Sign in

or Register now

MyDepressionConnection.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Monday, November, 30, 2009
  • Font size

My Depression Connection Question of the Week!

Merely Me
Merely Me
Close
I am a published writer who suffers from depression and MS

I have suffered from depression for as long as I can remember and I...

Merely Me

Thursday, September 10, 2009
View All of Merely Me's Posts
Hi everybody!   Are you ready for some good conversation?    I am thinking of Rodney Dangerfield and his mantra of "I get no respect, no respect at all."  I think of the issues that comes up for people who have depression is the notion of respect within their relationships and...
  1. Disrespect and depression
    rose martin
    Thursday, September 10, 2009 at 06:03 PM

    Dear Merely Me

    Yes, definitely, I do believe that in many family dynamics, the person who suffers with Depression, and the side effects that can ensue - loss of job, mood swings,lack of confidence. Can lead to people with Depression being treated as 2ndClass people of a lesser God.   I find that people are respectful of me in the main but my family members whom I dont see that often, are disrespectful, its in a very insideous way, like say at Christmas, [one of the few times I see them]. they will be discussing something at the table. I will chip in. I consider myself fairly well read, invariably i will be ignored. Recently Is sent emails to my only remaining family, a nice email to all, outlining that I suffered from bad depressions that had blighted my childhood and life. I thought Ishould come out of the closet. I said that I was on antidepressants. I didnt get the Dignity of a reply, i felt embarrassed, humiliated and disrespected.

    My  family members would know that i spent time in hospital and suffer from'Nerves' and in my presence there have been comments about people being on 'Happy Pills' and my cousin who lives near once said 'Oh, we could all get depressed if we wanted'. This is absolutely disrespectful to me and it disregards me as a genuine and credible human being. OF course Im flawed. But Im worthy of respect.  People with Depression are seen as Weak human beings, people with no courage,lazy, losers.  In my presence, there have been comments made about people whove had breakdowns or are very depressed and its always in a sort 'arent they pathetic ' sort of mode.  

    I dread Christmas because Im never asked 'how are you?' im taken to somebodys house for the Day. theyre all high achievers and wealthy, theres lots of lovely prada handbags and clothes and one trying to outdo the other with presents. I feel very alone and I feel like screaming inside.  I dread it. I feel definitely that Depression seems to be a red light for people thinking youre a push over, somebody whose views arent worth merit.  I have to finish by saying, I have a particularly bad family in so much as my mother and siblings are in England and I only  have my mothers sisters children here who live nearby, know I suffer but never pop in, I think Im fun and i always try and enter their world for the Day.  I inevitably become dreadfully depressed around the end of october, start of November, Disrespect or the apprehension of it, for me brings on Depression. Ive found this posting very emotional and upsetting so sorry for rambling on, Its really brought home to me, just how much disrespect ive been putting up with. unjustified.

    Reply
    re: Disrespect and depression
    stardust
    Thursday, September 10, 2009 at 07:47 PM

    Hi Rose,

     

    You are so well spoken and I know from your posts that you are very well read!  I am sorry for the disrespect from your family.  Hurts, huh?  The difficult part to remember is that it is their ignorance and lack of compassion and that is so selfish!  I have a very wealthy brother who has his own depression problem (well hid), does the country club scene, etc.  I make sure I never bring up the word "depression" because I don't want them to perceive that I may struggle with it, and not keep their respect.  Isn't that awful.  It's like trying to fit in their box when I'm around them.  And really, I think I'm disrespecting myself when I do that.  Your family is labeling you, like you said, but really, Rose, you are so much more authentic than they are, and I found, that around "uppity" people, I feel so vulnerable.  I don't see my family much at all because my husband and I live a long distance from all of them.  Selfish, but after I've seen them, I feel good going back to my own territory without them.  I wish it weren't that way, but that sums it all up!

     

    I wish you the best as you work to find the best way within yourself to work this out.

    Gina

    Reply
    re: re: Disrespect and depression
    janet
    Thursday, September 10, 2009 at 09:31 PM

    rose you are the real deal. i'd rather deal with real folks than uppity, plastic, phonie joanies!

    Reply
    re: re: re: Disrespect and depression
    rose martin
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 06:37 AM

    Thanks so much Joanni - your feedback like the previous one has helped me coz sometimes i just feel 'Is itme?' 'Am i a horrible person?' and when youre in a Depression the answer is invariably yes. thanks again for your support

    Reply
    re: re: re: re: Disrespect and depression
    janet
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 12:31 PM

    hi rose i'm janet i was just using an expression phonie joanie & you got to calling me joanie.no biggie hun.have a nice daySmile

    Reply
    re: re: re: re: re: Disrespect and depression
    rose martin
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 01:10 PM

    OOPs Janet ! its the tabs ! sorry bout that Embarassed

    Reply
    re: re: Disrespect and depression
    rose martin
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 06:36 AM

    Manythanks for your kind words. I can totall understand why you and your husband like to get away. I didnt tell my 'family' about the awful depression and it was thru this website that I decided to 'come out' and explain to them. You are so right, we disprespect ourselves by allowing ourselves be disrespected. Fitting into their box , speaking about thing They find interesting, Exotic holidays that Weve never had, all very on the surface and superficial. Im not a respector of wealth and dont  feel in awe of it, Ijust find that when youre senstive and not 'out there' earning and achieving materially etc that in certain families and circles youre seen as a loser hence what you have to say or add t oa conversation isnt really important to them. thats the logical side but the little inner child still feels like Cinderella and very excluded and unloved.

    Disrespect is dreadful in any shape or form.  Another factor for the Site, If you make a complaint about a doctor and its a physical illness [negligence] youre taken seriously here in this Country, if however, you wish to change from one Psychiatrist whose obviously not very good, because you have a 'psychiatric condition' people in the Hospitals can be extremely condescending. I had that experience personally and went onn Radio about it.

    Reply
    re: Disrespect and depression
    Ricovring
    Thursday, September 10, 2009 at 10:38 PM

    rose,

     

    You see just fine. Your family may never come around, but being open like you are here

    makes you a stronger you.

    Reply
    re: re: Disrespect and depression
    rose martin
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 06:42 AM

    Sorry I dont want to Hog this Question of the Week Post so can i just say a big thank you to all who went the trouble of writing here to give me support, its meant so much to me, thanks for taking the time and trouble to write.

    Reply
    re: Disrespect and depression
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 11:54 AM

    AHHHHHH!

     

    There...I was screaming for you.  Geez oh man...what horrid comments to make to you!  Seriously...there is no call for what they said.  And to ignore you...that is the deepest cut of all.  I am so sorry Rose.

     

    I think a lot of us feel this anxiety and pressure and also depression right before the holidays because...we know we have to face family.  And for some of us...our families may have a definite um...toxic side to them. 

     

    I do believe that we create our own "family" with friends...people we trust...people who will be kind to us.  Some of us have to...for survival.

     

    Maybe we can have a virtual holiday here.  A time to make merry with kindred spirits.  Just an idea I just thought of...

     

    Wish I could give you a hug.  (((Rose)))

    Reply
  2. disrespect/ stigma
    Ricovring
    Thursday, September 10, 2009 at 10:55 PM

    My family has been very supportive for the most part. My own ignorance about depression and how I need to take as much responsibility as I can for my  own condition

    has brought on much of the ambivalence that has surfaced in the past. As I have grown 

    in my understanding of depression and have learned to handle symptoms more gracefully,

    my respect from others has also grown. Sometimes our perceptions of how others are relating to us is not as clear when we are not coping well. Life seems cheerier when we feel cheerier. We find sometimes people are not really censoring us, but we anticipate

    their coolness, and set ourselves up to notice what is not really being sent. I am not saying that stigma isn't real, but often people don't really mean to be disrespectful, they 

    are just not thinking about "unusual" things. They are stuck in their "normalcy."

    Reply
    re: disrespect/ stigma
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 11:58 AM

    "They are stuck in their normalcy"...I like that.  Yeah...how true.  For all of us really.  We get stuck in our heads...because this is the only world we know.  We can't truly walk in someone else's shoes no matter how much we want to.

     

    Thank you as always for your insights...you have true wisdom!

    Reply
  3. Respect
    Judy
    Thursday, September 10, 2009 at 11:36 PM

    I've had different experiences with this.  I think when I was younger and depressed, my family referred to it as "psychological problems" caused by being sick for a period of time when I was 12 - my mother still refers to it at times and here it is, 48 years later!  I think my illness gave them a safe explanation for why I was unhappy, but it really wasn't about being sick.  That's disrespect in the form of disregard - if they don't acknowledge it, it doesn't exist.  It's still that way today, nobody will discuss any kind of emotional problems but with my mother, it's better that way because having emotional problems is equivalent to being crazy and that just gets you written off.  It's kind of sad, but I can't be truthful about myself with her.  When my son tried to kill himself, I never told her, my father, nor 3 of my 4 siblings.  People get judgmental when they feel threatened.

     

    When I went through a severe depression twice while I was working, I was honest about it, but felt that it was held against me for the rest of my career.  The second time it happened, my boss became impatient because I wasn't performing at 100% and told me the "real" reason I was depressed and put me on notice.  Of course, that made me feel 100% better right away. Surprised  What was actually happening, as I discovered in retrospect, was that my small work group was a replication of my childhood family, so going to work every day was like triggering PTSD.  I'm sure some of my negative thinking was irrational, but when it came down to my last year there, I was the only one excluded from department meetings, yet expected to be responsible for things that were discussed only in those meetings but not communicated to me.  I thought I was really going crazy at times because most of them avoided me and sometimes didn't speak to me for days at a time.  The job I once loved became totally unbearable for the last 12 years I was there.  Why did I stay so long?  Maybe you've heard of "golden handcuffs."  I had too many years there to throw away a decent retirement and too old and lacking enough education to get a job anywhere else in the company.  I don't know if I've yet made peace with it because I still feel very bitter and won't set foot in the place again if I don't have to.

     

    In both cases - family of origin and work environment - it really was like I was invisible, which is a form of disrespect.  Nothing you could put your finger on, but it was there.  I don't know if there will ever NOT be a stigma with having depression and maybe we perpetuate that ourselves because we end up feeling ashamed and guilty, so we don't want to talk about it, either.  Yet, there's an astronomical number of people taking antidepressants today.

     

    That's what's great about this site - we can be truthful about the depression and learn a lot from others' experience.  Knowledge is power.  And ignorance is not bliss!

    Reply
    re: Respect
    Marlene227
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 02:41 AM

    When it comes to depression I usually can put up with other's being disrespectful unless they are gloating in it. What I do not like is the "trust" that is being disrespected.  The trust is not there. I realize that my past may contribute to that but when someone intentionally betray's you that is what hurts.

     

      

    Reply
    re: re: Respect
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 12:09 PM

    Hi Marlene!

     

    Yeah this is a good point.  Trust.  You trust and expect people to be nice or at least neutral...but when you get a kick in the butt...when you are already down...it just hurts all the more.

    Reply
    re: Respect
    rose martin
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 06:57 AM

    Dear Judy,  what a wonderful posting on Disrespect. I would love to say to you that your experience in the workplace was sad, awful but unusual, unfortunately, its not.

    Youre a highly intelligent,intuitive, efficient and articulate person, probably could have done the bosses job too! How convenient for the that you were 'Slightly mad' or 'weak' I worked for a huge Govt.Body here. I always felt truth is best. I told them that I was on antidepressants and would need an afternoon off once every 2wks to see him and would make up the hours [we had flexi time anyway]. From that day on, the whole situation changed judy. I could feel the disrespect, the conversations that stopped when i entered a room, the lunches I wasnt invited to join. I eventually left, a great pensionable job. I found out that any type of 'emotional Distress' is perceived as a weakness. Most of my workmates were budding alchoholics who used drink to ease their obvious stress, but thats socially acceptabe. Depression and Mental problems is not acceptable, its feared -might be contageous. I dont tell friends except for 2 who suffer themselves. Ive learnt its better not to. Sad - But true.

    Reply
    re: Respect
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 12:07 PM

    Oh Judy...You have been through so much from family...and then work.  I understand about the work part...I have been in that situation too...you feel like...how can I possibly give this up after I have invested so much time here? 

     

    The feeling invisible...yeah...I can relate.  It seems unbelievable that in this day and time...when so many people suffer from depression...we see ads for antidepressants all the time on tv...it is talked about by famous people...yet...there is still a stigma.  Many do not want to talk about it or see it as some character flaw.

     

    A time when I felt particularly disrespected was...when I had a miscarriage and...I was also having trouble at work...with family...it was a horrible time for me.  I was struggling to maintain my sanity...but breaking down at work.  I was put on an antidepressant and...I was angry about it because I wanted to keep trying to have a baby.  When I saw my doctor and also my gynecologist and explained how I did not want to be on an antidepressant for long...because I wanted to try again it was like...I became a child.  I was told this wasn't a good idea and...maybe sometime in the future I could try again and I got so angry.  Of course I would wait until I felt better but...I was definitely treated differently because I was depressed and taking medication for it.  There was this air of...I didn't know how to make my own decisions.

     

    I will never forget that time.  I felt...less than.  And it definitely contributed to my depression. 

     

    I am sure all of us can relate stories about this feeling.

    Reply
  4. This site is a place to find respect
    LyraStorm
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 03:04 AM

    I find this one a difficult question to answer. I've certainly felt that people have been disrespetful to me a lot in my life, but then everyone has that at some point, whether they are depressed or not. I mean there is always going to be somebody who is going to look down their nose at you/think you're not worthy/treat you horribly... When you're depressed you're stressed and more sensitive so it might hurt more... maybe...

     

    Some of the more hurtful things that come to mind are things like my Mum telling everyone that I was depressed because it is her life too apparently and me being depressed affects her and she needs to talk about things with friends... so many friends... it's so uncomfortable when people you don't even know, but your mum does, comes up to you and talks to you in that patronising voice used for little kids or those who are mentally handicapped or something like they have to be careful what they say and upbeat and all that shit. I didn't want people to know, I felt ashamed (now I know I shouldn't be but this was years ago) and yet everywhere I went there seemed to be someone Mum knew so they knew... that seemed very disrespectful to me.

     

    And then there are those who say that I should just try harder, if I only thought more positive, etc... I just feel like I should get some respect for all the hard work I have put in. I'm still here. I'm still fighting. I feel like I've accomplished Herculean tasks. A bit of respect, please!

     

    I think that is why we all love this site so much. We get it and respect each others struggles and stories and accomplishments. Respect makes us feel safe here and keep coming back. It's something we're all lacking at least somewhere in our lives, I think, and it's nice to have a place to go to find it.

    Reply
    re: This site is a place to find respect
    rose martin
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 07:05 AM

    Dear Lyra, youre a warrior, a fighter, the condescending condolences are just ignorance really and embarrassment. The 'Work harder' or 'try and be positive' or 'there are people in hospital dying' is common and disrespectful and it not only denies our Real Pain and Mental Anguish, it presumes to know the levels of our pain and how difficult it can be just to exist day to day.  We on site know how strong you are, i certainly do, youre a true warrior.  Lyra the saying Those that matter dont mind and those that mind dont matter comes t mind.Yell

    Reply
    re: This site is a place to find respect
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 12:16 PM

    Hi Lyra!

     

    I think I will print out your comment here and post it to my wall...when I am feeling bad I will look at it.

     

    I really hope that we have made this a community where everyone does feel safe and able to share in a way that maybe they cannot do otherwise.  Yes...respect is so important and...this is something we are giving each other when sometimes the world does not.  Let this place be a safe refuge. 

     

    I am sorry your mom did that to you...I can see where you would be hurt.  And people telling you to try harder or think more positively...bah humbug.  You are trying...and many people cannot see this but know that we can.  I totally get how hard you are trying each and every day.

     

    Thanks for being such a vital part of our community here.  We need you.

    Reply
  5. Dr. Seuss
    findme
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 02:19 PM

    I use to have a huge issue with respect and I still do.

     

    You're all correct...My own self image make me less confident and when I am in a meeting or hanging out with the guys, I'm constanly asking myself, "Why am I being treated like I'm defective" I know that its a cognitive distortion, and I try my best to work through it.

     

    What I found that helps is a Quote from Dr. Seuss..""Be who you are and say what you feel because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind."

     

    Hope I can help.

    Reply
    re: Dr. Seuss
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 12:30 PM

    Really?  That is a doctor seuss quote?  I did not know that.  Smart man he was. 

     

    I feel at times I have a sign on my head, "please poop on me...go ahead...I won't mind."

     

    I just cannot get over people who purposefully go out of their way to try to humiliate, one up you, or try to diminish you so that they can feel better about themselves.  And then get rewarded for it.  It kills me when I see someone who is clearly a jerk who gets over because they are like eddie haskell...smiling as they stick it to you.  Other people are fooled and think they are great!  Childhood bullies are alive and well...they transform into skillful and even more manipulative adult versions.  They have had years to perfect their talents.  At least in grade school you might have had the option of going all " Ralphie from the christmas story" on them and giving them the butt whooping they deserve.

     

    sorry...for the vent.  Smile

     

    Anyways...we are not defective.  We are just human.  Thanks for your comment.

     

     

    Reply
    re: re: Dr. Seuss
    Ricovring
    Sunday, September 13, 2009 at 05:17 PM

    I always like what you write, MM. That was just a little vent, I might not have noticed

    if you hadn't pointed it out. The adult bullies can't out last innocent goodness. Love always wins in the end. Kinda like rain off a duck's back, when you get the hang of it(not that I know much about it!). A nap really helps in that department, too.

    Reply
    re: re: re: Dr. Seuss
    Merely Me
    Sunday, September 13, 2009 at 05:34 PM

    Innocent goodness...love... rain...ducks...naps...this all sounds great!  Smile

     

    I really want to believe good wins out in the end.  Call me a naive romantic.  I guess I am kinda like charlie brown...I will probably always try to kick the football before it is snatched away.

     

    Foolish or hopeful?  I dunno.

    Reply
  6. how a person is treated whose birthday is 9/11
    janet
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 07:23 PM

    my birthday is 9/11 which is depressing.i hate hearing the news & people talk about '01 & @ some point i can count on breaking out in tears.some people laugh when they hear my birthday is 9/11.true i didn't lose any1 close to me but it cuts like a knife each year.my birthday is like a nightmare that won't go away since '01 . i wouldn't treat my enemy like that.thousands died ,planes crashing.make it stop.

    Reply
    re: how a person is treated whose birthday is 9/11
    Paul
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 10:55 PM

    Janet. you are proof that good things also happen on 9/11. You hang in here.

    Reply
    re: re: how a person is treated whose birthday is 9/11
    janet
    Friday, September 11, 2009 at 11:19 PM

    thank you paul from 1 who didn't want to face today Cry

    Reply
    re: how a person is treated whose birthday is 9/11
    Merely Me
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 12:34 PM

    Oh my...I am so sorry.  I had read an article about this very thing.  Your birthday was just your birthday until...that horrible trauma happened. 

     

    May I say Happy Birthday anyway?  I hope you still get to celebrate it. 

     

     

    Reply
    re: re: how a person is treated whose birthday is 9/11
    janet
    Saturday, September 12, 2009 at 01:16 PM

    sure ya can say happy birthday just don't discuss planes crashing,where you were on9/11/01,the pentagon,twin towers, you get the idea.i got to pizza hut yesterday.p'zone was beautiful & sharing that with my honey & his little pizza was great.best pizza & p'zone i'd had in i don't know how long. yum yum!!!!!!!

    Reply
  7. The Importance of Respect
    amy
    Friday, September 18, 2009 at 12:48 AM

    Respect is integral to a relationship. Without the existence of respect, a relationship will flounder. The negativity which seems to accompany depression can be misinterpreted by others, including those close to you. Often, it seems that it is misunderstood & denounced as not trying to "look for the good" in life around one. A depressive state can be triggered also by not feeling the recognition which accompanies being valued for one's opinions, thoughts or ideas. The very dignity of a human being is at stake when respect is not shown; lack of respect can threaten the core of a human being. Although a "joke source" by Rodney, the essence of his humor was the truth of his mantra.

    Reply
  8. The Importance of Respect
    amy
    Friday, September 18, 2009 at 12:48 AM

    Respect is integral to a relationship. Without the existence of respect, a relationship will flounder. The negativity which seems to accompany depression can be misinterpreted by others, including those close to you. Often, it seems that it is misunderstood & denounced as not trying to "look for the good" in life around one. A depressive state can be triggered also by not feeling the recognition which accompanies being valued for one's opinions, thoughts or ideas. The very dignity of a human being is at stake when respect is not shown; lack of respect can threaten the core of a human being. Although a "joke source" by Rodney, the essence of his humor was the truth of his mantra.

    Reply
  9. The Importance of Respect
    amy
    Friday, September 18, 2009 at 12:48 AM

    Respect is integral to a relationship. Without the existence of respect, a relationship will flounder. The negativity which seems to accompany depression can be misinterpreted by others, including those close to you. Often, it seems that it is misunderstood & denounced as not trying to "look for the good" in life around one. A depressive state can be triggered also by not feeling the recognition which accompanies being valued for one's opinions, thoughts or ideas. The very dignity of a human being is at stake when respect is not shown; lack of respect can threaten the core of a human being. Although a "joke source" by Rodney, the essence of his humor was the truth of his mantra.

    Reply
  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Was this helpful? Yes
  • Save
  • RSS
  • Report Abuse

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

View all questions (2375) >