Wednesday, June 19, 2013
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Mild and Severe Depression: How are They Different? The Question of the Week

By Merely Me Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Hello everybody!

 

I hope you all are having a good week so far.  I am a little behind in posting and commenting and pretty much everything.  Smile  Just trying to plug along here until I make some headway. Would love to hear how you all are doing.  If you have never written a sharepost or if you have not written one in awhile now is a perfect time to tell your story or share your thoughts. We also invite you to join in our weekly discussion below.

 

This week's question for discussion is:  In what ways do you feel that mild depression is different from severe depression?  What would you say are the major differences?  Or do you think that the severity of depression is primarily subjective?  Should mild depression be treated differently than severe depression? 

 

And lastly...which type of depression would you say you have?  Or does your depression fluctuate from mild to severe?

 

Looking forward to hearing what you all have to say.

Thank you for your participation!

 

 

How Depression May Change Your Life
10/18/11 5:17pm

Mild 1/2 speed;  Severe no speed.

10/18/11 6:09pm

Mild means to me, a transitory, situational, manageable instance with recognizable cause, or causes.

 

Severe is an immobilizing, insurmountable, indefinite, inexplicable loss of interest in things of every day, of goals and future. Of spirit.

 

I believe the severity is subjective, even to those in the mental health field, even given the attempts to quantify and standardize. I think both are treated differently and probably should be.

 

My depression, has always seemed to me, to fluctuate and for no particular length of time. I think both, and everything in between. But again, it is subjective, compared to some of my fellow members, I would say mild. It just has not seemed that way, at times.

10/18/11 9:36pm

Hi MM and all,

Thanks for the question. My experience tells me that there are times when severe depression requires immediate attention. When a person is not eating, hardly moving, sleeping excessively, and staying in isolation, intervention may be needed to provide a way out. If the person is not communicating at all, someone has to bridge the withdrawal or a life is at risk. Mild depression is more like trying to swim with an anchor tied to a limb. Movement is possible, but the struggle is constant. In either case the pain is very real to the person with depression. With severe depression the symptoms are more easily detected. Whereas a person with mild depression can pass for being uninterested, "self-centered", socially inept, dull, anti-social, unmotivated, or moody. The treatment for severe depression has to be much more focused, with hospitalization as the most intense antidote. During recovery forward steps are

first tiny. Larger strides easily fool one into believing the unwanted "guest has been dismissed. Mild depression is a welcome reprieve after a severe bout. The 

hardest part for some one who has spent years of relative gregarious living is

finding that many who are not in your condition do not fathom what is now common for you. Thus an added burden to being depressed is sensing being misunderstood. Enough probing! Thank goodness for wonderful medications, counselors who accept insurance benifits, days, weeks, and months of relief in between hard times.

Ric

 

 

10/19/11 12:02pm

I agree with Ric in his description of the difference between mild and severe depression.  In between there, though, is what I think is referred to as "moderate," which is where I fall, with a few severe episodes now and then.  However, I've never been unable to get out of bed or to speak but to me, when everything I need to do feels like a big, huge burden, it feels severe.  That's when I know I have to talk to my doctor.

 

I am slowly trying to get off my Wellbutrin because I'm not sure it's helping all that much, but also because of what I've read about tardive dysphoria.  I want to see if it makes any difference.  My doctor is behind me and telling me to do it slowly and to let him know if any problems arise.  So far, I've just noticed that I'm a lot more tired, less energetic.  Wellbutrin is kind of an energizer, so I'm thinking it might be the reduced dosage causing it.  We'll see.  There's always that grey area where you aren't sure if you're getting more depressed or just tired, but usually time will tell.

 

Am babysitting again today, but meeting friends for lunch, so am looking forward to that!

10/19/11 2:00pm

In what ways is mild depression different from severe depression?   Mild depression may be situational in nature.  The symptoms are mostly the same as in severe depression, but have less effect and are more easily handled.  For me severe depression has included the wish to die and lack of fear of death with hoarding of old medications which might be effective in ending my life.

 

Do you think that the severity of depression is primarily subjective?

It can be.  But there is no doubt for me when I have severe depression, as my whole life is affected extremely adversely, and I think about dying to get out of the pain.

 

Should mild depression be treated differently than severe depression?  Yes, I believe mild depression would be more easily treated with therapy and medications.  For me, severe depression is treatment resistant.  I've been treated with therapy, medication, ECT, hospitalization, Vagus Nerve Stimulator implanted and settings adjusted.  I've also tried fish oil supplements without much positive effect.  I did finally come to a point where I was feeling better and had several months of mood stability.  However, since shortly after my mother's death in July, my mood has been worse due to bad memories stirred by going through her things and having them present in my home.  I've lost motivation to do as I need--get her things out and taken care of.  She named me executor of her will, and I've had to decide what to send each of my two sisters, who live away from the town I live in.  I have too little motivation and organizational ability due to the effects of my depression.

 

And lastly...which type of depression would you say you have? Or does your depression fluctuate from mild to severe?  Since the end of July there has been a fluctuation from a relatively mild depression back to a more severe one, though without the suicidal ideation.  My therapy and medications have remained the same.  As far as I know, my VNS is still operating.

 

10/20/11 12:21pm

Mild depresion I would treat w.St Joh's Wort and water exercise.  Severe depression, one (me) fluctuates between thinking of a rope, taking meds, Dr. adding more meds (reference tope), lying down and thinking of the many things that would

be more productive (vacuuming. a walk, swim, visit w/friends, cleaning, laundry, a movie, and much more).  Living/existing between dr. visits, and ...uh .... no discernable day to day energy for life.  That's the difference.  The mild depression meds to not eventually stop working and once again one desires a rope or a more immediate "feel better" drug.  Other than that, for me, not much else.

10/22/11 9:52am

I've been diagnosed with major depression. I have ups and downs with mild to sever depression. I live alone and it drives me crazy. I get so depressed I don't know what to do, along with anxiety. 

10/23/11 8:00am

I find it a bit difficult to really tell at times. But if I had to describe my own ups and downs it would be kinda like this:

 

Ups:

 

Today I feel like I've got nothing going on and I'm wasting my time trying to improve. I've got to go to the store though. So maybe that will take my mind off of it?

 

Downs:

 

Today I feel like life is just one big mass of painful memories and broken hearts and shredded dreams. I just want to sleep. I hope I don't wake up. Nobody bother me with any nonsense.

 

As for symptoms:

 

Ups:

 

Staring off into space. Not interacting. Incredibly focused on absolutely nothing. Would rather not speak. Sluggish.

 

Downs:

 

Badly hurt. Feeling worthless and like a burden. Thinking about what a funeral would cost to my family. Weighing out the options. Thoughts are racing like stock cars. Crashing into eachother like bumper cars. Thinking about trying something really stupid to get good help. Like I have to EARN it with my blood and tears. Almost a complete shut down of functions.

 

As for if they should be treated differently. Well if my descriptions seem familiar I'd say definitely. More work needs to be done to treat severe (down) depression.

10/26/11 8:25pm

hi there

 

i go to the doc's a lot with depression all he ever say's is this wont get sorted over night that is what i have been told for 15 years now and is getting a whole lot worse, my simptoms are i do not enjoy anything at all anymore, my 2 kid's say to me i wish you were a fun mum again, that really hurt'si isolate myself from everyone, i have lost friend's and family due to this. i have anxiety aswell and stress, everyone say's i am a hypricondriact or however you spell it, my sis say's it is a fake illness, my mum says i should go back to work i would feel better, i work in a bank, also have severe mood swing's fly off the handle at the slightest thing's including things i used to know now forgotten and get really annoyed with myself and customer because i have forgotten which is not their fault, all i want to do is hide and not see anyone at all, i am happy to go a week or two without seeing anyone or going out, my son is trying to get me to befriend his friends mums which i am not interested in, i used to love socialising, find it very difficult to get up in the morning and getting to sleep at night, to try and feel better when i can be botherd to pull myself together go out and spend money on things i do not need, does not make me feel any better at all, i feel absolutly worthless and that their is no point in my life, the only thing that acctually stops me from doing anythign stupid is my kids i got tattoos of their names so i remember why i am here that does help sometimes, i feel they would be better off with their dad and his girlfriend, i feel everyone is back stabbing me and talks about me so i try to avoid it and stay in with curtains shut, i used to take carwe of my apperance ii have forgotten how do that, probably wont get a message back i am lost and confussed i am married but think he just takes the piss out of me and is only here cause he has nowhare to go please

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4340) >
By Merely Me— Last Modified: 12/12/11, First Published: 10/18/11