Sign in

or Register now

MultipleSclerosisCentral.com

See all of our health sites at www.HealthCentral.com
Tuesday, November, 24, 2009
  • Font size
Receive a FREE Osteoarthritis of the knee pamphlet. Start here.

Living With Multiple Sclerosis: The Cost of Chronic Illness

Lisa Emrich
Lisa Emrich
Close
Musician, Patient Advocate, and Founder - Carnival of MS Bloggers

Lisa Emrich is a professional musician. She happens to live with...

Lisa Emrich

Wednesday, July 29, 2009
View All of Lisa Emrich's Posts
With the ongoing debate on ways to reform health care, I've been thinking about the routine medical care I receive in a typical year.  However, living with multiple sclerosis and rheumatoid arthritis, it is not always easy to know if a particular year is going to be "typical" or not.  So I ...
  1. Untitled Comment
    Julie
    Thursday, July 30, 2009 at 11:07 AM

    Lisa:

    Thanks for taking the time and effort involved in detailing your expenses. I wish I could share my expenses but I haven't kept track. I did have a brain/spine MRI earlier this year and believe my share of the costs were around $500. I do not take any of the CRAB drugs and my prescription costs run around $30/month. I have monthly blood tests and that's $40+.

    With kids at home, someone is always headed to the dentist, doctor, optometrist and so I do always give thought as to whether a doctor's visit is absolutely necessary.

    As far as I know, I have a $1 million lifetime benefit -- meaning that once insurance costs hit that number, I'm booted off the insurance program. On the positive side, once my family costs (the costs we have to pay, not including co-pays or prescriptions) surpass $3,000 for the year, insurance picks up 100 percent of the rest for the year.

    I have great insurance and have no complaints.

    My worries are that I will lose my job (through my illness) and will be a burden on my family because of my health costs. I'm hoping my children will be safely launched into the world, with their own careers, before this could become an issue. I would not want the cost of my health care to take anything away from them.

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    Lisa Emrich
    Friday, July 31, 2009 at 07:23 PM

    Julie,

     

    I can understand your worry about future employment and health insurance, but it's wonderful that right now you are secure.  Yeah!!  It truly is eye-opening to look at the concrete numbers associated with just one person living with MS.  Multiply that many times over and we're talking about some real money.  Hope you are doing well lately and that the summer is going fine.

     

    Reply
  2. Medical costs- MS & other
    barbaraquinn@bjqltd
    Thursday, July 30, 2009 at 02:31 PM

    Thanks for doing such a complete job identifying your medical costs.  I am retired but do not have company health insurance.  My costs are very similar to yours including a relapse related MRI, with and without dye of my brain, my thorasic and cervical spine after falling and breaking my ankle.   Medicare and AARP supplemental paid the entire cost, including the surgery.  Medicare can't continue this level of coverage for the aging baby boomers.  I have Medicare part B, AARP supplemental (#7) and AARP RX coverage costing about $525/mo.  I'm taking it one day at a time.

    Reply
    re: Medical costs- MS & other
    Lisa Emrich
    Friday, July 31, 2009 at 07:36 PM

    Oh no!!  You fell and broke your ankle; how is the recovery going?  So glad to hear that your care was covered through Medicare and supplemental insurance, though.  Did you have any new developments on your MRI scans?

    Reply
  3. Untitled Comment
    pattivt
    Thursday, July 30, 2009 at 02:36 PM

    I can't help but think what the costs will be under "ObamaCare" and if you would even have access to the quality of care you are able to get now as expensive as it is now...

    Reply
    re: Untitled Comment
    Lisa Emrich
    Friday, July 31, 2009 at 08:11 PM

    Hi pattivt,

     

    I appreciate your comment.  Right now, it's impossible to know what structures any new legislation will have because they are still being designs, debated, and voted upon.  Nothing is set yet.

     

    True that the quality of my care is very good and the costs of the care provided by my doctors and other providers is actually rather contained and reasonable.  It is the cost of medication and the lack of prescription coverage (which comes from lack of regulation in my state) which puts me at a disadvantage.

     

    There are no easy answers, unfortunately.

    Reply
  4. Health Care Costs
    Denise Coleman
    Thursday, July 30, 2009 at 05:19 PM

    Lisa, thank you for this eye opening article.  I count my blessings every time I see a doctor or have a procedure done because I have excellent coverage, thanks to my former employer. When I went on SS Disability and started receiving Medicare, I was also covered by the insurance plan that my former employer gives to its retired employees.  Over the years some of the specific benefits have changed, and for a while my prescription coverage was only for generic meds so I either had to pay or not take those medications that were.  That has changed now and I pay a relatively small co-payment for my prescriptions, usually between $15 and $35 per.  It adds up each month but at least I can take all of the prescriptions I have been given.

     

    I now can see any doctor I need to, as long as he or she accepts Medicare. I mentioned in a previous Post that I see a neurologist, pain specialist, urologist, neuro-pharmacologist, pulmonologist, internist, and podiatrist, and other specialists as needed.  I see all these doctors because of the range of symptoms I have from MS and my other diagnosed chronic conditions. I am thankful that I no longer have to get referrals or see only in-network doctors, and I hope it stays this way.  

     

    While I cannot complain about my current insurance plan and hope that it stays this way, I do recognize that I am very fortunate and there are many people out there not so fortunate with their plans, or who have no insurance at all.  I think there are major problems with the insurance system as we know it, specifically because of the number of families, especially children, with no coverage.  

     

    There are other issues though, including the continued decrease in reimbursement to doctors.  In your Post you itemize how much the insurance company discounts the doctors' bills.  I have had situations where a specialist has submitted a bill of several hundred dollars and receives back from my insurance less than $100.  I blame this high amount of discounting for some doctors increasing their fees in an effort to be reimbursed what they consider a reasonable amount.  Another practice  that many doctors have adopted is limiting the time spent with any patient; they allocate fifteen minutes per patient so they can see more patients to make the money they once did or perceive they need.  I don't know how much doctors should make but the fact is their income is being cut by these discounted payments and they are doing what they can to make more. 

     

     Another new development is that of Concierge Doctors, and I don't mean the one on TV. I received a glossy brochure from a vascular surgeon I saw for my legs offering Concierge Medicine for $2500 a year.  For this membership fee I would be entitled to guaranteed appointments with no limit on the amount of time my doctor would spend with me.  The brochure did say he would remain my doctor even if I didn't pay this fee, however I might not get in to see the doctor right away and I will only be allotted 15 minutes, regardless of why I was there.  I had heard of this new practice but was speechless when I received such a notice from one of my doctors. Isn't the issue of discounting doctors' bills important enough to be studied during health care reform? If we are concerned that the padding of bills is a large part of the cost of Medicare, shouldn't we include doctors in an effort to find out why this is happening and see if it can be fixed?  Wouldn't this all be part of a true reform effort?

     

    I believe we need Insurance Reform though I am concerned about what will actually come out of the current effort; will it be better than what we have?  Will competition really drive down costs?  Are pharmaceuticals going to look to trim costs so insurance companies can afford to cove medicines?  The government plan is only one option that will be given to the public so will it be able to fund itself?  

     

    I am concerned that my wonderful insurance plan, which has to cost my former employer a lot of money, will be cut or changed to meet the minimum requirements of any new government option.  I pay about $40 a month toward my premium, although this has gone up and down over the years, depending on the policy. This may be selfish of me, but I don't know how I would manage my health care without a policy such as the one I now have.

     

    One last comment.  I don't view the current effort to be true health care reform. Instead I see it as insurance reform, which I believe is critical but there is very little being discussed about the quality of care and all that means, from access to care and educating doctors to palliative care for terminal patients.  

     

    Thanks again for your insightful article.  I apologize for this being so long, however you stirred up some thoughts I wanted to share. 

    Reply
    re: Health Care Costs
    Lisa Emrich
    Friday, July 31, 2009 at 07:59 PM

    Denise,

     

    You have brought up some excellent points regarding the limitations of the current "health reform" effort.  I've wondered about the discount (or disallowed) amounts which are seen in the EOB.  Makes me want to ask, "so what is the real cost?" 

     

    Recently, my neurologist stopped participating with a particular insurance company in this area (not my own).  He implemented a new process, whereby if you were paying cash (filing with insurance later) on the day of the visit, then the charge would be discounted significantly.  The lower rate is coincidently very close to the amount my insurance company pays for neuro visits.  Result being, the neurologist office gets reimbursement faster.  So what is the real cost?

     

    As far as doctor's visits, I'm satisfied with my insurance coverage and do believe that the costs are contained.  Now when I started going to PT, something amazed me.  The physical therapist said that their charges were the same amount as what Medicare allows to make it easier.  Apparently, Medicare rates for therapy are higher than my insurance plan's negotiated rates. That surprised me based on the argument that Medicare rates are too low.

     

    Very interesting questions raised by just looking at the real numbers.  I could go on and on, too.

    Reply
  5. Medical visit payments
    Token
    Thursday, July 30, 2009 at 07:45 PM

    So sorry, Lisa, about all the $$ you've been paying when you got that variety of medical visits/treatments.  I'm only 55yrs., but I've been on Medicare awhile now & I'm spoiled because I pay very little.  I wish everyone with a disease could be on Medicare. Yes, I have a $250 deductible at the begeinning of the year, but the only thing I pay a significant amount for is the dentist.  Thanks for the info. on the Cost of Chronic Illness. 

    Reply
    re: Medical visit payments
    Lisa Emrich
    Friday, July 31, 2009 at 08:04 PM

    Token,

     

    I like hearing when people are satisfied with their coverage, such as Medicare.  If I had not gone through difficulties with drug coverage, I'd have had no idea that there were these types of problems within the system.  So maybe it's a good thing that I know, because now I can share my story and hopefully help someone else.

    Reply
  6. Health Insurance Initiative Project
    Kim Roberts
    Tuesday, August 04, 2009 at 10:48 AM

    If any of you are in the Greater Delaware Valley Chapter area of the National MS Society, we can help with our Health Insurance Initiative Project. Visit http://main.nationalmssociety.org/hiip

    Reply
  • Font size
  • Bookmark
  • Thank you for your input
  • Save
  • RSS
  • Report Abuse

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

View all questions (1020) >