Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Self-Esteem and the Habit of Comparing Yourself to Others

By John Folk-Williams Monday, July 19, 2010

 

All the lists of depression symptoms include the loss of self-esteem, but reducing it to a phrase says nothing about how it affects daily life. For me, constant self-comparisons to other people make it all too real.

 

In this post, I’ll describe what I do and how I think about this habit of comparing when I’m depressed, and in the next post I’ll detail the ways I finally learned how to keep this kind of mental action from taking over.

 

..............

 

When I’m depressed, my self-esteem is an ugly doormat. I seem to invite everyone to walk right over me. With this bottom-of-the-shoe view of the world, nothing comes more naturally than comparing myself to every friend, colleague, or famous person who comes to mind. 

 

I never do well in these match-ups, and that's the whole point. My depressed mind sees them all as ideal beings while, by comparison, I'll never come close.

 

Without exception, I know they are smarter, more accomplished, better looking, wealthier and generally much more successful than I am.

 

There is only one script here: they are always better, I am always worse. How could it be any different, I think in despair, when I’m such a depressed mess of a person?

 

I wonder if you’ve you worked as hard as I have to push yourself by comparisons into the loser’s corner?

 

How about this.

 

For real self-torture, I show up at a college reunion.

 

Naturally, I can safely assume that all the classmates I’ll meet there have done better than I have. Nevertheless, I tell myself not to think that way, but comparisons are my private elephant in the ballroom I walk into. I pretend not to notice it but can't think of anything else.

 

And so I greet them, wincing inwardly as I smile congratulations:

 

 

  • He’s an award winning journalist (I'm not.)
  • She started her own company (I didn't.)
  • He’s got a law practice (I could have been but wasn't.)
  • She’s a doctor (She has it all, I don't.)
  • He got elected to the school board. (I should have done that.)
  • I don’t know what he does, but his smile is bigger than the room. (I can't even smile.)

 

 

Even the ones who don’t say much about what they do are obviously wittier, more likable, better parents than I am.

 

They’re even happy! (I’m so depressed I hardly know what the word means.)

 

Of course, they make a fuss over me - oh you’re looking great, you’re lucky to do such interesting work, you live in such a beautiful place, you’ve always been a role model for me. But I know that’s just politeness - either that or I’ve succeeded in fooling them. I’m such a fraud!

 

I cringe in shame until those cringing muscles are sore, and I wear myself down with all this noise in my head. I get out of there as soon as I can to get back to my darkened life. Why did I ever try to step out of it?

7/19/10 9:13pm

I honestly don't know if I have had a problem with self-esteem.  I am keeping that separate from social anxiety which is kind of an unnamed, floating fear of people looking at me and demanding that I say something.  I am rarely worried about how I look or how I am perceived by others.  I just like to be alone rather than with people.  (See -- I even started every sentence with "I"  so maybe the problem is inflated ego.)

 

But I do have a friend who has been depressed most of his life.  I worked in the same office as he did for 10 years and then dated him for a while after I got a divorce.  He constantly thought everyone else had a better life than he did.  Someone else had beautiful children while Tom was still a virgin.  Someone else had already repaid their school loans while Tom's wages were garnished because he wasn't making payments on time.  Someone else obviously leads the life of a princess because she has money, a nice house, an luxury car, and no cavities.  (He actually harped on the "no cavities" bit because his teeth are not perfect.)  And, naturally, he believed most everyone was free of mental torture but him.  No matter what I have said to convince him otherwise, Tom focuses on what others have and what he does not, like your meeting with old acquaintences.

 

But too many times, the subject has come up and I make a real effort at convincing him he DOES have a lot to be thankful for, and he denies it.  It is like he WANTS to feel bad about himself/his life.  I wish I knew how to help him.  And maybe there was a time when I felt the same way.  Thank God I've been able to move on.

 

Donna

7/24/10 5:25pm

Moving on from problems with self-esteem is an enormous step! In fact, it's hard for me to imagine depression without this problem in some form - though the constant comparisons may not happen for everyone. You're lucky to have avoided that dimension of depression. By the way, starting every sentence with I is one of the legacies of depression I deal with - in depression I was completely self-absorbed, and everything revolved around me. That's pretty common, I think.

 

I developed the sense I was somehow wrong long before depression clearly set in. And I mean way back there as soon as I became fully aware of myself as an independent little person. Perhaps depression and the self-esteem issue aren't so inseparable.

 

John

 

 

7/20/10 12:49am

I actually think I do a lot less of this than I used to; maybe age has something to do with it.  I realize that no one has the perfect life, even though it may appear to be the case.  I gave up long ago having to be the "best" at anything and am not sure if that was resignation or just acceptance of what is.  I got reprimanded in school so much for "not working up to my potential" but feeling hopeless about the future, I hardly knew what that meant.  I was never good enough, no matter what I did.  About the time I lost my faith in my religion, I started to see things less as black and white and, instead, all of the gray areas where we have to decide with our hearts what is the right thing to do.  And, of course, we'll make mistakes and if we can find ourselves forgiving others for theirs, why not ourselves?

 

When I get seriously depressed, it's not about comparing myself with others; it's more about feeling self-hate without end, not being able to change a situation or myself.  I KNOW there are some things that I am better at than others, and vice-versa, and it helps to realize that we are all given different talents to use in our own way.  I want to get to a point where, if someone I care about rejects me, that it doesn't mean I should go drink poison.  That's hard to do in the midst of it, that's for sure.  And then there's dealing with the parent voices telling us we're stupid, no good, etc., which are very hard to erase - they FEEL so true.

 

Last night, my sister-in-law took it upon herself to tell my that my grandson was eating chips at our family get-together because he was anxious and needed to have something to do.  Yes, he was shy, but he was also hungry and stopped when he had enough.  Why didn't she say that to all the other people eating chips all afternoon?  I just blew it off and said I supposed that could be true, because debating with her is a never-ending conversation and I just wasn't up to it.  But I'm not buying into that - let the kid have a little fun once in a while!

 

Sorry to rant on, but I think we all have something we can feel proud about, even if it's just learning how to be our best selves.

7/24/10 5:36pm

Age and experience do make a big difference in learning to accept who we are and what we can actually do. But I've found that to be more an intellectual rather than emotional acceptance. It hasn't become a deep down belief.

 

You've clearly done a lot of great work for yourself to get past the self-hate and those destructive early messages from parents. The balance and wisdom you've gained shine through in everything you write here.

 

John

8/16/10 10:30pm

Hi Ya:

 

I am suffering through my 3rd round of depression since Dec/07, my self-esteem is next to nothing.  I see myself as defective for having this happen to me again & again & again.  I tell myself I am useless and that my mum would be better off if I wasn't here.

 

When I do force myself to go out I am constantly thinking that other people will judge me negatively,  I feel like running away when cars pass by on the street.

 

I am not on meds of any kind, my choice & feel as if I will never recover.

9/10/11 3:27pm

just read this post while searching for any similar cases as mine..

i'm almost 40 years old, and been in therapy for at least 15 years now.

but in regard to my obsessive envy and comparison, i feel i havn't moved a bit !

i'm a overly depressed, negative,and embittered person, detached from my inner feelings.

(only child, early divorce etc..)

 

and these days it seems i'm at my lowest point, feeling i won't be able to stop comparing myself to my closest friends.

i can summon it up as not wanting ANYONE to be happy.

that is, anyone who "passes me" makes me feel like a loser,

empty from any self esteem, and basically want to die.

i cannot even describe those envy feelings.
it burns me up inside and consuming me completely.
no logical thinking or humor can even start solving it.

so my only way of "surviving" this without being evil and negative to other people's lives, is just walk away and disconnect.

and then i can walk around for a few days, wishing them dead, or that they fail,

or disappear..

especially considering my friends romantic relations.

but it also concerns certain succsess, artistic achievments (i'm an artist).

 

it actually made me disconnect with most of my friends, i did it again and again many times. once they found relationships.

and even now, when i somehow managed to marry a very nice

girl who understand my situation and still choosing to stay with me,

i STILL can't stop comparing my relationship to others, STILL avoiding social

meetings in order not to get into those destructive feelings, because it can also destroy the only stable relationship i finally got.

 

i do realize i probably hate myself and have a very primal envy in me, folowed by very low self esteem. like an evil pig baby.

 

and i cannot bring myself to really understand that nothing is perfect for anyone.

i feel i'm the most deformed, twisted and dark person in the world.

(except of course- real psychos who actually KILL their friends..)

 

i also started taking "wellbutrin", giving a chance to hypnosis, and maybe CBT.

 

any ideas? :)

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4332) >
By John Folk-Williams— Last Modified: 01/18/12, First Published: 07/19/10