience in their life....yes it can be draining at times but w/the control Ive gained over the years, maybe just from wisdom or trial & error....Id much rather feel the emotions life has to offer than feel nothing, numb, like a zombie inwhich meds can induce...I felt like I was just existing. So if BP doesnt put you in harmful situations anymore like it used to & you have some sort of control & can almost calculate when they are coming & how long they last....maybe its livable w/o all the medication games & side effects & let downs hoping this pill will be the one & when its not...its heart breaking. My bf says my intense, direct emotions are something to be admired, I just need to learn to chanel them in a more positive manner...w/Borderline personality disorder there is a dif type of therapy aimed @learning coping skills to live more efficent, not like other therapy ive tried that didnt work where you just talk about your past & get no feed back. I dont think rehashing your past w/o some sort of feed back is pointless...but Maybe read about BPD just incase you really arent BP....as do all mental disorders, most symptoms are almost identical & until recently most doctors didnt think it was a real disorder...justa suggestion, good luck!! Sorry to ramble on, I just hope I can help others on this site as they have helped me...outside opinions make you look in a direction you might not have otherwise.

    Reply
    re: re: Untitled Comment
    MissE
    Monday, January 26, 2009 at 11:32 AM

    ps...

    Have you tried Abilify? I know everyones different but for me it was amazing, I just felt normal not like I was on meds but unless you have insurance it is VERY expensive $425/mos for a 30 day supply....minimal side effects for me & felt better after the 3rd pill, lessened depression & made my anxiety practically non existant. again good luck

    Reply
  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Thank you for your input
  • Save
  • RSS
  • Report Abuse

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

View all questions (1666) >