People's Pharmacy

For more up-to-date information on drugs, herbs and home remedies visit The People's Pharmacy Home Site at peoplespharmacy.us

Genric Drug Problem Raises Questions On Quality

Posting Date: 11/22/2004

For decades the FDA has maintained that generic drugs are every bit as good as their brand name counterparts. Millions of people rely on generics as less expensive alternatives to pricey products like Coumadin, Valium or Prozac.

Employers, insurance companies and HMOs are desperate to control the ever-escalating costs of prescription drugs. That?s why they have embraced generics and trust the FDA to guarantee equivalency. This means that a generic is supposed to get into the blood stream just the way the original innovator drug does and work exactly the same way in the body.

But is the FDA right in its assumption that generic drugs meet the same quality standards physicians, pharmacists and patients expect of brand name medicines? A new study suggests that the FDA may be overlooking some evidence.

The research, published in the journal Neurology (Oct., 2004), reports on a problem that was noticed in Minnesota soon after the state health plan mandated generic drug substitution. Epileptic patients who had been controlled for years began to have seizures that required urgent clinic or emergency room visits or even hospitalization.

Health care providers investigated eight patients who suffered serious seizures after being switched from the prescription antiepileptic medicine Dilantin to its generic equivalent, phenytoin. Blood levels dropped by roughly 30 percent when patients took generic phenytoin (made by Mylan).

The researchers concluded that switching patients to generic phenytoin could be penny-wise but pound-foolish. The small cost savings could be wiped out in a single hospitalization.

Readers of this column have been reporting trouble with generic drugs for years. One person had a similar experience to the Minnesota patients:

?I have been taking Dilantin for 16 years to treat temporal lobe seizures. About two years ago my pharmacist filled my prescription with the generic. I began to have seizure problems within a few weeks. That is when I noticed that I was using a generic.