People with Chronic Illnesses Could Be Labeled as Mentally Ill

By Lene Andersen, Health Guide Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Did it take a long time for you to get diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis or another chronic illness? Did your symptoms disrupt your daily life? Did you worry about your symptoms? Is your condition under control or does it disrupt your daily life? If so, do you worry about it?

 

According to the fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-V) to be published in May, this could cause you to be diagnosed with a mental disorder.

 

The DSM-V is published by the American Psychiatric Association (APA) and is used to categorize mental disorders. It contains the diagnostic codes and criteria that psychiatrists, therapists and other medical professionals use when diagnosing mental illness.

 

A new disorder called Somatic Symptom Disorder (SSD) has been added to fifth edition (draft pdf here). According to the definition, you can be diagnosed with SSD if for at least six months, you have had a symptom or symptoms that is distressing and/or disrupt your daily life and you have one of the following reactions

 

  • Disproportionate thoughts about the seriousness of your symptom(s);
  • A high level of anxiety about your symptoms or health; or
  • Devote excessive time and energy to your symptoms or health concerns.

 

This could describe anyone who has struggled to get a diagnosis for e.g., an autoimmune disease, notorious for being hard to pin down. It could describe anyone with uncontrolled RA, lupus, MS, IBS, or fibromyalgia who are worried about their condition — and who wouldn't be with an uncontrolled illness? In that situation, what constitutes "excessive time and energy" and who decides what's excessive? When a medical condition has taken over, your life becomes about trying to control and manage that condition. It can be a full-time job.

 

There are a number of concerns related to this new disorder. One of the primary concerns is that the definition is too vague — as illustrated above, it could theoretically be applied to most anyone who lives with a chronic or serious illness. SSD also labels a normal emotional response to a difficult health condition as mental illness. If a symptom or your condition disrupts your life or is distressing, it is a normal human process to be anxious about it, even very anxious. An uncontrolled, long-term RA flare can consume your life and require all your time and energy to manage. Do all doctors understand that? Do all doctors agree with your assessment of the impact your disease has on your life? Should they get to decide or should you?

 

A diagnosis of SSD has potentially serious consequences to someone's future. This kind of diagnosis shifts the focus from the physical condition to an alleged mental illness. Once you have been labeled as mentally ill due to your reaction to your illness, getting medical professionals to take your concerns seriously could be close to impossible. This could have serious implications in terms of people being left untreated for real health problems. As well, it could also mean people being unnecessarily prescribed psychiatric medication.

By Lene Andersen, Health Guide— Last Modified: 02/05/13, First Published: 01/22/13