Thursday, May 31, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

Wednesday, January 07, 2009 Clare Hutcheon asks

Q: i think my sister has bipolar but cant see it

My sister has turned her back on all the family, she has attacked my mum twice, shes abusive, jumpy, obsessive, spends like it going out of fashion, erratic sometimes, just everything.

But the one thing she always says is "THERES NOTHING WRONG WITH ME, ITS EVERYONE ELSE".

Shes currently living with her partner and hes at his wits end, they also have a 2year old in the house, which he is repeating what theyre saying to on another.

He has tried doctors, mental services everything and everyone but no one will listen to him.

What can we do ?  She snaps at him from the time he walks in the door at night to the time he goes to bed.  Please help if you can, thankyou.

Answer This
Answers (3)
John McManamy, Health Guide
1/ 8/09 6:41pm

Hi, Clare. Is your sister's behavior UNUSUAL for her? Out of character?

 

Or is her most recent behavior part of a long pattern?

 

There are no pat answers here, but you have an opportunity to learn more by trying to engage your sister in a constructive dialogue. You might want to open with something like: "I know you have been under a lot of stress lately. Would you care to talk about it?"

 

Everyone is ALWAYS under stress, so you are very safe leading with this. You will come across as sympathetic rather than judgmental. Everyone needs someone to talk to, and you are offering her that opportunity. If your sister feels safe, she is likely to open up to you rather than be defensive.

 

You will probably find that whether there is a mental illness or not that some kind of personal stress was the trigger - family worries, financial worries, workplace worries, and so on. Even normal people fall apart under the strain. Those of us with a genetic vulnerabilty predictably go into an episode.

 

If she is undergoing an episode and is too far into it, rational conversation is impossible, and you will probably need to back off for the time being, and keep your fingers crossed. But active engagement is often a good way to bring a person down from an episode - at least to the point where they can take stock and figure out where to go from there.

 

If she does acknowledge stress, then you can start to ask leading questions. Work? Family? Don't be judgmental. Let her vent.Keep encouraging her to talk.

 

It's okay for someone to admit to stress. There's no stigma involved in stress. There's no blot on a person's character. As she opens up, you will have a lot more info to go on. Just stress? Possibly bipolar? Perhaps bipolar triggered by stress? Something else?

 

Keep in mind, your sister is likely to regard it as a breach of trust if you were to prematurely suggest she seek help. Her reaction: Here I am, I opened up to you, and you think I'm crazy.

 

This is actually a very rational thought, so you need to tread very carefully. But first you need to work on establishing a dialogue.

 

Good luck and please keep checking in ...

Reply
1/ 8/09 9:05am

Sounds like she has symptoms , get the download of the symptoms and print it , give it to her and acopy to her partner , then leave it up to them to get treatment. She will sure check it out once her partner decides has had enough of this rollercoaster ride , that's the wake up call she needs.

I also know someone who has major symptoms but refuses to see any fault in himself.

We are gonna try tricking him into getting a blood test for lithium levels and once we get those results will confront him.

Reply
1/15/09 3:58pm

I am not a doctor.. but I think that if you want to help your sister everyone should pull together and have an intervention..I am 27 years old and recently was diagnosed with bipolar2 disorder..I have recently started treatment..tell your sister that you are worried..alot of people are in denial because they do not want to feel as though they are crazy..millions of people have bipolar..once treated properly you can live a normal life..I hit rock bottom and new that if I did not see someone that I would lose my fiance...my life would fall apart..your sister is in denial..it may take patience and time to get her help..all you can do is be there for her... I put my fiance through hell and back and he stuck by me..that is the most important thing..

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (2514) >
By Clare Hutcheon— Last Modified: 10/26/11, First Published: 01/07/09