Sign in

or Register now

BipolarConnect.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Thursday, November, 26, 2009
  • Font size
Exclusive savings on ADHD products and much, much more!  Start saving today!

A Mental Illness Awareness Week Special - A Brief History of Mental Illness

John McManamy
John McManamy
Close
Author and Advocate

John McManamy is an award-winning mental health journalist and...

John McManamy

Thursday, October 08, 2009
View All of John McManamy's Posts
This week is Mental Illness Awareness Week. Okay, let’s get aware. Following is a random traverse through history:   790,000 BC, give or take a few years - Discovery of fire. Anyone crazy enough to take a burning tree into their cave and find a practical application had to have been deal...
  1. Untitled Comment
    sunnyday1982
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 05:09 PM

    Those dumb little commercials on tv don't make people pay attention, heck, I ignore them too, and people who aren't affected by by mental illness aren't going to go to support groups (which don't help, b/c, personally I don't like to listen to people b*tch and moan & I have bipolar disorder myself) This isn't going to TEACH or MAKE anyone more aware of anything, IMHO...people don't want to learn about what they're afraid of (mentally ill)...interesting facts though... Have a nice day, folks :)

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    John McManamy
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 10:02 PM

    Hi, Sunnyday. I agree that the commercials are dumb. But there is no question that they and the Prozac culture brought the taboo topic of depression out into the open - which is a very healthy development. You will note that further down I bring out the negative aspects of drug industry marketing.

     

    Re support groups - the whiners and complainers there are a major problem. But I do encourage everyone to attend at least 3 times, as people can get a lot out of them.

     

    Reply
  2. Untitled Comment
    Dore'
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 05:10 PM

    Very interesting info. We've come a long way baby!!Laughing

    Reply
  3. Untitled Comment
    A Visitor
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 06:59 PM

    So ...

    It took someone with bipolar disorder to discover the use of fire,
    a known fact, apparantly.
    Christopher Colombus had bipolar disorder and discovered the Americas,
    Michelangelo had bipolar disorder and so painted the Sistine Chapel, and
    Isaac Newton had bipolar disorder and gave us modern mechanics and physical principles.

    This blog and definitely titled toward the silly side lately.

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    John McManamy
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 09:53 PM

    Hey, Visitor. The creativity and productivity connection to bipolar is well-established. Kay Jamison and Nancy Andreassen have written books on the topic. Columbus, Michaelangelo, and Newton have been specifically brought up by respected commentators. As for the discovery of fire, you're forgetting - I was there.

     

    Proud to be silly ...

    Reply
    re: re: Untitled Comment
    A Visitor
    Friday, October 09, 2009 at 10:58 AM

    Hey John,

    It's just that some people I'ved read are concerned there is more emphasis on a link between creatitity and bipolar disorder than is warranted. It seems to be true for certain individuals but it's not  the general case. I've read this being called bipolar chic.

    As for the historical figures you mention, could you mention the commentators who have brought them up specifically as examples of bipolar creativity. I may like to read more by them sometime.

    Thanks and cheers.

    Reply
    re: re: re: Untitled Comment
    John McManamy
    Friday, October 09, 2009 at 12:45 PM

    Hi, Visitor. The link is warranted. We are an amazingly creative lot - and I don't just mean in an artsy sense. We tend to be popping with thoughts and ideas. Bipolar is a terrible illness, but our awareness of our gifts can turn into a tremendous advantage once we get our illness under control and we learn to nurture our creative spark rather than play with fire. Then we are kicking butt rather than whining and complaining victims. One small example, if we lose sleep while we are in a creative tear then we are playing with fire, and there is usually all hell to pay. I know - it used to happen to me. So leading a highly-disciplined life is crucial.

     

    This is an article I wrote on creativity: http://www.mcmanweb.com/creativity.html

     

    This is a blog I wrote on bipolar chic: http://knowledgeisnecessity.blogspot.com/2009/01/is-bipolar-cool.html

    Reply
  4. Untitled Comment
    Galaxy
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 07:59 PM
    I found this very interesting, shocking and entertaining all in the same article, but concerned by the implication of the future looking bleak,as yiu mentioned John, at a time when research is peaking in terms of treatments, yet resources to deliver them are dwindling, yet and mental illness is on the increase apparently or is it just being picked up more or diagnosed more rathern actually increasing. Is this why it is increasing ? because good quality services have been cut and people are left struggling for longer or left to "community care" which is idealistic but ineffective inpractice What Community care is left ? I requested help agreed to see a councillor back in July.It is now October, I am feeling mch better throigh my onw efforts and time , yet I am still on the referral list. Help is not there when it is most needed when people feel at their worst in my experience twice. It was the same 7 years ago. I canacelled the counsellor many months after a bad breakdown once I had picked up. help is always too late unless you need sectioning. Peopel should not reach this level of crisis. Where are the Crisis Action Teams ! or early intervention teams. Where and When do they act or intervene ? I should like to know. What do they prevent by any early intervention. I ca see no evidence of this. They sit in some call centre and bat off calls until peopel are at their worst and at breaking ppoint or at risk to self or others. They are a waste of money in my opinion. I rememer when Mental Illness Support Teams would come to the house when called for a relative or partner with serious mental illness. This service was wiped out, Now you can not even get a GP to take concerns seriously out of hours, if someone is already known to be attached to the Community Mental Health Teams. They would rather they dealt with a enqury the nexty day, so what use is the out of hours service either. No one wants to be troubled out of hours yet they are paid extra for this and this is their job !!!
    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    John McManamy
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 10:08 PM

    Hi, Galaxy. Absolutely. What drives a lot of my writing these days is the fact that in so many ways we are on our own. We all have to help each other pick up the necessary skills so that we can help ourselves. It's not really a solution, but for many of us it's all we have.

    Reply
  5. Untitled Comment
    Galaxy
    Thursday, October 08, 2009 at 08:00 PM
    I found this very interesting, shocking and entertaining all in the same article, but concerned by the implication of the future looking bleak,as yiu mentioned John, at a time when research is peaking in terms of treatments, yet resources to deliver them are dwindling, yet and mental illness is on the increase apparently or is it just being picked up more or diagnosed more rathern actually increasing. Is this why it is increasing ? because good quality services have been cut and people are left struggling for longer or left to "community care" which is idealistic but ineffective inpractice What Community care is left ? I requested help agreed to see a councillor back in July.It is now October, I am feeling mch better throigh my onw efforts and time , yet I am still on the referral list. Help is not there when it is most needed when people feel at their worst in my experience twice. It was the same 7 years ago. I canacelled the counsellor many months after a bad breakdown once I had picked up. help is always too late unless you need sectioning. Peopel should not reach this level of crisis. Where are the Crisis Action Teams ! or early intervention teams. Where and When do they act or intervene ? I should like to know. What do they prevent by any early intervention. I ca see no evidence of this. They sit in some call centre and bat off calls until peopel are at their worst and at breaking ppoint or at risk to self or others. They are a waste of money in my opinion. I rememer when Mental Illness Support Teams would come to the house when called for a relative or partner with serious mental illness. This service was wiped out, Now you can not even get a GP to take concerns seriously out of hours, if someone is already known to be attached to the Community Mental Health Teams. They would rather they dealt with a enqury the nexty day, so what use is the out of hours service either. No one wants to be troubled out of hours yet they are paid extra for this and this is their job !!!
    Reply
  6. Thankfulness
    tls
    Friday, October 09, 2009 at 07:41 AM

    Everyone is talking about mindful this and mindful that but I subscribe to the thankful this and thankful that.  I am thankful I never had to have ECT.  I am thankful that my numerous suicide attempts were unsuccessful.  I am thankful that four meds treat two disorders and I can function in the real world most of the time.  I am thankful that I've only be in psych ward twice.  I am thankful that my ex-husband recognized something was wrong and encouraged me to get the help I needed.  I am thankful that I never harmed someone else while in a cycle.  Wait, I can't say that.  I am thankful that I never physically harmed someone esle while in a cycle - I've hurt a lot of people.  I am thankful I wasn't locked up and had a hole drilled in my head.  I'm thankful that drug and alcohol addiction didn't destroy me.  I am thankful for my pscy service dog who get's me up in the morning and keeps me calm throughout the day.  I am thankful that I have had two fantastic therapists in my life even though I can't find a decent one now (LOL).  I am thankful that NYS recognizes the importance of mental health and my insurance covers treatment and therapy at the same co-pay as medical treatment.  I am thankful for people who sit on hotlines 24-hours a day (like my sister) and help people and listen when all you need to do is talk and send out a crises team when necessary.  I am thankful there are two mental health wards in local hospitals within 20 miles of me.  I could go on and on.  Yes, there are things in society that frustrate me and there are things about me that are frustrating and sometimes I want to change a behavior that is detremintal but I don't know how or I can't get the motivation to do so.  BUT - I am thankful to be alive and watch the sun rise and hear the birds and know that it may not be a perfect world but it's not too bad.  I recently did a talk in my department of a large research univsersity and I self-disclosed and introduced my dog and people I work with and barely know started talking to me about their own problems with mental health and problems they have had with family members.  Education and empathy are important and sum up and finish here - thank you John for continuing to educate us and I too love being silly even when it annoys my brother:)

    Reply
    re: Thankfulness
    John McManamy
    Friday, October 09, 2009 at 12:54 PM

    Hi, Tis. I'm thankful for readers like you. :)

    Reply
    re: Thankfulness
    SweetLynnie
    Saturday, October 24, 2009 at 12:33 AM
    I am thankful for your comments, too. I also feel blessed with all the gifts that God has given me, and know that I would not be the special, creative person I am if I weren't like my mother, who was bipolar. I feel that God has a purpose for my life, and that I have a great capacity to love, which is my most important avocation. To love God with all my heart and soul and being, and to love my neighbor as myself (I could do better with the last one, but I'm a work in progress, progress, rather than perfection, as they say). Thank you for sharing from the heart. SweetLynnie
    Reply
  7. Untitled Comment
    augmenting with gentleness
    Saturday, October 10, 2009 at 12:16 PM

    A tour de force, combining both bipolar brilliance and bipolar managed well enough for brevity.  So what am I doing complaining about something left out?  Nevertheless, NAMI, National Alliance on Mental Illness deserves a mention, at least in the comments, where the mentally interesting and their families have come together to do what the Pharma/Medica/Therapeutic Industrial Complex could not: turn the focus from cure to recovery.  The P/M/T Complex has no stake in admitting that they cannot cure.  (And the tour de force suggests that the evolutionary wisdom of the species has a stake in preserving the existence of the mentally interesting, against the best efforts of the industry to eliminate us.) 

     

    I attended my first NAMI-sponsored P2P (Peer To Peer) class this week, and heard for the first time what I have been saying to my caregivers for the last year, that the experience of treatment itself includes trauma.  Well, doh!  It took me a year and a half to figure it out.  The therapist who hung up on me when I called to ask whether I needed to be hospitalized was not the therapist who could help me deal with the flashbacks I keep having of that phone call.  NAMI.org is thefirst stop  for people with mental illness and their families for support from others who have been there.

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    John McManamy
    Saturday, October 10, 2009 at 02:51 PM

    Hi, Augmenting. I'm very glad you brought this up. I made a very brief reference to the recovery movement in my piece, but I obviously should have fleshed this out. I spent 3 years leading a DBSA group in New Jersey and am on the board of NAMI San Diego. Also, I have spoken to local DBSA and NAMI groups on both the east and west coasts and love the people I have met. Both organizations do outstanding work, and the efforts of its volunteers and staff are heroic. I'm very proud of my associations with both groups. In addition, there are other organizations with strong support, education, advocacy, and recovery missions.

     

    If you check out the bottom of the page here, you will see that HealthCentral has affiliations with NAMI and DBSA. I know at HealthCentral we strongly believe that there is no substitute for learning from fellow patients (and loved ones). Clinicians bring their own expert information to the table, which we need to have regard for, but they are only one part of the equation. NAMI and DBSA believe in patients working with their clinicians, but we know that the key to recovery lies in patients (and loved ones) learning from one another.

     

    NAMI has many excellent programs, including Peer to Peer and Family to Family. DBSA's strength is its local support groups. I strongly urge readers to check these out.

    Reply
  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Thank you for your input
  • Save
  • RSS
  • Report Abuse

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

View all questions (1723) >