Sign in

or Register now

MyDiabetesCentral.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Sunday, July, 27, 2008

Old Ideas and the ADA

by  Gretchen Becker
Wednesday, January 02, 2008
Gretchen Becker
Gretchen Becker
Close
Author, Humorist

Gretchen Becker studied biology for 8 years at Radcliffe/Harvard, w...

Gretchen Becker

Recent Posts:
View All
"Just as important as having ideas is getting rid of them."

 

So said the late Francis Crick, who along with James Watson worked out the basic structure of DNA in the early 1950s. His remark was quoted in a 1978 New Yorker article on the history of DNA (sometimes ...

  1. What a great post!
    Anonymous
    Wednesday, January 02, 2008 at 03:45 PM
    Changing one's mind is probably the most useful asset we humans own. the Edge web site has 163 essays by people who... changed their mind. This is one of my favourites: http://www.edge.org/q2008/q08_16.html#bharucha --buck
    reply
    re: What a great post!
    Gretchen Becker
    Saturday, January 05, 2008 at 11:17 AM
    Thanks, Buck. Good essay.
    reply
  2. Old Ideas
    Virginia Page
    Thursday, January 03, 2008 at 12:02 PM
    Gretchen's essay is excellent--about old thoughts continuing their grip on established institutions, especially the ADA. I have similar criticisms of the American Cancer Society. Oh well, I could add to the list the Pentagon, State Department, Dept. of Justice and...and...and... Either we revise our thinking about important issues with reality-based insights, or we stay curled up in squalid intellectual fetal positions.
    reply
    re: Old Ideas
    Gretchen Becker
    Saturday, January 05, 2008 at 11:19 AM
    I agree, Virginia. I'd add more but I've got to go and curl up in a fetal position <G>.
    reply
  3. Cascade...
    Nicky
    Thursday, January 03, 2008 at 05:53 PM
    And when the ADA do change their minds - or at least get all of their minds on the same page, the range of opinions on the ADA site is bewildering, once you get past the vox pop stuff - then we'll have a cascade of support for low carb from all the other diabetic associations across the globe - and I'll actually start paying subs to Diabetes UK Big Smile
    reply
    re: Cascade...
    Gretchen Becker
    Saturday, January 05, 2008 at 11:23 AM

    I hope the other organizations do consider LC diets. BTW, I was interested that when the woman in the BBC sitcom "Waiting for God" got type 2 diabetes, she had to listen to a lecture from a dietician telling her not to eat bananas because they have too many carbs.

     

    But of course, it's an old sitcom. 


    reply
  4. Old & Outdated ADA
    BeardedOne
    Friday, January 04, 2008 at 11:42 AM
    On the money article, Gretchen.  Whenever I see an endorsement of anything by the ADA or a recommendation by the ADA I run in the opposite direction.  I am sure there are many many like me.
    reply
    re: Old & Outdated ADA
    Gretchen Becker
    Saturday, January 05, 2008 at 11:25 AM

    Yes, Oh BeardedOne. It's very sad, because the ADA could help so many people but they seem to be doing the opposite.

     

    I recently got a mailing from them in which they warned people not to try LC diets on their own because their BG levels might go down. 


    reply
    re: re: Old & Outdated ADA
    BeardedOne
    Saturday, January 05, 2008 at 12:30 PM

    Yes, I'm afraid Big Pharma has a hold of them & will not let go.  Money speaks & the people suffer.  I am so very thankful for folks like you, Mendosa, Bernstein, et al.

    Stand for the truth & run from the lies.

     

     


    reply
  5. Old ideas and the ADA
    whimsy2
    Wednesday, January 09, 2008 at 12:00 AM

    You actually got a letter from the ADA warning people against a low carb diet because it might make peoples' BGs go down??? Unbelievable!  Isn't that supposed to be the goal of good diabetic control? 

     

    Conversely, if you don't get your BGs down to non-diabetic levels you can get blind, need kidney transplants, get heart disease,  have amputations, etc. etc. 

     

    And the ADA is supposed to be SUPPORTING diabetics?

     

    Geez!


    reply
    re: Old ideas and the ADA
    Gretchen Becker
    Wednesday, January 09, 2008 at 10:12 AM

    Whimsy, it wasn't a letter but an ad urging me to join the ADA. Then it had a list of "myths" about diabetes, like telling people it's OK to eat sugar because it's no worse than starch.

     

    One of the myths was "It's easy to go on an Atkins-type diet." They said it's dangerous without medical supervision because your BGs might plummet and you'd go low. Of course if you're injecting tons of insulin on the theory that you're eating tons of carbs, this is true. 

     

    But the impression one got was that LC diets are dangerous. 


    reply
  6. ADA and food catagories
    Michael Hurney
    Monday, April 21, 2008 at 11:06 PM

    I've been a diabetic for over 50 years and it hurts and angers me when the ADA pushes carbs and restricts fats. Almost all of the people I see in my practice think that fat makes them fat including most diabetes health educators. Most of the diabetics are always trying to cut back on fat and still drinking regular sodas, sport drinks, and orange juice. Also, no one seems to be looking at how diabetics usually metabilize B vitamins poorly and how high carbs soothe feelings of depression, loneliness, and anger. Mike Hurney, LCSW-C


    reply
    re: ADA and food catagories
    Gretchen Becker
    Tuesday, April 22, 2008 at 09:49 AM

    It's sad, isn't it.


    reply

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Answer a Question

Still on disciplined low carb diet....

Answer This View all questions >
Healthcare 08