Thursday, June 20, 2013

Myths about Coconut and MCT Oils

By David Mendosa, Health Guide Tuesday, March 27, 2012
One type of saturated fat is especially valuable for those of us who have diabetes. Oils like coconut and MCT are the easiest for us to use, as I have written in my last four posts here, including “The Best Saturated Fats.”But too many people avoid these great fats because they believe my...
Anonymous
anonymous
3/29/12 7:28pm

again, thanks for your ability to clarify and simplify these concepts -- just "cast my ballot" attesting to the value of your series on oils and fats by ordering the coconut oil, the gheee, and the mct...look forward to trying them

 

thanks! david,

mike

 

ps: why does dr rosedale prefer hard boiled eggs (or at least boiled eggs) and discourage scrambled eggs? do the temperatures or cooking techniques effect changes in the eggs?

David Mendosa, Health Guide
3/29/12 8:22pm
Thank you, Mike. I have passed on your excellent question about eggs to Dr. Rosedale. When he answers, I will let you know. David
Anonymous
RiFi
3/29/12 8:42pm

I'm really not sure if this information is accurate, but according to Leo Galland, author of The Fat Resistance Diet:

 

"If the yolk is broken and then fried or scrambled, the cholesterol in the yolk is oxodised. This produces toxic cholesterol by-products that are far more dangerous than cholesterol itself."

 

I wouldn't recommend this book per se, because many of Galland's ideas are at odds with David's more recent posts. Still, it does have some little gems.

 

 

David Mendosa, Health Guide
3/30/12 10:04am

Dear Mike,

 

This morning I received a reply from Dr. Rosedale to your excellent question. This is what he wrote:

 

"As far as eggs it does have to do with the cooking technique. When eggs are boiled underwater they will not get hotter than 212° at sea level, less than that at higher elevations, and exposure to oxygen is quite minimal. When one scrambles an egg, they mix oxygen with the cholesterol at high temperature, accelerating oxidation of the cholesterol and therefore making it potentially harmful."

 

I am so glad that you asked! I am going to poach my eggs this morning instead of frying them as I have for a while.

 

Best regards,

 

David

Anonymous
anon
3/30/12 11:41pm

goodness, that was quick!

 

thanks for the answer --- it was just what i was looking for

Anonymous
anon
3/30/12 11:43pm

thank you. kind of figured the answer would be something like this --- thanks for your input  :-)

Anonymous
mghu
4/ 4/12 9:49am

I'm also wondering if the same oxidizing effect happens when eggs are beaten and used in cooking, e.g. to bind elements together, or in baking (with almond and other low carb "flours") ?

David Mendosa, Health Guide
4/ 4/12 10:35am

It depends on how high the heat is on what you are cooking.

Anonymous
mghu
4/ 4/12 11:06am

Thank you, David. Very interesting discussion.  Eggs in this context are not subjected to very high heat for one thing, almond flour burns quite easily.  So care is required.

Anonymous
Diabetic too
4/ 5/12 6:57pm

Dear friends and fellow diabetics

I respect David’s advice. But palm oil is off limits for me.

The harvesting of palm oil is destroying the habitat of one of (If not the most) endangered primate in the world. The orangutan is so like us; except for one thing: its survival depends on the palm forests. If you want to protect the world's few orangutans DO NOT BUY ANYTHING THAT EVEN CONTAINS PALM OIL. Please. Campaign to have palm oil listed as an ingredient on food labels so that you can avoid supporting this trade.

David Mendosa, Health Guide
4/ 5/12 7:29pm

Thank you for posting this comment. I for one will not even try to buy palm oil again.

 

David

Anonymous
Diabetes too
4/ 6/12 9:41pm

Thank you, David. It's not always easy to know what might damage the ecolgical balance, is it? But we can survive without palm oil, so we should try to. Best wishes, always.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (3906) >
By David Mendosa, Health Guide— Last Modified: 04/06/12, First Published: 03/27/12