Sunday, June 03, 2012

Treating Insulin Not Weightloss in Low Carbohydrates Diabetes Diet & Nutrition

By David Mendosa, Health Guide Saturday, December 29, 2007
Low-carb advocates are already jumping all over the American Diabetes Association for the new "Nutrition Recommendations" that the organization published yesterday. That policy statement, published in a supplement to the January 2008 issue of Diabetes Care, provides only limited endorsement of a l...
Glycemic Index Lags Behind Low-Carb Acceptance
12/29/07 4:14pm

More evidence in favour of  low carb diets is pouring in every day.  I just did a query on Google News "low carb diet for diabetes"

 

The following article is an excellent read : "The Debate Goes On: Carbs In or Carbs Out?"

 

verdungal

 

 

 

David Mendosa, Health Guide
12/29/07 5:07pm

Dear Verdungal,

 

Thank you.  But what is the URL?

 

David 

David Mendosa, Health Guide
12/29/07 7:24pm

Dear Verdungal,

 

Good article. Thanks for sending the link. I actually found it at:

http://www.diabeteshealth.com/read/2007/12/27/5606/html

 

I especially liked Professor Feinman's comment.

 

David 

12/29/07 6:07pm
I was diagnosed about a year ago. It didn't take too long to determine that (as I learned in many books and websites) I could easily control my BG with low carb, minimal exercise -- a brisk 15 minute walk after meals could drop my BG 50 points -- and herbs such as cinnamon. With no drugs at all I went from A1C of 8.5 to 5.5 and lost 25 pounds. Then I went to the diabetes class and had a meeting with a nutritionist/DE who wanted me to eat 40-50% carbs, the ADA recommendation she said. That's crazy, I said. Eating that way will cause me to NEED to take drugs, all of which have side effects. Fergit it! Now it appears the ADA has changed their tune, but only for weight loss. It's a start. But it's really discouraging when the agency we should be able to look to for guidance for diabetes is so clueless about nutrition, like the AHA recommending that we eat trans fats. It makes me wonder about drug company conflicts of interest behind the scenes.
12/29/07 6:12pm
I didn't mean to imply in my previous post that the AHA HAD recommended eating trans fats; they have NOT. I just meant that if they had, it would be as ludicrous as the ADA's recommendation of 40-50% carbs.
Anonymous
whimsy2
1/ 1/08 12:24am

Well, okay, goody for the ADA, they now admit that low carbing is good for weight loss. But what about the really IMPORTANT benefit -- after all, the ADA is the American DIABETIC Association.  So why can't they just admit that low carbing is an excellent way to help control diabetes???

 

1/ 2/08 4:24pm
I have type 2 diabetes and have been following a a moderate protein, moderate to low carbs and moderate fat diet. My A1c has gone from 11.2 to 5.2, colesterol from 205 to 135 and weight from 205 to 165. This has been steady for over a year. I read a recent article by Ron Rosedale of the Rosedale diet in a diabetic magazine and am currently reading his book. He recommends high fats as well as staying away from bread, pasta , rice. You should only eat high fiber carbs. I don't know about high fats. It would be difficult to get that without high protein, but I only eat low glycemic carbs such as green vegetables. It seems to be working. 
1/ 2/08 6:28pm

Finally!  This gives me encouragement to continue in my efforts at low-carb eating.  I got tired of debating and fighting with Dr.s and nutritionists that insisted I follow a hi-carb diet for my diabetes.  When I did follow lo-carb my A1C was below 6!  My blood sugars were in the normal range and my family physician was willing to start cutting back on my meds!  Even so, the "specialists" continued to berate me for not including more carbs in my diet!

 

Thanks for the encouragement! 

1/ 2/08 7:24pm
What is the definition of a low-carb diet.  I try to keep carbs from all sources at 45 grams per meal and 15 grams per snack.  My A1C has been at 5.5 for the past 3 1/2 years.  No meds for 3 1/2 years.  I am a vegetarian and limit my carbs to whole grains. I do use Dreamfields pasta.  I'm just trying to get a handle on what the ADA and the readers define as low-carb.  Thanks to all and Happy New Year.
David Mendosa, Health Guide
1/ 3/08 12:52am

Dear Pam,

 

There isn't any signle definition of low-carb. But the one that Dr. Bernstein uses probably is the most authoritative. I described it in my article just before this one.

 

David 

Anonymous
Rogerhlmn
1/ 3/08 8:34am

Pam,

There's no official definition of "low-carb", but your 165 grams per day is definitely not it. Yes, you're eating less carbs than the average American, but still not considered low.

 

Dr Bernstein's diabetic diet is 30 grams per day.

Atkins Induction is 20 grams per day (for limited time).

Protein Power (in the old version of the book I have) is 50 grams per day.

These are "low-carb" diet plans.

 

Consider this---Each gram of carbs eaten can raise our blood-glucose (bg) by 3mg/dl to 5 mg/dl. Multiply that number by the amount of carbs you're eating & see what you're giving your body to deal with. The whole problem of diabetes is an inability of our bodies to properly use the glucose in our blood, the vast majority of which is caused by carbs.

So, does it make logical sense to eat a lot of the very food that "is the problem"?

Anonymous
Bodyhealthadvisor
1/ 6/08 2:23am
I agree that low carb is one aspect especially for diabetics. However, also remember that it is the simple sugars that enter the bloodstream fastest, causing a sudden jump in the blood gluscose leves. Hence, stay away from simple sugars and go for the complex carbohydrates instead. I'll love to share more on my personal blog at http://www.bodyhealthadvisor.com
Anonymous
Henry
1/ 9/08 12:12am

5 years ago I was diagnosed with type 2 diabetes. Dr. prescribed Metformin, diet,and exercise. 1) When I was told I had diabetes, I was in shock. From that very first day I took control. First, Diabetes can, and will, if it gets the chance, to attack every organ of your body. Lose weight and exercise. Your body must move to use up the sugar energy. In 6 months I went from 210 lbs. to 150 lbs. Cut out the carbs, add more vegies and fish, and learn what foods PRODUCE the least amounts of sugar. Within 8 months I was off the medication and remain so. What I say to anyone who is diagnosed with diabetes : "If you want to live longer with a relatively healthy body,

learn everything you can about your body

and your diabetes. Diabetes affects each body a little differently. Only you can beat your type 2 diabetes.

David Mendosa, Health Guide
1/ 9/08 10:44am

Dear Henry,

 

Amen!

 

David 

By David Mendosa, Health Guide— Last Modified: 06/03/12, First Published: 12/29/07