Is mental illness just a sane reaction to intolerable conditions? I was reading a very interesting book called "Children With Emerald Eyes." The author, herself a surviover of extreme conditions, did extensive work with children suffering from autism and childhood sz for many years. She writes in her introduction, that this is her conclusion. That insanity is a reasonable, in fact normal, reaction to intolerable suffering for a particular individual. What is your opinion on this? I always understood that there is a hereditary factor involved, or sometimes street drugs.





I'm sorry to hear of your great stress. What's often helped me when suffering severe worry is a short prayer... It can be a real release.
Regarding what you wrote, well, we are speaking of severe trauma, not regular stress from ordinary life events. In those conditions it seems doubtful that a person can make a cool appropriate decision; that his judgement would be clear . Especially not a child or young adult.
It seems that under such duress insanity is, perhaps, a coping tool of the mind. That it might actually be a protective survival method of the individual.
i personally know an elderly woman for many years, who during late childhood was abandoned by a close family member whom she dearly loved and was very close to. It's my opinion that this is what drove her over the edge. She simply was unable to cope with this life-shattering betrayal, and to save herself she went into another more sympathetic and kinder world of her own creation. Was this reasonable? Yes... it helped her survive. It protected her mind from the horror of what had happened to her...
There was no one there to give a helping hand to her, to pull her up from this abyss, so that this was her only way of coping.
It is only in much later years, i think, that a person develops the coping skills and acquires the wisdom and ability to deal with calamity. And then only sometimes...
It's not only our bodies that are fragile, our mindes are too... And some people's minds more than others..
i recommend this excellent book to you (written by Mira Rosenberg). It is not only very interesting, but a real eye-opener