Sign in

or Register now

MyDiabetesCentral.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Friday, July, 25, 2008

Misleading Diabetes News Reports

by  Gretchen Becker
Wednesday, February 27, 2008
Gretchen Becker
Gretchen Becker
Close
Author, Humorist

Gretchen Becker studied biology for 8 years at Radcliffe/Harvard, w...

Gretchen Becker

Recent Posts:
View All
It seems as if almost every day there's a news story about diabetes, and most of these stories include misinformation and hyperbole.

 

The hyperbole occurs when some study shows a small difference in blood glucose cont...

  1. Misleading news reports
    Little Sue
    Friday, March 07, 2008 at 04:56 PM

    Thank you, Gretchen, I'm so pleased to see someone else gets as irritated as I do with these reports! 

     

    The news media seem obsessed with the idea that diabetes is something fat people get.   I know the truth is not so simple.  But I'm concerned that 'diabetic=fat' is the overwhelming message the public are receiving.  On one day, there might be a news story that a new gene has been identified which is implicated in one or another type of diabetes (in other words, there's a genetic component).  Next day, the same newsreader is spouting the obese=diabetic message!  Its also often stated or implied that weight loss and exercise can 'cure or prevent diabetes'.  Sometimes the phrase 'type 2' is used, but that's the only indication other types exist.

     

    I sometimes wish I had this 'tabloid news diabetes'.  No need for all those symptom-awareness campaigns or expensive research (often supported by donations from diabetics and their loved ones), or come to think of it, for all those injections I keep pumping in.  I just need to skip dessert and I'll be cured!!! 

     

    Figures vary, but apparently around 80% of type 2 diabetics are obese at diagnosis.  Am I the only one to spot that this means around 20% are NOT obese?  Surely if 20% had another common risk factor, there'd be publicity about it?  Instead it seems these 20% who don't fit the easy message are being ignored.  And made to feel guilty that their condition is 'their own fault'.

     

    Aside from my grumbling, there's a serious point here.  Diabetes UK estimates there are around 750,000 undiagnosed diabetics in the UK.  A proportion of those will have type 1, or non-obese type 2, or medication-induced diabetes. Maybe they've listened to the media messages, and think they're not at risk because they're not overweight? 


    reply
    re: Misleading news reports
    Gretchen Becker
    Friday, March 07, 2008 at 05:53 PM
    If you're a "thin type 2," have you been tested for LADA and MODY?
    reply
    re: re: Misleading news reports
    Little Sue
    Sunday, March 16, 2008 at 12:49 PM
    I'm actually a (thin) type 1. Which is one reason I find the diabetic=obese message annoying, but also sympathise with those who have thin type 2 or medication-induced diabetes. 
    reply

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Answer a Question

Metformin, can it raise your blood presure?

Answer This View all questions >
Healthcare 08