Sunday, February 12, 2012

Miracle Foods for Diabetes Deserve Skepticism

Written by

Gretchen Becker

Gretchen Becker

Tue, July 14, 2009

Additional Posts

View all Posts »

Normal 0 [Humor]   Almost every day, it seems, we see a "news" article in which one food is named as having great benefit for people with diabetes, or those at risk. For example, blueberries, milk, lean beef, and now pork.   When you look closely, you always find that the "research...
7/14/09 4:19pm

unfortunately, this article only looks at the benefits of eating australian pork, who are quite skinny pigs as compared to their american counterparts- the globalized pork industry here has created the super pig, via confined feeding of condensed corn product, steroids, and antibiotic use- so there is an obesity epidemic in pigs here, whereas the australian pig receives better healthcare via socialized medicine- no surprise, then, that eating a healthier pig has healthier results- in fact overall, eating wild boar would have the healthiest glycemic profile, but as you point out, nobody will sponsor that study

7/14/09 6:42pm

Frank, I think you missed the main point of the satire, which is that the pork probably had very little to do with the results of the study. They said they used, "a high protein, lower carbohydrate diet that includes regular pork intake in conjunction with resistance exercise."

 

The diet also undoubtedly included regular chicken, fish, cheese, eggs, and beef intake, but the headline said, "Eat More Pork."

 

They didn't compare high-pork vs low-pork diets. They just put overweight people on a lower-carb diet and gave them exercise and found that they lost weight. Because there's no reference, it's difficult to check details.

 

The story about "lean pork" is also illustrated with slides of pork with oodles of fat.

 

 

7/14/09 4:58pm

GREAT!!!! As usual Gretchen!

7/14/09 6:45pm

Thanks Jude. Do they eat a lot of pork where you live?

7/14/09 7:39pm

Quite a bit at the frequent barbeques, feasts, festivals and fiestas. Anytime there is a BIG group 'feed' there's a roast pig or six and a roast cow or 2. But chicken, fish, seafood and (ugh!) SPAM are most common on a daily basis. It's all in cost. And alas typical diabetes control is to have the doc up your meds.  

7/24/09 9:12pm

Jude, Unfortunately too many people here on the mainland also want to be able to eat as they always have with the help of popping more pills.

Anonymous
Anonymous
7/20/09 4:04am

Nice for someone to interject a note of levity into this potentially grim topic.  Unfortunately there are probably people out there who can't stand anyone making light of anything, and will proclaim the danger of joking about something so serious.  Some people just never figured out Kisshow to have fun.

Incidentally, I'm a type 2.

7/24/09 8:43pm

Thanks, Anonymous.

7/24/09 8:02pm

You should review actual science articles rather than opinion pieces. I have included an example on how insulin is beneficial to bones

http://ajpendo.physiology.org/cgi/content/full/289/5/E735

 

Further I advise everyone to think of insulin as diabetes intelligence 2009 nkirk1

 

This link below talks about insulin and the brain

http://jn.nutrition.org/cgi/content/abstract/125/11/2768

 

Study those science articles, avoid opinions and articles seeking to promote drugs simply for profit.

7/24/09 8:54pm

Archie, I'm not sure what opinion pieces you are speaking of. I read zillions of primary sources and comment on the ones that I think are most important. The pork story I satirized had nothing to do with promoting drugs, so I really don't follow your logic.

Anonymous
Tiger Lily
8/ 5/09 9:35pm

priceless!

 

thanks for the chuckle Gretchen :D

 

8/ 5/09 10:17pm

Thanks for the comment.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (3731) >