Sign in

or Register now

BipolarConnect.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Wednesday, November, 25, 2009
  • Font size
Exclusive savings on ADHD products and much, much more!  Start saving today!

Is My Depression Really Bipolar?

John McManamy
John McManamy
Close
Author and Advocate

John McManamy is an award-winning mental health journalist and...

John McManamy

Friday, October 02, 2009
View All of John McManamy's Posts
Ticadoo writes:"[My best friend] and my husband have told me I need to be checked for bipolar, but everything I've read, up until finding your site, showed I did not have all the symptoms, which is the mania - having ups. I never have those."Thank you for writing, Ticadoo. You have raised what I woul...
  1. Untitled Comment
    tabby
    Saturday, October 03, 2009 at 04:37 PM

    Very interesting topic post John and eerily sorta coincidental, to me anyway

     

    See... I've had 3 full on High Mixed Manic Episodes in my life and I learned during my last one that this alone gave me Bipolar I designation.  All the other symptoms and qualifying criteria kinda shored it up EXCEPT for 1 thing I was told at the time.... my primary episodes that cause me the most dysfunction are depressive.  So, I was given my first Bipolar diagnosis of Bipolar II with Mixed Features.  That was in 2006.

     

    Prior to that I had always been diagnosed with Recurring Moderate to Severe Major Depression - Unipolar.  I had also always been treated with standard anti-depressants along with a few anti-anxiety meds and only twice did I get anti-psychotics.  The ADs did everything BUT what they were supposed to do and worse.

     

    I say this post is coincidental to me, at the moment, because I've had 4 psychiatrists since that 1 hospital psychiatrist in 2006 each designate me on either the I or the II level of the spectrum (depending on how I presented).  All agreed I have psychotic features and mixed features.

     

    I've even had 3 separate therapists all agree.  Yet, the one therapist I'm seeing now absolutely refuses to believe the diagnosis.

     

    I've seen her, off and on, since 1993.  There have been years that I saw no therapist or psychiatrist and there have been some years where I saw therapists but not her.  Still, I've seen her randomly since 1993.

     

    Today, she and I got into yet another argument over the Bipolar.  I mentioned how my GP and the Pdocs all believed it being Bipolar and how I needed my GP to prescribe me something now that I've lost my last Pdoc.  She got all up in arms, so to speak, once again that I did not have Bipolar.  I had Recurring Major Depression and perhaps some rapid cycling of the depression due to having 4 severe suicidal episodes in a 12 month period... but absolutely no Bipolar.

     

    See, I haven't had a full on Manic episode while being treated with her and since I've only had hypomanic episodes that she does not recognize as such.... she is adamant that it is solely unipolar depression.  My hypomanic episodes?  She views them as my having come out of unipolar depression and feeling better about everything to a greater degree.  In that I function highly during these episodes... she sees no hypomania.

     

    So... is it Bipolar or is it just unipolar depression?

     

    All I know is I'm depressed and I want help and I don't much care how it's labelled and I told her so quite flatly.

     

    Between you and I, I know what I know is what I know... it's Bipolar cause when I was diagnosed and being told how and why I fit the diagnosis.... something deep inside just... clicked as being true.  I'd never had that before...

     

     

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    John McManamy
    Monday, October 05, 2009 at 10:38 PM

    Hey, Tabby. I read you loud and clear.

    Reply
    re: re: Untitled Comment
    tabby
    Tuesday, October 06, 2009 at 09:41 AM

    sorry...Embarassed just frustrated with the psychiatric world and well... your post just kinda "triggered" some venting. 

     

    I want to scream "Don't care what you label me any longer... just help me and don't argue about it.  I know it's not a exact science and each individual has their own interpretation of the DSM manual for Jimmy Cricket's sake.  Yet when I come to you, for help do not argue over what my label is on my can... just help me, ya know?" Yell

     

    Reply
  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Thank you for your input
  • Save
  • RSS
  • Report Abuse

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

View all questions (1721) >