Saccharin, aspartame, sucralose. Which sugar substitute is best?
It used to be that we didn't have much choice. When we went to the supermarket, we could find various formulations of saccharin, and then aspartame and more recently, sucralose.
Stevia, which comes from a South American plant, has bee...
Featuring Content From:
By using this service, you accept our Terms of Use. Please read them. The consumer health information on is for informational purposes only and is not a substitute for medical advice or treatment for any medical conditions. You should promptly seek professional medical care if you have any concern about your health, and you should always consult your physician before starting a fitness regimen. Copyright © 2012 Remedy Health Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Gretchen,
I appreciate your information and review here and at wildlyfluctuating.com. I like the Stevita "spoonable stevia" blend of stevia and erythritol myself. I wonder if it's possible to find out what are the mystery "natural" flavors in Truvia. If it's natural, why not disclose their identity? I know that in some products "natural" means derived from things we wouldn't want to eat, like MSG, or that red food coloring in hot dogs and tofu dogs derived from squished beetles. I have been experimenting with using erythritol in low carb puddings and flax seed bread and cake formulations with good success. Due to your tip, I'll now try it in frozen desserts as well.
Having just recently visited the Denver ADA sponsored "Diabetes Expo" I was shocked to see how the sponsoring food suppliers were promoting many "low glycemic" and "gluten free" products as diabetic friendly, where these products contain many combinations of sugar, disruptive alcohol sugars and other high carbohydrate ingredients. It's scary to consider how sales driven corporate marketing departments continue to influence the public's knowledge base with misinformed and misleading beliefs about foods.
Thanks again to you and David Mendosa for giving us another view of the diabetes landscape to navigate from. I hope that you will continue to write informative (and humorous) pieces to keep us all on a better track.
Sincerely,
Barry from Boulder
Hi Barry,
There are several other sweeteners being sold on the Internet that I haven't seen in local stores, and I didn't include them in the review because I was focusing on what you can find at your supermarket (except for erythritol, which I've never found there). One of them also had "natural flavors" and when I corresponded with them to find out what they were, they said it was "proprietary information."
Another sweetener listed the ingredients, and they didn't include anything that would produce a sweet taste. Their site had an article by a food chemist, with a link to his e-mail, so I wrote to him. He said he hadn't given them permission to use his article. He also said that some compound that can be extracted from orange peels will give a sweet taste when it's hydrogenated. Because these compounds haven't been approved by the FDA for use as sweeteners, the manufacturers might be trying to get around the rules by listing "natural flavorings" or "orange peel extract."
I once saw something labeled as containing "natural flavoring" and asked what it was and it turned out to be sugar.
Whoa! Natural flavoring as SUGAR! Outrageous. And, hydrogenated anything makes me worried about it's negative effect on our inflammatory and T cell systems, even if it seems to innocently come from citrus peels...
FYI, I buy my erythritol directly from my favorite health food store, "Vitamin Cottage". I think David Mendosa got his at "WholePaycheck" (WholeFoods).
Thanks again.
-Barry from Boulder
Barry that "sugar listed as natural flavoring" was on some sausage sold at a local sausage shop. It's possible that it wouldn't be permitted with larger commercial products but I don't trust anyone in this respect.