Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Selecting incontinence protection: do you prefer thin and discreet, or thicker and more absorbent?

I am curious how other incontinent adults select their protection, and whether the type of protection changes much over time. When I initially needed protection several years ago (for strong urge incontinence), I wore Depend and store brands. They aren't very absorbent, but I was concerned that people would be able to detect the protection under my clothes. Unfortunately, they are less than ideal for heavy wetting. As the years went on, I gravitated toward the most absorbent diapers (such as the Abena X Plus), which are bulky by comparison. I'm pretty sure nobody has detected them under casual (jeans) or work clothes (khakis).

 

So how does everyone select their level of protection?

5/28/08 8:32pm

Hello Craig,

 

You've asked the community a great question -- thank you. We'll wait for the helpful comments to come in. Keep writing and asking for feedback like this -- conversation stimulators are always good. There's always much to learn from each other.

 

Best,

Maria

7/23/08 12:36am

Hi, I think I've tried virtually every solution for incontinence from indwelling caths to diapers.  As a very mobile mid-live male, I prefer the McGuire urinal with a leg bag for long-term comfort and convenience.  This solution solves the unpleasant "yanking" feeling of condom catheters with the occasional detachment disaster, not to mention the unpleasantness of the disgusting adhesive!  Diapers just aren't a solution for travel, business life, etc.   OK occasionally for overnight, if absorbent enough, but can't imagine life in these. 

 

McGuire urinal with leg bag, properly fitted, provides long-term (3-4 days if necessary) protection, it is discreet, and completely washable and reusable.   Leg bags last 3 weeks or so.  Cost for this approach seems to be lowest of all choices.

 

Jim f.

 

5/29/08 3:15pm

Hi Craig well your right depends aren't very good for my urge incontinence have used all throught the night brand with some sucess now use secure,but still looking for the right combination alot of people say cloth and plastic are best.

7/ 6/08 6:53am

I have tried several diferent brands of disposable diapers but still for me cloth diapers and plastic pants are best. I wear loose fitting shorts and large t-shirts over double adult cloth diapers and plastic pants. As far as being spoted wearing diapers nobody has ever said anything too me about it.  They sure would if I dodn't have a diaper on.

 

7/ 6/08 6:55am

I have tried several different brands of disposable diapers but still for me cloth diapers and plastic pants are best. I wear loose fitting shorts and large t-shirts over double adult cloth diapers and plastic pants. As far as being spoted wearing diapers nobody has ever said anything too me about it.  They sure would if I didn't have a diaper on.

 

Anonymous
JEFFERY
3/ 9/10 12:00pm

I DO NOT THINK ANYBODY CARES ANYMORE, PEOPLE ON THE BUS GUYS ARE WEARING DRESSES , PEOPLE WITH ORANGE HAIR, THEN I TESTED IT TOO COZ I FORGOT A DIAPER TO CHANGE INTO SO I HAD TO GO DIAPERLESS UNDER MY JEANS ANYWAY BY THE TIME I GOT TO MY APARTMENT I WAS VERY WET WITH A BIG WET STAIN ON MY PANTS AND IT RUNNING DOWN MY LEG NOONE SAID BOO TO ME EITHER

5/31/08 3:23am

Cloth diapers are still the standard against which disposables are judged, I suppose. I quit using cloth diapers several years ago, mostly for convenience. I hated having to come home from work and have to wash and dry a load or two of diapers!

Disposables have improved a lot since the original Attends and Depends. These days, my preference is for Molicare Super Plus or Abena X-Plus for work, Equaline Overnight (from the supermarket) for at-home use.

Are disposables noisy? Sometimes. Plastic pants help with that, as will any other

underwear. Don't rely on plastic pants to prevent leaks, though. Do I care about noise? Not really. I don't think anyone's noticed, at least not where I work. They don't 'show' under khakis or jeans. Besides,  people see what they want to see, and hear what they want to hear. Don't worry about it.

6/ 1/08 2:32am

I have always worn cloth pin-on diapers and plastic or rubber pants for bedwetting. When I first went back into diapers it was my mom's choice. She said cloth would be cheaper in the long run, more absorbent (and adjustable by adding cloth baby diapers as boosters if necessary), and cloth allows the wearer to feel the wetness, which might help to stop.

6/ 3/08 3:41pm

I select them on how absorbant they are but i dont want them to be too bulky. I also decide that pullups can sometimes be better since im more active. The abena pullups are very good and absorbant but not too thick or noisy. The most important thing in choosing an incontinence product for me is how comfortable they are, some products are too thick or noisy or too hard to be active in.

7/ 8/08 9:29am

Have you tried external catheters (with bag) or male condom catheters which serve as a small drip bag? Some brands call them Mcguire urinals.

7/ 9/08 2:11pm

I prefer whatever offers the best security for me.  I've been dealing with bladder incontinence for most of my life, and I've tried nearly every product combination out there.

 

I use Abena X-Plus with a Depend booster pad, worn under pull-on plastic pants.  This is a comparatively bulky combination, but it seldom leaks and can truly be worn under nearly every clothing combination I have. 

Anonymous
Me and the Pee
7/13/08 4:42pm
I've experimented a lot over a while and I just discovered Tena flex super (small) are SUPER! I have urge/frequency incontinence and these are super absorbent, several wettings don't leak it and it's quiet and not hot air flow -- great for summer day wear. there is a belt that fastens around the waist with velcro and (if you can make it to the toilet) the front velcros away fast and you simply hold the product to the side of you or attach the velcro from the front to the belt. simply great product. I was almost content with wearing goodnights, but I do not like the fact changing underwear style protection means undressing in some form. they are also a bit noisy, don't mask odour well. the supplier called the tena flex "sumo" because they look a bit like a sumo garment. I think Attends makes something similar,but they are only available in EU. night I use Attends 10 briefs ... they haven't leaked on me yet. I have some cloth on hand in case of emergency, but I much prefer disposables. experimentation -- research -- good supplier -- trying to get over embarrassment when asked if they are for a senior... I'm 36 I am very glad there are the products we have today -- thank goodness for the aging population... heh.
7/18/08 1:45am

Due to being very concerned that someone will notice I am wearind a diaper,I prefer thin and discreet when wearing a diaper outside of home.I wear depends when I go out.

I can not get over this feeling that people will know what I am wearing.

I still have a feeling of shame over my wetting problems.

8/10/08 12:15am

I have only recentley had to were diapers i use attends 10 this is the brand my doctor sogested i did try som cheper brands but thay leeked

i decided it was beter to just pay the extra mony for the beter brand

Also so far no one has notced i ame wering thank god i dont know what i would do if thay did

7/23/08 4:34pm

I have been both bladder and bowel incontinant for over 11 years. I have to wear full time and to answer your question it all depends on if we are talking day or night. During the day I usually wear Attends with waistband because of my work and I need a thin very discreet diaper, or I will wear the MegaCareline if I voiding heavily. At night I wear the MegaCareline.

Anonymous
JEFFERY WOODARD
7/26/08 12:46pm

RIGHT NOW I FEEL THAT EVEN IF PEOPLE KNOW IF BETTER THAT WETTING IN PUBLIC WITH A BIG WET STAIN ON MY PANTS , I DO THAT ANYWAY WHEN MY DIAPER LEAKS COZ I AM A HEAVY WETTER , BUT I GOT TO DRINK ALOT TO KEEP FROM COUGHING MY HEAD OFF A BIG CATCH 22 JEFF

10/16/08 2:18pm

I also started out with the store brands, until I had a few accidents in public. I now use abri x plus, but also wear abri body stocking/ underwear. I wear one size smaller than what the label said and they fit snug. It helps to hide the "bulge" and stops some of the noise when moving around. One of the abri x last all day at work and into the evening. I change no more than 3 times in a 24 hour period. It is comforting to have the extra padding.

Anonymous
Deen
11/29/08 2:08am

I usually wear thin during the day with a soaker pad, but if I know I'll be out most of the day I wear a Molicare or Abena (and maybe 2 soakers inside them) with plastic pants and boxer briefs. If someone notices then it's their problem!

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (1021) >