Saturday, June 02, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone.Try it today!

Friday, March 11, 2011 noodle90 asks

Q: What's wrong with me or is it him that's wrong?

I don't think I have depression but I have been quite miserable for some time. I started dating a guy that was everything I've been waiting for, for years. We were happily enjoying falling in love with each other but during our relationship my dad died very suddenly with no pre illness. It has been a major shock as he was young and healthy (he was a sports man). My ex supported me wonderfully and helped with things I will always be greatful for. He became my life line and our relationship moved forward very quickly as he put his life on hold to be with me and look after me 24/7. We were blissfully happy even through this pain but I felt guilty and didn't want to be dependant on him forever. I tried to tell him I wanted things to change so that we'd both have more space for our own lives. I only intended for us to have a healthier more balanced relationship onces we had a little space and said I couldn't love him at that moment because the funeral was coming up and emotionally I felt like I couldn't love anyone til it was over (which I now know to be true). He went very quiet and although I stayed with him that night and he went to church with me the next day, after church he broke up with me saying he was emotionally exhausted and that he wanted to be alone because he was still hurting from his past. He offered to remain friends but over Christmas suddenly changed his mind and after trying to get in touch with him for several weeks (he ignored all my calls and texts), he said he never wanted to speak to me again and that he never loved and that the person that he was with me wasn't really him. He also claimed that my love for him wasn't real and that I only want him back because I want him to replace my dad. We study together and I see him a lot but he has said anything to me since New Year's. I desparately want to reconcile with him as I don't believe he was pretending to be happy with me but I don't know how. I've been coping well with the loss of my dad and my family keep each other strong but I found someone I truly loved and although I won't love him forever (if he were to ignore me for year for example) and that I will move on I hope I won't have to because my heart has chosen him. Is he right am I feeling heart break or grief or could I be depressed. And it possible to be with someone through such intense emotion and not care one bit once the relationship is over. He acts as though we never met and seems to be some happy enjoying the single life which causes me the most pain. I've recently to get back into my studies and things are going so well I'm getting involved in a lot things and many opportunities have come up but inside I still feel pain. When ever I see him I feel weak and I have to focus all of my energy to stoop my self crying in front of him.
Answer This
Answers (2)
John Folk-Williams, Health Guide
3/14/11 7:44pm

I don't see this as a case of either one of you being wrong. You were speaking truthfully when you said you felt you couldn't love him until the experience of the funeral was over, and I can see why he could be deeply hurt by this. Perhaps he felt he had given his love and support without reservation - and from what you say that was a powerful part of the relationship, confirming how strong the bond was between you. It's easy to see that he would be shocked by your suddenly pulling away - however legitimate the reason. From the extreme nature of his reaction, I would imagine he felt betrayed.

 

My wife and I went through something like that after she had given me unstinting support during a major illness. Not long after, I was once again depressed and separated myself from her emotionally. That was more than she could handle at that point and felt hopeless about the relationship. We put things back together, but it took a long time since I had damaged the trust between us.

 

I don't know if your friend is depressed or not, or if it was depression that had something to do with your pulling away from him. But it's easy to trigger a feeling of betrayal in an intense relationship and perhaps that is what he's been through. Expressing understanding for his likely feelings when you told him about your need to be on your own for a while might be one thing to communicate. Backing off for a while after making that clear might be helpful.

 

John

Reply
3/11/11 6:26pm

I think sometimes it is easy to "over commit" to someone you love during a low point in their lives.  You want to be there for them and be everything to them.  As you say, he "put his life on hold to be there" for you.  Maybe this left him feeling really vulnerable so he is withdrawing all his attentions and love right now in order to cope with his own feelings.  Also, it may have stung him when you said you had to get through your dad's funeral before you could return the kind of love he was giving you.  (Is this what you were saying to him?)  Some people get their feelings hurt really easily.  If I were you, I would just back off and let him do his own thing for now.  If there was really love between the two of you, I think you will eventually get back together, but don't try to force it.  He has to get past this vulnerability issue like you had to get through your dad's funeral, before he can move forward.

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (4165) >
By noodle90— Last Modified: 03/15/11, First Published: 03/11/11