Saturday, January 12, 2013
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Diet Soda Linked to Depression

By Jerry Kennard, Health Pro Wednesday, January 09, 2013
Those sweet sparkling drinks we’ve come to enjoy have been under the spotlight lately and what emerges suggests we might want to evaluate our relationship with them. Dr. Honglei Chen, a member of the American Academy of Neurology, has reported a 30 per cent increased risk of depression in peopl...
1/ 9/13 2:36pm

Of the percentage that seemed to be most affected by diet soft drinks, how many were already obese?  Does the study tell us that?  The effects of both regular and diet sodas could be weight-related.  Does depression increase with eating disorders (both eating too little and eating too much)?  I know abnormal eating patterns are often listed with symptoms of depression.  Maybe dry mouth caused by antidepressants could cause one to drink more sodas, too.  Just things to think about.

Jerry Kennard, Health Pro
1/ 9/13 3:00pm
All good questions, Donna! Unfortunately the full details of the study in terms of the controls exercised will not be available until the conference presentation in March. I think the central word here is 'link' rather than cause. I know, for example the study made no attempt to examine the nature of sweeteners and the study author admits there are limitations. I suppose we might regard it as a flashing light and yet another study that reveals concerns over some of the things we might choose to consume.
1/ 9/13 3:16pm

Hi Jerry,

 

I absolutely agree with you. I have known a few young people who drank soft drinks all day and they were not only depressed but had too much weight on them.

 

I do agree that coffee, in moderation, is extremely good for us. Italians do drink a bit of coffee and the interesting thing is that Italians, before the current European financial crisis, had the lowest depression in the world.

 

I think that it was a combination of family support, good food, the good life and coffee along with olive oil. These things helped to keep depression away. Of course today Italy is not the same anymore. Corruption has a hold on the country and many people are depressed because there is no money, no jobs and not much to do for the young people there.

 

This is interesting Jerry. I will make sure to include soft drinks or carbonated drinks in the list of toxic substances for depression.

 

On the other hand, when my (hypo)mania comes in I stop all coffee and tea because these are stimulants.

 

1/ 9/13 5:35pm
Hi Kerry, Very interesting and good info to have. I have read that artificial sweeteners in drinks actually cause weight gain because your body does not know how to matabilize the foreign substance. Your body knows how to matabilize natural sugar. Two reasons to perhaps stay away now.
1/ 9/13 5:36pm
Ignore (Kerry) it was suppose to say your name, the computer went way too fast. Sorry Jerry.
Jerry Kennard, Health Pro
1/10/13 10:35am

Hi Crystal,

 

Yes, it's interesting stuff, although I expect the scientific and medical community are champing at the bit to take this particular study apart.

 

My own perspective is that these single studies and the somewhat tenuous associations they produce are limited in themselves, but collectively and from different scientific disciplines, there may be something of interest. Really, I think there's enough material around pointing in roughly the same direction to argue for a properly funded study into the area. Let's hope others feel the same way.

1/ 9/13 8:08pm

Here is a good article about this research

 

http://www.ibtimes.com/diet-soda-linked-depression-while-coffee-could-lower-risk-1002492

 

1/10/13 1:29am

The really funny thing is that the soda industries are saying that the research is bogus because it has not been proven scientifically?

 

This is absolutely silly because we all know that each can of drink (375ml) has at least 10 or more teaspoon of sugar (some say up to 14 teaspoons). We all know that too much sugar can cause depression. Imagine those who drink five or six cans per day. I mean, 10 teaspoon of sugar is more than the recommended daily dosage. So why do we need so much proof? Makes sense to me.

 

By Jerry Kennard, Health Pro— Last Modified: 01/10/13, First Published: 01/09/13