Thursday, May 31, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

The HCL-32 Test: Distinguishing Major Depression from Bipolar Disorder

By G.J. Gregory Monday, March 26, 2007
As many of us know, the diagnosis of bipolar disorder can be a difficult and inexact process.  It is especially difficult to accurately distinguish between depression and bipolar disorder.  As some of us have experienced, the effects of prescribing anti-depressants to individuals with bipolar disorder can be counterproductive.   Researchers believe they have developed a simple test to distinguish between some forms of bipolar disorder and depression. Type II bipolar disorder is easily confused with depression, as manic episodes in this condition are not very marked.  For this reason, individuals with this condition are often diagnosed with depression.

A simple test of 32 questions called the HCL-32 test has been developed to help distinguish major depression from bipolar disorder. The study documenting this is published in the Journal of Affective Disorders.

According to the study, this test was able to identify more than 80 percent of patients with bipolar disorder. Although this test was not designed to distinguish between types I and II, this diagnosis should be easier to make given patient data and history.

I have heard that an on-line test will be developed soon.  In the meantime, here are the main questions used in the HCL-32:

Please try to remember a period when you were in a "high" state (while not using drugs or alcohol). In such a state:
  1. I need less sleep
  2. I feel more energetic and more active
  3. I am more self-confident
  4. I enjoy my work more
  5. I am more sociable (make more phone calls, go out more)
  6. I want to travel and/or do travel more
  7. I tend to drive faster or take more risks when driving
  8. I spend more money/too much money
  9. I take more risks in my daily life (in my work and/or other activities)
  10. I am physically more active (sport etc.)
  11. I plan more activities or projects. 
  12. I have more ideas, I am more creative
  13. I am less shy or inhibited 
  14. I wear more colorful and more extravagant clothes/make-up
  15. I want to meet or actually do meet more people
  16. I am more interested in sex, and/or have increased sexual desire
  17. I am more flirtatious and/or am more sexually active
  18. I talk more
  19. I think faster
  20. I make more jokes or puns when I am talking
  21. I am more easily distracted
  22. I engage in lots of new things
  23. My thoughts jump from topic to topic
  24. I do things more quickly and/or more easily
  25. I am more impatient and/or get irritable more easily
  26. I can be exhausting or irritating for others 
  27. I get into more quarrels
  28. My mood is higher, more optimistic
  29. I drink more coffee
  30. I smoke more cigarettes
  31. I drink more alcohol
  32. I take more drugs (sedatives, anti-anxiety pills, stimulants)
There’s a little more to the test than this, and I haven’t found information on actually scoring the test.  But looking this over it’s obviously thorough enough to cut to the core.

By the way, I took this test - does anyone else score 100%?




Caring for a Child With Bipolar Disorder: Setting an Example
Anonymous
Jane
3/27/07 7:34pm
I've only been manic 3 times & 1 of those was considered  depressed  anxiety, or something like that.  But the 2 times I was manic, yes, I exhibited all 32 qualities.
Being put on Prozac for depression is what caused me to become manic. I didn't figure this out for at least 7 years or so.
3/27/07 10:56pm
Jane - those anti-depressants really send me into orbit.  The times I was on them I got manic every time.  It was pretty bad.

Thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment!
Anonymous
Anonymous
4/27/07 5:06am

hi,


i've noticed your name popping up on a few of the depression websites i've been looking at. one of my friends prompted me to look them up and try some of the tests, and all of them are pointing to some form of moderate or severe depression, although a councellor i was seeing for the last couple of months has not said anything about it. do you have any advice for what i should do from here?


if so, please drop me a line if you have a free moment:


meow_kitty56@hotmail.com


thankyou

4/27/07 3:26pm

Thanks for your comment.  I have a hard time giving advice, I’m not a medical professional, I’m just a guy with bipolar disorder, who raised a child with bipolar disorder.  I have suffered from depression, some significant depressions, so I do have some experience.

 

It sounds like you haven’t gotten your counselor’s attention, or they don’t feel it’s severe enough to worry about.  If you think you need more help, don’t hesitate to ask for a referral.  You may have to ask your primary care physician for one, many insurance companies will require it.  If you think you can kick the depression yourself, good for you.  It may make you stronger.  But there are so many options today for dealing with depression don’t hesitate to pursue pharmacological help if deemed appropriate by your medical professional.  There is no need to suffer any more than necessary.

 

Thanks again for your comment. 

Anonymous
Wendell Lewis
7/19/08 5:32pm

Except for smoking more cigarettes,I answered all the questions YES.

Anonymous
leah
5/28/09 6:57pm

What does 17/32 mean?

Anonymous
Anonymous
12/30/09 5:44am

HI, According to this report

the original cut off point of 14 is suggested for bipolar II disorder

Ref

http://opus.bath.ac.uk/17444/

 

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2514) >
By G.J. Gregory— Last Modified: 10/26/11, First Published: 03/26/07