Vitamins - Introduction

Regulating Quality

Regulation of dietary supplements by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is a complex issue.

Labels on vitamins and other dietary supplements now include nutrient information and list all ingredients, including identifying parts of plants from which ingredients may be taken. Unlike the labels for drugs, however, labels for vitamins and supplements may not claim to prevent or treat any specific disease. Labels for vitamins and supplements include one of the following:

Health claim ? description of how the substance may reduce the risk of a health-related condition,
Nutrient claim ? description of the amount of the nutrient in the product, or
Structure/function claim -- description of how the product may affect organs or systems of the body, without claiming to prevent or treat specific disease.

The quality of dietary supplements depends on the manufacturer and is not ensured by FDA. The US government does not require that supplements be standardized, meaning that the amounts or quality of nutrients may vary depending on the batch. So, more expensive supplements are not necessarily better than the less expensive ones. Government regulations are in the process of catching up to the boom in the supplement industry; in the meantime, some companies voluntarily adhere to rigorous quality controls, while others do not.

The US Pharmacopeia, an independent organization that sets quality standards for drugs, has also implemented standards for vitamins. Consumers may look for the USP label on products of companies that adhere to these standards. USP verification means the following:

What is in the bottle matches what is listed on the label.
There are no harmful levels of contaminants.
The supplement willbe absorbedproperly into the body.
It has been produced according to good manufacturing standards.

Before selling any supplement introduced after 1994, manufacturers must submit information as to why the product is considered safe for people. The FDA may refuse to allow it on the market if it finds the evidence insufficient. The FDA does not require manufacturers to provide any scientific evidence that dietary supplements are safe and effective before a product is sold (unlike drugs, which must be proven both safe and effective through clinical trials). If a supplement causes side effects in people once it is for sale, the government may place restrictions on the supplement or withdraw it from the market. The FDA may also withdraw products from the market if their labels are misleading or false.