Monday, May 20, 2013
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

7 Presidents who Battled Depression

By Merely Me Monday, February 20, 2012

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) an estimated 1 in 10 Americans suffer from depression. This statistic also includes our nation’s leaders, our presidents. On this President’s Day we are going to take a look at how mood disorders have affected some of the most famous men in American history. Before you take a peek at the rest of this post, do you think you can name all the presidents who have had depression at some point in their lives?

 

In 2006 an article was published by psychiatrists at the Duke University Medical Center which reviewed the biographies of American presidents from 1776 to 1974. This study, which was published in the Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease analyzed the historical data of 37 presidents looking for symptoms of mental illness as defined by the criteria of the DSM-IV, the Diagnostic Statistical Manual. What they found was startling. According to the Duke researchers, 49% of former presidents had experienced some form of mental illness. Depression was the most common type of presidential mental illness (24%) which some experts say is a high percentage compared with the national average.

 

Other mental health diagnoses included anxiety, social phobia, substance abuse, and bipolar disorder.

 

Here is a list of the presidents who have been diagnosed with depression through analysis of historical data:

 

John Adams

 

According to the historical literature, John Adams was an unhappy president. Some think he may have suffered from both depression and bouts of mania. He was said to have experienced recurring attacks of depression in 1756 when he studied law. In his diaries he wrote about “great anxiety and distress.” He confessed later in life that he was not one to suffer in silence: “I sighed, sobbed, and groaned, and sometimes screeched and screamed. And I must confess to my shame and sorrow that I sometimes swore.”

 

Thomas Jefferson

 

Thomas Jefferson, who followed John Adams, as our third president also experienced what we would call clinical depression today. Jefferson suffered from physical ailments such as back problems and headaches which contributed to his melancholy. Financial woes and personal loss deepened Jefferson’s depression. His wife, Martha, died after her last pregnancy at the early age of 33. It is said that following his wife’s death that he stayed in his room for three weeks and ventured out only to join his daughter Patsy on all-day rides on horseback.

 

James Madison

 

James Madison has been described as one of the smallest and frailest of our presidents. As a young man he is said to have felt insecure about himself and had difficulty becoming independent from his family. Madison developed a depression characterized by inertia and wish for an early death. The death of his college roommate and best friend deepened his depression. Following his friend’s death he wrote to a friend: "As to myself, I am too dull and infirm now to look out for any extraordinary things in this world, for I think my sensations for many months have intimated to me not to expect a long or a healthy life . . . therefore have little spirit or elasticity to set about anything that is difficult in acquiring, and useless in possessing after one has exchanged time for eternity."

Pam Flores, Health Guide
2/20/12 1:27pm

Hi MM, I find this so interesting!  I also agree with John Quincy Adams; water is such a soothing thing and great for your cardiovascular health and overall well being.

 

Sad to know this many had to battle with depression, since I'm not sure what they had to help.  Maybe there were holistic approaches that helped!

 

Thanks for shedding light on this, I love history.

 

Pam

2/20/12 3:47pm

Hello Miss Pam!

 

This was a fun post to write...I love history too.  I had bought the series on John Adams and it is very good but I got sidetracked by other shows...Boardwalk Empire...which is also a little historical...about the prohibition days.

 

It was difficult for me to stop researching this topic as I find it amazing that these men were dealing with grief and depression but still had this huge task of running our country.  I wonder too what they did to alleviate their depression...it seems a common remedy was exercise including walks and horseback riding or swimming.  There was no Prozac then.  I wonder if we had a president today who had a mental illness such as depression...would we be accepting?  The elections are so negative I hate to say this but I think something like depression would be used against a candidate. 

 

Thank you so much for stopping by.  I always love to see you!

2/21/12 11:39am

MM;  Your readers & you would be interested in John Gartners book "In Search of Bill Clinton."  John has his Phd/Psy from John Hopkins & is an asst. clinical professor. His professioal opinion is Bill Clinton is BiPolar.

2/21/12 8:05pm

Hi there

 

Thanks for this book suggestion.  I have wondered myself about this possible diagnosis.  But I am sure many people have their theories.

 

What I most wonder about is if one of our leaders were to say..."I have depression" or some other mental illness...how would the country react?

 

Thanks for stopping by...

MM

 

 

10/ 2/12 6:06am

Well .... this is very interesting and great article, very useful information! Embarassed

I have more health care articles on http://tipshealth.org

Thanks a lot guys

2/20/12 2:10pm

Thanks MM, for this post.  Wow, you did a lot od research on this.  It is amazing how people struggle with depression and etc. and can do gret things as well.  We can all do this.  Very inspirational.

2/20/12 3:53pm

Thanks Rena!

 

I was a little obsessive about this post...once I began to research I found it difficult to stop.  Abraham Lincoln, of course, is probably the most interesting president to me...as he was so complex and dynamic.  He changed the course of history in a huge way but was in constant battle with his emotions.  How did he do it? 

 

What may also be of interest but I could not include in a single post is the women who marry presidents sometimes have some sort of mental illness. For example Lincoln's wife was suspected to have bipolar disorder. 

 

It is a fascinating realm to explore. 

 

Thanks so much for your comment.

 

 

2/21/12 2:46pm

I really like Lincoln as well and I had no idea that  women who marry presidents sometimes have some sort of mental illness.  How interesting is that?  Thanks again for all the work you do for all of us to read.  Every post is truly a gift to us all.  :)

2/21/12 8:45pm

You are very kind Rena

 

I am so grateful for you guys. 

 

Thanks for being here.

2/20/12 11:22pm

This was really interesting to me, too, MM.  I didn't know that many presidents suffered from it.  I can't imagine having to deal with that while trying to run the country, yet most of them did it, some more successfully than others.  Yes, it would be interesting to see what would happen to a president today who was depressed - maybe we'd never hear about it unless it became really severe.  It's interesting, too, how many of them lost children and other family members at young ages.  Someone in my family did a genealogy study on my grandmother's family and it was amazing how many of them died very young, from things that today are very treatable.  Thank God for advances in medicine, as much as we sometimes hate having to take drugs!

2/21/12 8:58pm

Hey Judy!

 

It did seem that there was an amazing similarity between some of these men in all the losses they endured especially of children.  We sometimes take for granted today...that our children will most likely be healthy or that we won't die in childbirth.  Living to a "ripe old age" in some eras was a feat in itself.

 

I am curious too what would happen if one of our leaders would talk about having depression.  I just don't know.

 

Thanks so much for your comment...hope you are having a great week so far.

2/21/12 12:31pm

Hi M/M,

 

Great article...I love history! True, it makes one wonder what they did and how they handled those crushing 'lows', etc. Did they ever confide in someone? Could they? Or would 'society' frown upon it, perhaps as some sort of demonic posession?

 

Hoping that you & yours are doing well.

 

Carl

2/21/12 9:15pm

Thanks Carl

 

Good to see you...how has life been treating you?

 

I imagine that it must have been very lonely for many of these men.  Some probably did not have a word for how they were feeling.  In some ways we have pogressed but in other ways...how accepting would we be of a depressed president?  There is still a stigma after all these centuries.

 

At least we aren't using leeches or blood-letting to cure someone of their melancholy. 

 

Thanks so much for stopping by to comment!

 

MM

2/21/12 12:32pm

Hi M/M,

 

Great article...I love history! True, it makes one wonder what they did and how they handled those crushing 'lows', etc. Did they ever confide in someone? Could they? Or would 'society' frown upon it, perhaps as some sort of demonic posession?

 

Hoping that you & yours are doing well.

 

Carl

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4331) >
By Merely Me— Last Modified: 10/02/12, First Published: 02/20/12