Saturday, October 25, 2014

Wednesday, March 25, 2009 Jihan, Community Member, asks

Q: Can Stress trigger MS symptoms and is there any research/medical articles that prove this?

Answer This
Answers (6)
Merely Me, Health Guide
3/25/09 10:50pm

Hi Jihan

 

This is such an excellent question and one that I have wondered about as well.  And I am finding that it is a difficult question to answer.

 

Some months back I had asked Doctor Nitin Sethi, a neurologist, to answer some reader questions and someone had asked about both diet and stress as triggers for MS.  Dr. Sethi had this to say: 

 

"Stress and food do not play a direct role in worsening MS symptomatology. I do though advise my patients to attempt to reduce the stress in their lives and eat a balanced nutritious diet."

 

It seems difficult to find a study which says that stress is a direct cause of MS symptoms. 

 

In an article entitled Stress and Multiple Sclerosis, author Julie Stachowiak has this to say about studies on stress and MS:

 

"In a 2006, Australian researchers conducted one of the first studies to seriously examine the relationship of stress and MS relapse. This study followed 101 people with MS for 2 years and asked about their stress levels and stressful events every three months. They found that the greater number of acute stressors that a person reported predicted relapse. They also found (not surprisingly) that people who were having a relapse reported more stress. Chronic stress and stress severity did not predict relapse, only the number of acute stressors."

 

But then I did find one study which actually said that stress can trigger MS symptoms.

 

A 2007 report from CBS news entitled, "Chronic stress can cause or exacerbate MS" states that: 

 

"Researchers have demonstrated for the first time that inflammation brought on by stress leads to the worsening of the mouse equivalent of MS." 

 

But we are talking about mice here and not humans so....I don't know how much merit one can base on such a study. 

 

In my humble opinion I think stress can make any illness worse.  But does it actually cause symptoms?  I don't know. 

 

I would love to know what others think about this.  Great topic for discussion!

Reply
Nicole Amoroso-Tuten, Community Member
9/26/09 7:04pm

Hi,  I am a 41 year old woman who was diagnosed with Ms after a tramatic neck injury and surgery.  I had an MRI for my neck injury which revealed c5 and c6 disc were crushed together. At that time, my neuro. surgeon had me taking pain killers until my surgery, this kept the pain at a bearable level however due to workers compensation rules he had to take me off the pain killers 5 before the surgery.  This put me in an extreme pain and stress due to the fear of the surgery.  I lost feeling in the right side of my face 3 days before surgery.  Here are my facts,  my neuro surgeon stated that I had absolutely no lesions on my brain prior to surgery, not only did I not have lesions, I had no symptoms and was very active with my 2 children and husband.  One month after my surgery another MRI was taken due to the numbness  in my face and I was told I had lesions on my brain, however my neurologists told me that we had caught this in very early stages due to the fact that they were very new, with the facts of my case I believe the evidence that I have proves that stress does cause MS.

 

Thank You,

Nicole Amoroso-Tuten

Reply
roby, Community Member
3/27/09 11:26pm

KissIve been waiting for many years for someone to answer this  but i no in my heart it sure does get my MS symptoms starting up exaserbations in stressful times are unfortunatly what seems to be expected and never wanted funny how some people say ur faking it!! who can twist there eyes in difrent ways and have painful treatments just to fake so much goes on with MS we who live it dont enjoy it at all but lets all pray for a cure mwa XX

Reply
Ali, Community Member
3/27/09 11:32pm

Yes, it can.

 

Reply
stacey, Community Member
3/30/09 10:04pm

I have had ms for 4 yrs. My dad passed away in Nov and my job has been very stressful. Two weeks ago I recieved steroid treatment for the first time for optic neurotis. This was my first major problem and I know it was caused by to much stress!

Reply
LinDiego, Community Member
6/ 7/09 1:09am

Stress release certain chemicals into our body. MS is a disease of our immune system. Our immune systems are confused and stressed. Anything that confuses or stresses our immune system, i.e., stress, is bad for us.

 

My case: All or most of us are exposed to the virus that causes mononucleosis, as well as many other viruses. Why don't we all get mononucleosis? In my case, I had a very stressed childhood. When I was 16 I believe my immune system was very stressed and when I was exposed to the mono virus, I became very sick with it and missed three months of school. My mother (who is in her 80s now) has been told that some of her problems were caused by MS. So: here I am a case of MS genes + mononucleosis + stress. A very bad combination that resulted in me getting MS. Maybe if I hadn't had the stress in my early childhood, I wouldn't have gotten mononucleosis? Maybe I wouldn't have gotten MS? So, yes, I totally believe that stress can lower our immune system. Combine stress with a virus or bacteria .... and/or a genetic predisposition to a disease.... what have you got? Stress is an inevitable factor of life. Some say we could not succeed without stress. But we need to recognize bad stresses and learn how to mitigate the stresses in our life? Our mind interprets our reality. So our attitude and education/knowledge/beliefs impact what kinds of stress we get. Does life happen to us? Or can we make a difference?

Reply
Oddar, Community Member
1/ 5/10 4:13am

Hi, I am Oddvar from Norway. I got MS 2 years after an accident where I had an complicated fracture in my left leg. I belive trauma was the reason for my MS.

Among other websites, You can read this:

http://ms.about.com/od/livingwellwithms/a/ms_stress.htm

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

By Jihan, Community Member— Last Modified: 05/15/14, First Published: 03/25/09