Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Depression Treatment May Not Treat Feeling of Hopelessness

By Jerry Kennard, Health Pro Friday, February 22, 2008
Results from a large clinical trial of patients with unipolar depression show that improvements in mood do not necessarily coincide with a decrease in the sense of hopelessness. Professor James E. Aikens, from the Department of Family Medicine, University of Michigan Health System, found that comp...
Antidepressants Don't Work
3/ 1/08 3:36pm
WOW.  Thanks for the revealing information.  Hopelessness is one of the worst feelings a person can experience, and to find out it hangs on once the depression has lifted.  I'll watch for that and spread the word.  Thanks.
Anonymous
peter nelson
7/17/08 3:48pm

" However, a sense of continuing hopelessness remained long after depressive symptoms lifted."

 

I'm having a hard time just processing this sentence.   I've only recently had experience with depression (as a result of the serious illness of my wife)  but I cannot imagine what you (or the original authors of the study) could possibly mean by mood improving but still feeling hopeless.   To me a feeling of hoplessness IS a mood.

 

Could this just be a semantic side effect  of the way they set up or worded the questions in their study?   One of the big problems with psychology (when I was an undergrad I switched my major from psychology to neurophysiology because of this problem . . . ) is the reliance on subjective self-reporting which is confounded by the way words are interpreted, question order and association, etc. 

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4165) >
By Jerry Kennard, Health Pro— Last Modified: 05/16/11, First Published: 02/22/08