Thursday, February 16, 2012

Are You a Wheat-aholic?

Here's an experiment: Eliminate any food made with or containing wheat for the next four weeks and see what happens.   This means no bread, pasta, crackers, cookies, breads, chips, pancakes, waffles, breading on chicken, rolls, bagels, cakes, breakfast cereal. It doesn't matter if i...
Anonymous
anthony
10/23/07 9:22am
Realistically, how many people can eliminate all wheat from their diet?  I bet Dr. Davis hasn't.  His idea is interesting but not practical.  I bet some of the people he described regainded most of the weight they lost during the brief time they eliminated wheat products.  Human beings have eaten wheat for thousands of years.
Anonymous
Laura (About.com Low Carb Diets)
10/27/07 1:58pm

Thousands of years isn't actually all that long in the course of human evolution.  There's lots of evidence that the starchy foods we started eating around that time haven't done us much good.

 

If you found out you were allergic to wheat, you would find a way to make it work for the sake of your health.  I've been gluten-free for 10 years.  Yes, it's a huge adjustment at first, but it certainly can be done. 

 

When it comes to heart disease, I'm curious as to whether he has evidence that the effect comes from the wheat itself or whether it could be the general carb reduction which would usually result from cutting out wheat.

1/ 3/11 6:00am

I did. I eliminated all wheat of my diet. -that was more than a year ago. Unlike Dr. Davis' advise I did it gradually, though, and it wasn't the result of an intentioned exclusion of wheat, I just was trying to adjust my diet to my energetic requirements after I had to stop running for a while. First, I gave up eating pasta. Some time later, I stop buying the bread I used to eat with all my meals (some sort of French/Italian-like so claimed "whole"-grain bread bars). I still kept eating home-made baked bread to accompany with my breakfast. Eventually, gave up making this bread once I cut down regular physical activity.

Since then I haven't feel the urge to eat any wheat-derived food anymore, so I tend to believe Dr. Davis saying wheat may be in some extent addictive. I also gave up rice, and cut legumes drastically (I used to eat them on a daily bases for more than 15 years). Now I don't eat any cereals, potatoes while I've been avoiding the salt in my meals for almost 20 years, I don't add it and I don't buy and don't eat anything with added salt, that easy. I don't cook with oil, butter or yard and don't eat meat either. Instead, I often eat some dairy products (natural skimmed yoghourt), ground flaxseeds, row or steamed vegetables, some fruit (mostly apples and occasionally pineapple, although I used to eat more fruit before, grapes, oranges) and occasionally eat fish, seafood and some nuts. I only indulge in adding some fructose to my daily one or a couple of teas.

With for some such drastic diet you can imagine I don't suffer from insulin-resistance, diabetes, nor I have cardiovascular or obesity problems. My BMI has been about 20 for years or even a little lower, My blood pressure most times lower than 100/60 (and I am a male), and my basal heart rate between 30 and 40 bpm, even though I've never been a professional athlete, nor even close. The main physical exercise I usually do is an hour daily walk, occasional longer walks of up to 3-4 hours. I used to run 2-3 times a week, but in the last years I've cut it down despite my desires. Even so, I didn't get on weight, and I didn't lose much physical capacity (I can still run 5K in 20 minutes without previous training).

1/ 3/11 9:47pm

Your diet is just amazing :)

how did you do it? and how long did it take?

 

Im trying to eat completely healthy but there is so much processed and food with wheat out there..

 

Your life story of your eating habits is very inspiring :)

i hope you can share some tips on how to eat healthy and staying eating healthy all the time

Anonymous
Michelle G
10/25/07 3:55pm
I went wheat-free about 2 months ago and I will never go back. I suspected that I had celiac disease and eliminated all gluten and wheat from my diet. I found this to be really easy to do since I prefer fresh, non-processed foods anyway and without any other effort I lost about 10 pounds. I really wasn't even trying to lose any weight. After my tests came back and it turned out that I do not have celiac disease, I still do not eat that junk and have no problem avoiding it completely.
Anonymous
Neelesh
11/12/07 11:41am

I assume rice(staple food in South India) is worse than wheat, then. After having a heart attack at 30, and with high LP(a) levels, I am trying to reduce rice and increase wheat in my diet. This is a shocker indeed. Are all the cereals as bad?

 

Anonymous
Jenny
4/ 4/08 4:21pm
I would be interested in seeing any clinical studies or other scientific research that has appeared in any professional publications to back this up.  Anyone know where I could find some?
Anonymous
Dick
2/20/10 6:10pm

Sunlight is the best disinfectant.  Any research in this area that produces evidence that wheat is detrimental to one's health should be distributed widely as soon as possible.

 

I would like to see as many articles as people can find.

11/11/10 10:45pm

Check out the China Study, I found it at rawfoodsos.com. It was somewhat hard to understand all of it but very well written.

Anonymous
theo
7/10/08 2:27pm

experiment and try it. that's also data you can use. it's difficult for me to take any assertions at face value. and for years now i've always found it strange that eating wheat didn't make me feel good, and would be contrary to all the claims being made.

 

being asian, i now eat 2-3 oz of brown rice each night to balance out my meals as an alternative to white rice varieties. now i'm considering replacing that with oatmeal instead, or to cut rice out entirely. what i've found overall is that by reducing my sugar level, i run further, feel stronger, and think more clearly. the trick is how to do it on a daily basis as many meals require staples like [brown] rice.

 

anyways, i think at the very least, it's good to moderate and reduce the level of wheatstuff and let the evidence [or lack thereof] speak for itself. one doesn't have to rely on studies per se; it's easy to prove/disprove yourself.

Anonymous
IrvnX
5/14/09 12:16pm

I can try that-- it is my sugar laden granola I love, but perhaps that is wheat-free, and my chicken I can "bread" with ground cashews

11/ 5/10 1:03pm

Wait a minute... this researcher is lacking common sense; everything he mentions (normal varieties of pasta aside) is also loaded with estrace (soya) that converts to Estradiol-B.

 

Looks to me like the results he lists are accurate but in line with a four week cessation of the practice of self administering female steroids to oneself repeatedly throughout the day and have nothing whatsoever to do with wheat consumption.

To prove it's the wheat would require a double blind study where wheat is discontinued but this supplement is added to replace the missing estrace:

 

http://www.novonordisk.co.nz/media/NZ_HRT_ConsumerDataSheet/EstrofemCMI_12_02.pdf

(a phytoestrogen [isoflavone is not descriptive] supplement that relies on conversion to Estradiol-B for it's efficacy).

 

If apple juice came fortified with Dianabol this scientist could leverage the same experiment to attribute it's anabolic properties to the apple juice instead; that's not science.

 


 

1/ 3/11 6:10am

In the last 2 years I've increased soy-derived products in my diet (mainly soy milk and tofu) with feeling the slightest discomfort, and I am a male!

Therefore, for me the so claimed harmful effects attributed to soy phytosterols and phytoestrogens are just BS.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (6101) >

Health Centers