HealthCare '08

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Sunday, November, 29, 2009
  • Font size

What Have Giuliani and Edwards Left Behind?

Craig Stoltz
Craig Stoltz
Close
Health Journalist

I'm former health editor at The Washington Post, veteran director...

Craig Stoltz

Wednesday, January 30, 2008
View All of Craig Stoltz's Posts
Whenever candidates drop out of a race, the first question is, Who's going to get their stuff?  News reports said that both Clinton's and Obama's people immediately started picking John Edwards' pockets--for delegates, supporters, fundraisers, gold teeth, etc.--while the former ...
  1. Being Presidential about Healthcare
    Megan Oltman
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 11:00 AM

    Craig - You made a very good point - Edwards bold idea will be missed, and I only hope the other candidates have the... hmmm... chutspah to be as bold about healthcare.  In the New Deal FDR took on tackling the huge national crisis that was the depression, and got Americans behind it.  In the Second World War we had a war effort that united people in a common cause as never before.  That was an example of being presidential.  We need a new president who is ready to be presidential about healthcare - a national crisis whose impact will only spread if not addressed effectively. 

     

    I'm a little disappointed I don't have a chance to vote for Edwards in Tuesday's primary.

     

    - Megan Oltman

    my blog: www.meganoltmanfreemybrain.typepad.com 

    Reply
  2. nothing left behind
    scott
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 12:14 PM

    I'm glad they're both off the campaign trail. Rudy is a phony (polished on stage and miserable in real life) and Edwards should be at home with his wife - practicing what he preaches.

     

    This, in my humble opinion, accentuates what Obama is trying to do with Health Care. And without the G-Man in the way, he might actually get it done.

    Reply
    re: nothing left behind
    Ernest Hayman
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 02:15 PM

    http://www.nytimes.com/2008/02/01/opinion/01krugman.html?_r=2&hp&oref=slogin&oref=slogin

    The always insightful Paul Krugman gives Edwards lots of credit for advancing the health care debate. Krugman also details the weakness of Obama's plan compared to Clinton's universal health care plan.

    Reply
    re: re: nothing left behind
    Craig Stoltz
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 04:25 PM

    Ernest--

     

    Thanks for this. I hadn't seen Krugman's piece. He does indeed assign credit to Edwards for being first with a proposal to extend care to all via a public-private plan.

     

    All good brain-food. Thanks again for the note. 

    Reply
    re: re: nothing left behind
    Joseph Brenner
    Sunday, February 24, 2008 at 05:35 PM
    I would like to know where these "working class voters" are who "tend to favor Clinton over Obama". They must be too busy working to vote.
    Reply
  3. John Edwards
    gail
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 02:41 PM
    Guiliani had nothing to leave...but Edwards had something that defeated him, something that has not been in a candidate....since FDR?...compassion for people..not corporations, the rich OR our corporate healthcare industry....sad..because I do not think anybody will pick that up...
    Reply
    re: John Edwards
    Nancy Henson
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 05:44 PM

    You are so right. I have followed John Edwards since he first ran for President with John Kerry. I've read everything I could about him. I think gross misintrpretations have been made about him such as suggestion that he lived in a huge mansion. Well the house may be big but they included the square footage of his barn. Was that fair. No. The media often is not fair if they can create sensationalism.

     

    Just like the issue of why isn't he staying home with his wife. His wife "wanted" him out there. She's a dynamic woman!  But now they will be working together for those in New Orleans that have been forgotten. That says it all about John Edwards.

     

    We have truly lost what would have been a great president.

     

    Nancy

    Reply
    re: re: John Edwards
    Ernest Hayman
    Friday, February 01, 2008 at 06:36 PM
    Nancy -- although I was never an Edwards supporter, the size of his house and the type of hair cut are absolutely no one elses concern. I wish him and his family well.
    Reply
  4. healthcare reform
    katie geiger
    Sunday, February 03, 2008 at 12:22 AM

    Hi Craig:

     I so agree with your post. 

     Personally, I liked Edward's thought process;we need...a Revolution! Let's not pay taxes until they create a health care that  is going to work for everyoneHeart  I don't know, would that even work?Blink

    a people's revolution would work; it is just getting everyone motivated...

    Maybe having a woman in command would get the job done....women biologically are the nuturer's.Roll Eyes

     

    raku

    Reply
  5. And...
    Diane
    Monday, February 04, 2008 at 10:05 PM
    And... what about those concidered "uninsurable".  Those who have had surgery gone badly, or have had too many complications for insurance to want to pick them up.  I'm sure John Edwards has thought about how to keep insurance for his wife at this point. I was excited to hear his comment about taking insurance away from the elected leaders till they find it for all.  I wonder about how the AMA and the insurance industry are financing these compaigns, and what effect that will have on any chance of changing a failing system.
    Reply
  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Thank you for your input