Thursday, May 31, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

NeuroFeedback

By G.J. Gregory Monday, June 11, 2007
In the bipolar disorder blogosphere, I’ve seen a growing buzz about a therapy method called "Neurofeedback" or "Neurotherapy".   Neurotherapy is a therapy technique that presents the user with realtime feedback on brainwave activity.  Per CNN.com’s article Biofeedback Widens Its Role In Medicine:
Through electrodes on the scalp, a device measures electrical impulses in the brain, amplifies them and then records them. These impulses are divided into different types of brain waves.  For example, in order to concentrate on a task, parts of the brain must produce more high-frequency beta waves. To relax, the brain must produce more low-frequency theta waves.  Using a program similar to a computer game (only without a joystick), people learn to control the video display by achieving the mental state that produces increases in the desired brain wave. The use of neurofeedback for psychiatric problems depends on recent understanding about these diseases - scientists understand better the electrical and chemical components of mental illness, creating opportunities for neurofeedback. Children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) use neurofeedback games to reduce theta waves and increase beta waves, increasing their attentiveness. Joel Lubar, Ph.D., a psychologist at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville, who originated neurofeedback treatment for ADHD in the 1970s, says neurofeedback can produce some of the same brain wave changes as drugs used to treat the disorder.
Per EEG.info:
Neurofeedback is direct training of brain function, by which the brain learns to function more efficiently. We observe the brain in action from moment to moment. We show that information back to the person and we reward the brain for changing its own activity to more appropriate patterns. This is a gradual learning process. It applies to any aspect of brain function that we can measure. Neurofeedback is also called EEG biofeedback, because it is based on electrical brain activity, the electroencephalogram, or EEG. Neurofeedback is training in self-regulation. It is simply biofeedback applied to the brain directly. Self-regulation is a necessary part of good brain function. Self-regulation training allows the system (the central nervous system) to function better.
As can be imagined, Neurofeedback is not without controversy.  Supporters argue that big Pharma will do anything they can to discredit the therapy.  Detractors take a "junk science" approach.  Per Wikipedia.org:
Neurofeedback is being used as an addition to many psychotherapists' practices as a boost to a sagging 'talk-therapy' practice. Since in most states there are no licensing requirements, therapists who have little knowledge of physiology or computer technology can use the equipment with little oversight. The client can be hooked up and the computer program does the training with little effort on the therapist's part. It adds a high-tech effect to the session and makes the whole procedure seem more credible.

In the Gravelle case in Huron, Ohio, 11 adoptive children were given thousands of hours of neurofeedback training at a great cost to the county with seemingly little improvement in their conditions. The criticism is that neurotherapy was given to them for an array of different problems simply because the funds were so easily available.

As with any form of treatment or therapy in bipolar disorder you will have supporters and detractors.  I would be very much interested in the BipolarConnect community’s take on this.  Have you used Neurofeedback?  Know anyone who has?  Any feedback, pro or con?  Leave a comment and let us know! 
Another Roller Coaster Ride
Anonymous
Gianna
6/12/07 8:22am
I've had extremely good results with neurofeedback. I was off my anti-depressant in 5 weeks and have had no more hypomania or mania since starting. (5 years now) I've also come off more than half my meds and intend to come off all of them. (I also use diet and nutrition to further heal my brain--but neurofeedback is what got me headed in this direction.)

As G.J. points out there is controversy and it is justified. Anyway can set up shop. But with a little research it's possible to find good people who have been properly trained. EEG.info--the site G.J. gets some of his information from is a reputable site, but of course I can't speak for every provider they recommend either.

My doctor, when I ask him for referrals for friends across the country recommends that we ask the practicing doctor how many years they have practiced (my doctor recommends at least 5) and also if bipolar is a specialty for them. Our brains are unique!
6/12/07 10:07pm
Gianna,

I would be most interested in your experience and if you could share some specific names of phychiatrists and therapiest/treatments. I am not sure how to get in touch with you or how to tell you how to get in touch with me, but if you know how and are willing to share, PLEASE let me know.

Gratefully,
Mom of BPD young woman
Anonymous
Gianna
6/12/07 11:31pm
Hi Mother of BPD,
I'm really not sure if I can be of help, but if you like you can email me if GJ, author of this article will give you my email address. GJ, could you do that for me...I imagine you have both our email addresses.

I'm happy to talk to you and perhaps help you find someone, but I can't necessarily vouch for anyone I or my doctor doesn't know well. He does know a lot of people and may be able to give a good referral depending on where you live. He goes to worldwide conferences all the time.

Also...you can look at my blog...that may turn you on or off...I don't know. I'm going a natural route.

http://bipolarblast.blogspot.com/

be well,
Gianna
6/12/07 10:25am
No direct readout ... but feel the difference ... with meditation ?
Anonymous
Mom of BPD young woman
6/12/07 9:45pm
I happened upon this post as I have a 28 yr old daughter who has been diagnosed bi-polar about 4 yrs ago and through the usual "mood stabilizers" plus dopamine or seratonin or both, inhibitors is still just in an awful state and feeling hopeless. Through a former therapist of mine in Arizona I heard about Brain State Technologies. Neuro feedback has been around with various modalitites of therapy over the past 10-12 yrs. I personally have done some of them. I am paying for my dtr. to do a series of the brain state technologies sessions because the protocol is individualized and adaptable. This is possible because of the speed of computing for real time assessment as I understand it. Finally there are some real life excellent PhD psychotherpists who have been using it on addictions, obsessive compulsive disorder, phobias and other things with good to excellent results. Balancing the brain is the key. The drugs may be still necessary, but I have talked with people who have been able to cut back and cut out some of the Rx's. My dtr has an eating disorder already and some of the most commonly prescribed med for bipolar cause weight gain and can even induce type II diabetes. Its worth a try and then some to "re-train" the brain.
6/12/07 11:12pm
Thanks all for your comments!

Gianna - I appreciate you sharing your experience. From posts on your blog, http://bipolarblast.blogspot.com/ I know you have experience in this. Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to comment and share your knowledge.

Nick - We all hold a lot of potential within our own minds, don't we? I don't know that we're all able to use it as we would like to, but that's the subect of a future post I'm working up.

Mom of BPD Young Woman - Thanks so much for stopping by and leaving a comment. More real life experience, thanks for sharing that.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2514) >
By G.J. Gregory— Last Modified: 10/26/11, First Published: 06/11/07