Sign in

or Register now

MyBreastCancerNetwork.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Monday, November, 23, 2009
  • Font size
Featured ContentPJ Hamel On NPR!

survival rate of breast cancer when treatment is nutritional and fitness oriented?

baldnbeautiful
baldnbeautiful
Close
baldnbeautiful is looking for understanding

09/20/09

i am attempting to understand more about breast cancer and many different options for treatment. while i understand there doesnt seem to be many options i am aware that chemotherapy is not a cure all and is quite often equally as devistating as the disease itself. if there are ways to live longer and or at the very least more comfortably i would like to understand and spread the information.

thank you  

Answer This
Answers (3)
PJ Hamel
PJ Hamel
Close
PJ Hamel is happy to be alive. As always.
Author, breast cancer survivor

Writer, mother, wife, volunteer, and survivor: PJ Hamel joins the...

Sunday, September 20, 2009

Hi - While chemo is devastating, it's usually not as devastating as death - which can be the result of cancer, when left untreated by standard means. The best way to live longer, IN MY OPINION (and i'm not a doctor), is to take the medicine (surgery, chemo, radiation, hormone therapy), and go forward with your life. You can certainly refuse treatment; but you will also certainly increase your risk of recurrence. That said, if you don't do treatment, please be sure to avoid alcohol, follow a low-fat diet, and exercise. This is just a common sense healthy lifestyle; please follow it. Good luck - PJH

re: survival rate of breast cancer when treatment is nutritional and fitness oriented?
sue dyer
Friday, October 30, 2009 at 09:32 PM

Hooray for common sense, PJ! Just ask the doctors and nurses about the cases they've seen where women have tried "alternative therapies" and had to return with a fungated tumour (i.e. one that has grown outside the body), when it is too late for effective treatment. We need to read with a critical mind the claims made by those who publish dubious material on the internet. Ask yourself where the scientific proof is for some of the statements they make.

 

Someone on our staff at school left an internet article on the table in the staff room (on the day I organised a fund-raising afternoon tea for Pink Ribbon Day) making some unsubstantiated claims and ending with the statement, "Since I don't eat carbohydrates, I don't expect to get cancer". Apart from feeling angry at having my own experiences belittled, I was concerned for those who read such stuff and swallow it whole.

 

Chemo is not pleasant, but it's often nowhere near as bad as you expect. I'm sure that experiencing a few days of nausea has to be better than the smell of a fungated tumour. We would all be better off if we accepted the truth about cancer and stopped looking for magic and miracles. Fighting cancer is a hard battle, but it can be won.

 

Best wishes

 

Sue

Reply
re: re: survival rate of breast cancer when treatment is nutritional and fitness oriented?
PJ Hamel
Friday, October 30, 2009 at 09:52 PM

You've hit the nail right on the head, Sue, as always. There's no easy way out with cancer - how we fight it is to get down and dirty. If you're going to beat a vicious disease, you have to get down in the gutter with it and roll around and stomp on it. And that takes strength, and courage, and some attitude.

 

I was just thinking about you today, Sue, hoping you're doing well. Is it full spring yet there? School going OK? And you...? PJ

Reply
re: re: re: survival rate of breast cancer when treatment is
sue dyer
Saturday, October 31, 2009 at 05:48 PM

I'm feeling really well, PJ, so good that when I have time to stop and think, it gives me pleasure. School's going fine and I'm looking forward to going back full-time next year. It is indeed spring here and it's been beautiful. Not long after I was diagnosed last year I noticed how intense colours can look when you're dealing with something life-threatening, something I'd read and heard about. That effect seems to have lasted. Now there's a good side effect of cancer!

 

I've just got into some fund-raising for our National Breast Cancer Foundation and have volunteered for their Speakers' Bureau. You may have noticed that the problem lies not in getting me to speak, but in getting me to shut up. In any case, I'm looking forward to giving something back.

 

Life is fantastic!!!

 

With love and thoughts of you

 

Sue

Reply
re: re: re: re: survival rate of breast cancer when treatment is
PJ Hamel
Saturday, October 31, 2009 at 06:41 PM

"Life is good." I have T-shirts and mugs both with that imprint. And it is, indeed. Kudos on your volunteer work - I think you'll be a terrific speaker!! I'd love to hear you. We're just finishing up Breast Cancer Awareness Month here - despite taking 10 days off mid-month when I went away on vacation, I managed to put 40 miles on the treadmill at the gym - they're donating so much per mile to breast cancer research. (So WHY didn't I lose a single ounce?! Must be too much baking...) Anyway, I'll bet you're looking forward to going back full time next year. The new normal is pretty darned good, isn't it? Cancer really does make you want to stop and smell the roses... because they seem so precious and smell so good! Cheers, Sue - good to hear from you. PJ

Reply
Racuh
Racuh
Close
Diagnosed with angiosarcoma of the left breast in Jan 2009.

Im young, smart, crafty, a legitimate artist/designer, I have cancer...

Monday, September 21, 2009

I woudn't even take tylenol for a headache. Im a prius driving, recycling, organic food bying, phosphate killing hippy...

 

Chemotherapy was a struggle for me... IS a struggle for me. I hate it with everything I have. It's frustrating and counter intuitive to how our immune system responds to cancer. It's a crap shoot in my opinion. I feel like its a miricle that people survive the treatment.

 

I followed a raw food macrobiotic diet when I found out... went to see 4 or 5 certified natropaths and talked to a LOT of women who've had cancer and beat it "naturally". I mean really talked to them... first hand. Myself... I couldn't make that gamble. Im pragmatic.

 

My conclusion? A book I live by called "Natrual Cures for Caner Patinents", a butt-ton of research and utterly tormenting my oncologists with questions and bringing in stacks of medical journals. It all comes down to options. As women with cancer... we have 2. Die or try and beat it with whatever is avalible. I would love to think that sprouted lentils, Quercertin and alkaline water are going to save my life... but chances are, they probably will not. I put my life in the hands of oncologists I sometimes I think I am smarter than... and I do what I can on my end to stay as healthy as humanly possible. I try and eat vegetarian. It's hard. Changing your lifestyle is the most difficult thing of all to change... but change is must. Cancer is a systemic disease. There is something happening in your body that isn't supposed to. We eat like crap here in the USA. We are fed chemicals at every juncture. That stuff is BAD.

 

Try and find a balance... (in everything right!?) combine what is avalible from the medical community (chemo) and supliment it with the wealth of knowledge that natropaths and zen masters have to offer. You will not get nutritional information from your oncologists. They say things like... "a sensible diet" and the cancer pamphlet they hand out says eat healthy snacks like cake and cookies (presumably for the calories) but cancer feeds exclusivly on glucose (sugar). Your body converts everything to sugar for energy anyway but don't throw gassoline on the fire! Cancer cells have a protine coating that enables them to sneak past our immune systems undetected. Removing animal protines from your diet (books say) the protine coating around the cells starts to break down thus letting your immune system attack it. Presuming you HAVE an immune system which you won't after a few rounds of chemo. 

 

Try the best you can to separate fact from myth and keep that balance.

carolyn97222
Friday, October 23, 2009

For me I chose both the natural (supplements, diet, and I know I should be exercising but haven't gotten that far yet) and the standard treatment (chemo, radiation, Femara, etc. 

 

Answer This

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

View all questions (3932) >

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of The HealthCentral Network. The HealthCentral Network does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Save