Sunday, February 12, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

Forcing Mental Health Patients to Take Medication Is Not the Answer

In a September 19th New York Times article, Benedict Carey writes about the recent death of Dr. Wayne S. Fenton, a psychiatrist who was killed on Sunday, September 3, by a schizophrenic patient. The issue Carey brings up is whether or not severely disturbed patients should be forced to take their m...
Anonymous
Marie
9/27/06 2:14pm
Where I worked previously (outpatient MH clinic) we had patients who were primarily Paranoid Schizophrenics that from time to time wouldn't come in as scheduled for their shots. Our Crisis Manager would then go to the local Magistrate and have a "Pick Up" order issued for a deputy to find the patient, bring them to the clinic in a squad car, stand by while the patient received their shot (sometimes very unwillingly), and then take the patient home. Sometimes the patient wasn't a Paranoid Schizophrenic and if they were, they weren't always dangerous or on the verge of danger. Sometimes, the family or community would call the clinic and request. Also, by forcing whether legally or by harrassment into a hospital by a provider or Pdoc - thus forcing them to take medication, isn't always so good either. That almost happened to me with threat of removing my child. It didn't but, came too close for my comfort. I didn't appreciate the "pressure" being applied by my therapist and Pdoc and I'm BP II. Marie
Anonymous
Lynne Taetzsch
9/28/06 8:33am
Marie, Thanks for your input on this topic. We need to protect the civil rights of mental patients, not treat them as criminals. I'm sorry to hear you almost faced this forced medication yourself. Lynne
Anonymous
Michelle
5/16/09 7:03pm

I am emotionally torn on the matter. I don't, personally, practice allopathic healthcare and thus would consider being forced to do so against my rights. So on the one hand, I think that we shouldn't be forcing medical treatments on others ..lest my own rights be taken away for healthcare choices. While at the same time, I have 2 bipolar people in my life (an ex and my son) and wish they were doing SOMETHING for their disorders. Natural, conventional.. any treatment really. But their reasoning is always that they love the anger they feel.

 

Great. They love anger. And this is where I tend to WANT them to be forced to do something.   Like I said.. torn.

4/30/10 7:22pm

I have a bipolar son, 25, who went off his meds because he had some side effects and was reading scary things on the  Internet. That was 6 months ago, and it's been 6 months of hell for us (his parents). He is not violent but became so psychotic/manic, we didn't even know our own son anymore. He refused treatment and his condition would have deteriorated furhter if the hospital did not interfere with a court order for a commitment and medications--orally or by injection if refused. It's been 45 days now on oral medications and he is slowly improving. He could not have functioned in society and was at risk to himself because he was so illogical and irrational. Thank goodness for these laws. 

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2482) >