Thursday, May 31, 2012
Just Diagnosed with Cancer? Chat with Experts

Wednesday, August 19, 2009 ONE OR TWO asks

Q: SHOULD I NAVE A BILATERAL?

I HAVE HAD TWO LUMPECTOMIES ON MY LEFT BREAST.  MY DOCTOR SAYS NOW I NEED A MASTECTOMY.  I HAVE A FEW SMALL SPOTS IN MY RIGHT BREAST THAT NEED TO BE WATCHED CAREFULLY.  I AM LARGE BREASTED.  DO I GO AHEAD AND HAVE A BILATERAL SINCE I HAD THE OTHER TWO SURGERIES 2 YEARS APART?  I AM 65 YEARS OLD.

Answer This
Answers (5)
PJ Hamel, Health Guide
8/19/09 12:29pm

Hi - It's a tough decision, isn't it? Please read our post on deciding to have a double mastectomy - it might help you make up your mind. You'd probably want to consider reconstruction; having a double mastectomy might allow you to get more even results. But then, a double plus reconstruction is fairly aggressive surgery... I'm sorry I can't be more help to you, but in the end only you can make this decision; it's your body, and you need to be comfortable in it. Readers, could those of you who've faced this decision chime in here? Thanks- PJH

Reply
Phyllis Johnson, Health Guide
8/19/09 9:40pm

I had a single.  My doctor really didn't even mention the option of a bilateral, and I don't think I would have been ready to do it if he had.  I haven't worried too much about getting a second cancer in my remaining breast.  I have sometimes wished that I was more even.  If I had a bilateral, then I could get prostheses in any size without having to worry about matching.  And, as PJ says, if you are considering reconstruction, it may be difficult to match your healthy breast, so the doctor may end up suggesting a breast reduction to get satisfactory matching.  But are you ready to lose both breasts if you don't have to?  Ask your surgeon to discuss the risks and benefits of each option.  Then think it over and do what's feels right to you.  This is a very personal decision, and there really is no medically "right" answer.

Reply
8/19/09 9:50pm

Having been through making this same decision, I sympathize with you.  It seemed like a radical move to go ahead with the bilateral when I only had cancer in my left, and nothing wrong in my right.  I decided, with cancer history in other body parts, that it was in my best interest to go ahead and remove both breasts.  I figured, if I am going to go through yet another surgery, let it be this time and not yet another time when the right breast must go - with my luck, it would happen. Why subject yourself to more worry, more future surgeries, more tests, etc.  Also, with being large breasted, it will be so hard to wear a prostisis to match your left breast, and I have heard so  many women complain how heavy and uncomfortable they are.  Yes, a huge choice to make, but I think you will be happier to chose the bilateral - BUT we are all different and the decision has to be yours in the end.  I am 60, so close in years, and that being said, I wondered if I really cared if I had boobs or not.  I then made the choice to go ahead with the reconstruction, expanders being put in at time of surgery.  I had my implants put in in June and I am very happy - VERY happy - that I made these choices.  It is amazing, to say the least, to have perkey boobs at my age, and wearing a bathing suit is great.  I think it is one positive thing that has come out of the horrors of cancer, for sure.  All the best to you with your decision and let us know what you decide.

Connie J. 

Reply
8/21/09 6:43pm

I did as I was afraid that the cancer would go to the remaining brast. I also had lg. brast. I had reconstructive surgery. This is a decesion that you will have to make. I wish you the Best ib whatever your decesion may be.                                                                                                               Beth L

Reply
8/26/09 12:59pm

Having faced this same dilema back in June I can say it is a tough one. I had disease only in my right but have a significant family history and decided with difficulty to have bilateral mastectomies July 1st with reconstruction. Iam glad I did.There were precancerous cells in the left that were not seen on mammogram. I won't lie the first 7-10 days post op were hard esp. dealing with the side effects of the pain meds and trying to get comfortable sleeping on my side.I am now starting my chemo and have already had one Herceptin dose. It has also been hard to decide anything since it seems even those with very similiar diagnosis can receive different treatments.      I know first hand how much information is coming at you in such a short amount of time. We really do have to go with intuition. Hard as that sounds. My thoughts and prayers are with you.

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (6580) >
By ONE OR TWO— Last Modified: 12/24/10, First Published: 08/19/09