Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Thursday, October 27, 2011 Kyle asks

Q: I'm the concerned brother of someone who can't get to school.

She is 14 years old and trying to get to 8th grade but just can't... She is brilliant, (She took some sort of "smartness" test that I don't know too much about and was in the 99%), she is beautiful, she has rich parents, she doesn't want much in the way of designer clothes or phones or anything like that but if she did I have no doubt that she'd get it. She has fun at school or at least doesn't find it horrible. Everyday after school and on the weekends she is cheery and happy and fun to be around. Why can't she get to school? My parents having to physically get her out of bed put her clothes on and drag her through the school door and leave while she cries and refuses the whole way but once they leave, and there is no way she is getting away from it, she is fine, has fun with her friends, does whatever a wonderful person does in a well above average school. That seems to be her only problem. On days where she can't be forced to get to school she feels fine once she's not going. She often goes to school after hours for their football games and activities and things of that nature. My parents thought she was the problem at first, so they sent her to a mental institution for a while, thought she was rehabilitated. She still was unable to get into school. My parents thought public school was the problem then, so they sent her to the private school of her choice for what I would call and exorbitant amount of money, (they could send her to college twice over for that amount of money), she loves it but still can't walk in the doors. They really want this to work so they've been trying to get her in for two or three weeks now and there is only about a 50/50 success rate. Today my dad decided that it was her again, it's not the school. Since it is still the trial run he won't take that much money out of his retirement for the exact same thing that happened at the public school. I don't blame him. She is breaking our family. My father feels awful. My mother feels awful. I feel slightly sad about my sister and awful that my father feels awful and that the fact that she is starting to cause tension between my mother and father. (not too much for it to jeopardize their relationship yet.... yet) I have no idea what I can do to help. I might not even be able to help but is there something that any of us can do? What is the problem? Do we get her more counseling? Do we change it from once a week to twice or three times a week? Do we mess with her medicine that she is taking that is almost totally dedicated to reducing anxiety? I'm lost and she needs help.
Answer This
Answers (2)
Merely Me, Health Guide
10/29/11 11:11am

Hello Kyle

 

You are a good brother to be so caring and compassionate about your sister.

 

Does she have a diagnosis of some sort?

 

This may not be an option for your family but can she be homeschooled? 

 

Is school phobia the issue for your sister?  I had this as a child and I wrote about school phobia and my experience for our ADHD site.  For me it was a fear of my environment...I lived in a rough section of town and just getting to school was dangerous.  Doesn't sound like this is the case for your sister.  But too...it may be that something happening at school is upsetting.  Is she being bullied in any way.  Is there a reason why she wants to stay home? 

 

Only your sister can know why she doesn't want to go to school. 

 

Let us know what happens.  Thank you for reaching out here.

Reply
10/29/11 12:55pm

She has been homeschooled. It was hard to get her to do any work because it was too dumbed down for her. She felt like she was having to do stuff for someone two or three grades lower. Either way I think you might be on to something with the phobia idea. I'll be sure to check out what you wrote and see if that applies.

Reply
Merely Me, Health Guide
10/29/11 3:18pm

Hi again

 

Is there something going on at home where she feels perhaps that she needs to be there?  Is she worried about your parents for example?

 

This is a difficult topic to comment upon because we don't know the full story and also...we are not therapists.  This seems to be an issue which requires a professional to help sort out.

 

Homeschooling is extremely variable in the methods and approaches used.  I have been homeschooling for some years now for my son who has autism.  If your sister is gifted...she may need to be taught in a way to maximize her interest.  She may simply be bored with traditional teaching methods.  Some people opt for an approach called "unschooling" which suits some children.

 

Let us know how things turn out.  I wish you, your sister, and your family the very best.

Reply
10/27/11 10:17am

Hi, Kyle.  We aren't medical professionals here, so can only guess by what you're telling us.  It sounds, first of all, like even thought she's been in some kind of "rehabilitation" setting, she didn't get a proper diagnosis or subsequent treatment.  Is she seeing a therapist regularly?  She might have some kind of phobia, or something might be going on at school that causes her anxiety, I don't know.  I think your father may be right in not wanting to waste more of his retirement savings on trying another school because it appears this has happened with every school she's been to.  I would focus on finding a good mental health professional to get to the bottom of it, assuming she's had a physical exam and ruled out any possible medical problems.  You sound like a really caring brother and son.  I hope your parents are able to find some good help for your sister; let us know if we can be of further help to you.  Thanks for visiting our site and for your question.  I wish you all the best.

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4165) >
By Kyle— Last Modified: 10/29/11, First Published: 10/27/11