Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Thursday, February 09, 2012 FightorFlight asks

Q: My boyfriend broke up with me because he has depression... but he has made it seem as if there is still hope for us to reconcile. Do I move on or wait?

I spent two years in love with the most amazing man, we lived together, we played together, we laughed together. He was part of every bit of my life. This year we were planning on moving out, getting married, and travelling.

 

 

About a month ago i noticed a change in him, he was becoming withdrawn, he rarely smiled and he was struggling with every aspect of his life. There were days where he seemed fine, and days where we were in the same house together but didnt say a word. I am a social work/ psychology student so i recognised the signs and was prepared to help him in any way that i could.

 

 

Unfortunately, he broke up with me last week saying things like "this isnt fair on you" , "your better off without me", " i don't know where my head is at". He wouldn't let me support him because it was unfair on me with him not being able to give me all that i need or all that i "deserve". He cried through this entire speech and ignored everything I said about wanting to stick around and support him.

 

What makes it more difficult, i dont know whether or not i should move on because he has promised to "get himself sorted" and then try and win me back, and throughout his entire 'break-up speech' he cried and kept telling me that he loved me.

 

For the most part it was not a bad break-up we hugged and i harbour no animosity. Just a shattered sense of self worth and no desire what so ever to get out of bed.

 

This hurts more than anything i could ever imagined, he thinks he is doing whats best for me because nothing makes him happy anymore. I wanted to be there to help him through all of this, i hate seeing him hurt. We are still on communicative terms, what kind of contact is appropriate in this situation?

 

However, my real question is do i wait for him or do i try and recover? Is it even possible for a relationship to recover from this?

Answer This
Answers (3)
Merely Me, Health Guide
2/10/12 5:43pm

Hi there

 

Well first of all I am so sorry this has happened and right before Valentine's Day too. 

 

I have to say...we get pretty much the same story at least once a week here on the depression site...I wonder if all these guys have some sort of connection with one another because they all say the same things! 

 

The thing which is most unfair to you is that he is making this decision for you...to break up the relationship...assuming that you can't handle his depression.  Life is full of ups and downs, illness, setbacks and even depression.  Although you are telling him that you want to stick it out...he is ending things supposedly "for you."  If this were me I would be a little ticked off. 

 

Another thing to keep in mind is that he could honestly just want out of the relationship and this is his "get our of jail free" card.  He makes it sound like he is doing you a favor. 

 

But we don't know him and we don't know your relationship.

 

I want you to take a look at our Depression and Relationships Review where you can find a ton of articles on this very topic.  Especially read the member comments and posts.  Unfortunately when we hear such stories there usually isn't a happy ending with reconciliation.  I wish more people would write with the happy endings when they happen.  But usually...one partner is kept hanging and waiting long after the relationship is over. 

 

You must decide for yourself how you wish to handle this.  If he is going to bail over this...what happens when other bad things happen?  You do have to think about yourself and what is best for you.  You can check up on him if you feel that is appropriate but I would not get suckered into ambivalence where he uses you to lean on but doesn't commit to a relationship. 

 

I know this must be heartbreaking for you.  You offered to be there for him and he turned that support down.  It is up to him now to get himself together.  You can't save him and this is not your role. 

 

Let us know if you can...what happens.  You will get through this.

 

MM

Reply
2/17/12 12:37pm

FightorFlight-

Firstly, love your name.  Pretty much sums up exactly how we're feeling, huh?  I'm sorry that this happened to you right before Valentines Day.  I know it's just a day to a lot of people, but it doesn't really help matters. It seems our situations are very similar, and though I regret you having to go through this, it's nice to know we aren't the only ones. I'm just wondering if you've heard from him or seen any improvement, or at least you are feeling any better. Hope all is well.

 

-JWTH

Reply
2/17/12 1:59pm

You might check out this site: http://www.storiedmind.com/relationships-crisis/

 

The author of this site has some especially good insight into how men's depression affects their relationships, because he has been there himself.

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4165) >
By FightorFlight— Last Modified: 02/17/12, First Published: 02/09/12