Wednesday, February 15, 2012
Don't let RA limit your routineLearn more now about a treatment that may help
Friday, May 16, 2008 Linda9046 asks

Q: milk or soy milk?

Which is better for you milk or soy milk.  I was told milk is bad for your bones because of the acid.

Answer This
Answers (3)
5/16/08 4:54pm

Thanks for your excellent question! This is a controversial issue, and you may receive different answers from the proponents of cows milk and those of soy milk. To begin with, it's great to remember that either milk or calcium-fortified soy milk is a great bone-building alternative to calcium-free beverages such as sodas, and it's great to hear you're making the effort to stave off osteoporosis with smart choices in your diet.

 

When comparing the two, it's worthwhile to remember cow's milk (whether whole, low-fat or skim) generally has about 300 mg per cup. This is a good figure to compare to the amount of calcium present in whichever fortified soymilk you might choose (which could vary). However, some studies have indicated that the calcium in fortified soymilk is more difficult to digest than that in cow's milk, so you would need to drink more to get the same amount. Some soy milk brands dispute this assertion and suggest their calcium is just as absorbable -- the decision is up to you.

 

You may want to also consider other factors besides osteoporosis -- for example, some experts tout soy milk for vascular health, while others warn excessive soy consumption can be problematic for those with estrogen-responsive breast cancer. You may want to discuss the issue with your doctor if you have either of these conditions.

 

Best wishes!

 

 

Reply
5/27/08 3:16pm

milk i thank

Reply

This is from a telecast on BBC in the UK (end 1997).

 

Research was carried out in a town in US where children born in the 80s and were found to either have very brittle bones and / or did not have teeth even in their teens. Those that did grow some form of teeth, these were black or broken shards.

 

Over a 10 year research it was found that all the mothers of these children had switched to Soy Milk and products containing Soy rather than Cow/Buffalo Milk.

 

The research/video and data were shown once when I saw it, the news was sadly conveniently not reported in any other media and has not seen the light of day in any other news. PROBABLY DUE TO COMMERCIAL AND POLITICAL PRESSURE?

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of The HealthCentral Network. The HealthCentral Network does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (1285) >