Thursday, May 31, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

My thought on genetics.

By bipolarbear Wednesday, September 24, 2008

I am pretty sure that scientists do not believe that bipolar disorder is strictly genetic. They have done studies of twins where one twin had bp and the other did not. They scanned the twins' brains and observed differences before such differences could be credited to medications. So of course there are other factors, hormones, neurons, the electrical system of the brain, the structure of the brain, environmental factors and of course trama/stress (how else to explain post traumatic stress disorder?)...my thoughts are cheers to the researchers who are trying to figure this out! 

Bipolar relationships
9/24/08 5:05pm

 

 

Dear Bipolarbear,

 

so you try to tell me that scientists, health professionals and experts are completely honest and there is no reason to worry about anything? Let's welcome research with open arms no matter what dangers are ahead?

 

I wish I could include here the hundreds of emails that I received from members of BipolarConnect who need congitive therapy and cannot afford it. I wish that I could send the many emails of how doctors give up on patients and how family rejects sufferers. Just in the past two days I got such emails. So desperate was a woman that she had to improvise and offer some cognitive therapy to a person with bipolar who responded well and she writes how insensitive, unprofessional and cruel some people are. How the focus is all on medication and the attempt to FIX the person who has become an illness itself.

 

You see the danger is not in the research itself it is in the people who use such research findings often with hidden agendas to make more profits. This is what we have to be careful about. Mental illness is also a business that makes many people very wealthy so I would say that what you say is nice and very heartfelt but does it really apply in our corrupted world? I am not so sure. If people were genuine and honest I would agree with you.

 

 

For example an honest society would seriously do research on medication interaction: how doea lithium react with such other drug? Yet this is not dones. Too expensive and to much of a burden on profit. So it is not done. This is the sign of an irresponsible society after profit not people's interest as well.

 

 

It is not the research and not the scientist who are the problem. Scientists often do have good intentions. But these intentions are picked up by powerful people who have dollar signs in their eyes. Wink Also look at how many reply you got from your post. Not as many as I did. This says something I think.

 

Alfredo

 

You have a nice day now...and keep writing by speaking out we learn and healp each other.

9/24/08 8:31pm

Hi. I just wanted to share with you that I am a twin and my twin brother also has Bipolar Disorder, as well as our father.

10/ 1/08 2:03pm

Thanks for talking to me. I read about this study in a book called Surviving Manic Depression by Fuller and Knable, but apparently it is famous. 70% of the ientical twin pairs, both had bp. The rate for fraternal twins was less. So the question is why did 30% of the identical twins not develop the disease? Environment, stress response? Interesting, huh?

10/ 4/08 6:49am

That is very interesting. My twin brother and I grew up hard times with an emotionally unstable mother. Through all of our troubled childhood and through our teenage yrs., we sought comfort in each other. Both he and I suffered through depression silently as teenagers, but when we faced adult-hood, we knew that something was wrong.

Two weeks after I got married, I got diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder(2005).

My twin brother finished serving his country, and was diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder in 2006. I do feel that Bipolar Disorder is both genetic, and also has a lot to do with the type of environment that a person is raised in.

 

 

9/25/08 7:07am

Genetics must play some role in it because every male on my father's side has had some type of mood disorder.  All were raised in different environments.  Unfortunately in the past, most of them were raised in an abusive home with a male figurehead who suffered from it.

 

My son is the first to actually get treatment for it.  He is also the first to be raised in a non-abusive home.  My husband doesn't have any type of emotional/anger type problems.

 

It's weird that it's only the boys in my family from my dad's side.  The girls suffer from periodic depression but not bipolar.

Anonymous
Denise
9/25/08 10:54am

Hi, I just want to say that I truly believe that it is genetic to a certain extent. My father was an alcoholic, which caused in part his suicide, and I believe now after being diganoised with BP 1&2 myself that he also was. I remember his Manic sides, and his lows too, even as a child. Now back to the question, both of my sons were diagnoised as ADHD. I see signs of it in my 5yr. old grandson also. I also suffer from OCD, and anxiety. I have found that as long as I take my meds, it is for the most part controlled. I  have wondered if ADHD is just a different name for the same thing? The strange part is neither one of my sisters have any of these disorders. Oh and btw,I am a 46 yr. old female, so I'm not sure it is a gender issue.

10/ 1/08 2:14pm

I did not want to imply that bp is not in part or in main genetic. My dad and brother had bp. My mom has had some depressions. My aunt was diagnosed with schizophrenia back in the 60s but I will never know for sure about that as they often labelled bipolar symptoms schizophrenia back then. Alcoholism is in my family as well. Still it is not a broken leg, it is very complicated to deal with the mind and feelings...and I am going to continue to believe that scientific research holds some of the answers for the following generations.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2514) >
By bipolarbear— Last Modified: 12/23/10, First Published: 09/24/08