Saturday, June 02, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Tuesday, September 21, 2010 Indi asks

Q: Is it normal for a person with depression to cope in this manner?

I'm 17 and I was diagnosed with depression in the middle of last year - I've finally started getting back on track with everyday life.

However, some of my friends are now depressed which is very stressful. One of them claims to have depression but I find it really difficult to believe/understand her. All she does is talk about depression and all her symptoms whilst smiling (all the time - nothing else) and she's told almost all the girls in our year level that she has it. She doesn't draw away from anyone or burst into tears. She claims to self-harm badly, then tells other people that she was too scared to do it. She shows everyone scratches on her wrists that she's made with tweezers - isn't this attention-seeking? I feel confused, and angry - the way in which she is acting does not seem like depression at all, and she's gaining attention and support for this hypocritical behaviour. I find it upsetting sitting with my friends when all she does it talk about 'depression' and harming herself and suicide in a joking manner. Is this normal for someone with depression to 'cope' in this manner, or is she experiencing some other illness like borderline personality disorder?

Answer This
Answers (1)
9/21/10 11:39pm

Hello, Indi.  I do think it's possible that your friend is depressed, even though it appears that she's seeking attention.  Some people can put on the smiley face routine, which usually is an attempt to hide it (even from yourself).  Has anyone suggested she be evaluated by a psychologist?  Perhaps you or one of her other friends could bring up this question with the school counselor or with her parent(s) so that she can get help.  Even if she is just trying to get attention, there's a reason for that and she may feel she needs help of some kind and doesn't know how to ask for it.

 

Beyond that, there's not much else you can do except maybe try to sit down and talk with her to find out what her "depression" is all about.  You might then be able to figure out better where this is coming from.  Don't judge her too harshly as she may be in more pain than you realize.  Everyone experiences things differently, so it isn't always helpful to compare each others' symptoms - that's best left to professionals.

 

Don't know if this has helped much, but please let us know if we can be of more help.

Reply
9/24/10 9:47pm

Hi Judy. Yes my friend has seen a psychologist group, she sees the school counsellor herself and I've been to see her about all of this too. She is also on antidepressants and has been for a while now but they don't appear to be working because she keeps talking about committing suicide and cutting herself. She's also been to a psychiatric hospital for 3 weeks at one point and at another point, 2 days.

 

I suppose it is unhelpful to compare symptoms - I just feel so angry. I guess I didn't get the support she is getting because I was so worried about how I would affect everyone so I just hid what was going on and then my Mum ended up finding out how I was feeling. But I didn't tell my friends at school for ages, I just didn't want to worry them.

But I don't understand why she talks about depression all the time. Doesn't someone with depression find it difficult to talk about all that sort of stuff until they start getting better? Her talking about it all the time is affecting everyone in the group; one of them has become really depressed and she cut herself and it wasn't scratches, it was worse, and another one of my friends looks like a zombie because she's so stressed - I can't even stand sitting in the group now because that is all she talks about. If someone changes the subject, she will inevitably bring it back there.

After she came back from the psychiatric hospital she talked about self harming and suicide even more and horrific stories that happened there because of what all the girls there were talking about, and after she came back that was when she started scratching herself with tweezers. She keeps saying she's going to commit suicide and getting taken home. She wants to go back to the psychiatric hospital because she says she can 'relate' to the girls there - if she enjoys relating to other girls who have depression she's never going to want to get better.

The only problem is she's always been that attention seeking, exaggerating girl - even before all of this. So you can never tell if she's telling the truth, exaggerating or making up stories - but you just can't not take a suicidal statment seriously! She's putting so much pressure and responsibility on us.

She's been at home for a while and is coming back to school next term.

 

I just don't know what to do.

Reply
9/24/10 11:42pm

That's a tough spot to be in, Indi.  You don't know if what you're seeing is real or an attempt to get attention - either way, she's sick.  Maybe you and your friends can come up with a way of handling this whenever she talks about it, like telling her that you just can't listen to it any more, it's bringing the rest of you down and unless she takes responsibility for herself and tries to get better, it's too difficult to be there for her.  I had to do that once with a friend of mine.  Yes, she was mad for a while, but she eventually got over it, quit talking about suicide, for the most part, and we're still friends today, 20 years later.

 

Maybe another thing you can do is go with your friends to talk to the school counselor and ask for suggestions about how to cope with this.  Whatever you can do, you should do it because you need to take care of yourselves.  I hope you'll let us know how this goes - good luck.

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4165) >
By Indi— Last Modified: 12/27/10, First Published: 09/21/10