Friday, May 24, 2013
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

Wednesday, September 12, 2012 Amelia asks

Q: Is my boyfriend's diagnosis real, what can I do to help?

My boyfriend, age 22, told me about his diagnosis of schizophrenia and multiple personality disorder four months ago when I started asking about things that were happening to him and in our relationship.  There were a couple times when he would "black out" and not remember what had happened, most often this was accompanied by muscle spasms or convulsions, his eyes rolling around, mumbling or whispering words or sentences, and becoming unresponsive for periods of 5 to 15 minutes.  Once, he also said he was unable to see, that the room was dark, after such an episode.  Sometimes he'll ask me if it's raining or why the girl is crying during these instances.  These episodes most often happen as we are laying down to sleep, have been occurring more frequently than they were in the beginning of 2012 (to my knowledge), and are scary for both of us.  

 

He feels like he is losing control, he is a "miserable human being", and has no hope.  He uses alcohol and other substances to cope, or at least to help him with his sleeplessness.  He has a full-time job and does not have problems taking care of himself, though he sometimes exhibits signs of depression - lack of appetite and lack of interest in life and activities.  He feels like it is hard for him to connect with others and doesn't trust people, though he often does sweet and caring things like making me meals or taking good care of me when I'm sick.  He does have hallucinations from time to time, seeing things on the ceiling or walls, though he won't describe them to me and knows they're not real (unless his is confused shortly after an episode).  He feels like someone else is living in his head and he has no personality or passions of his own.  He is not delusional, rather he is very grounded in reality and a very logical thinker, though this sometimes makes him seem callous when he is critiquing my actions or emotions, an act he often apologizes for after the fact, saying his is simply bitter about his own life.  I am having a hard time accepting that he has schizophrenia, mostly because I simply don't want it to be the truth, but also because I'm not sure that his symptoms line up with what I've read about schizophrenia.  He told me he has been dealing with this since he was six, which I happen to know is the age when he was sexually and physically abused by his mother's boyfriend, an incident he has still not shared with his family or come to terms with (in my opinion).  He doesn't take any medication anymore, though he used to take Xanax and anti-depressants.  I've offered to go with him or bring him to the mental health clinic at my University to seek help, advice, or a second opinion, but he does not want to, feeling that his experience with doctors and treatments in the past have been pointless.  

 

Do his symptoms/experiences sound like that of a schizophrenic?  Could his history of sexual abuse have anything to do with what his is experiencing?  What can I do to help him if he doesn't want to help himself?

Answer This
Answers (5)
Christina Bruni, Health Guide
9/25/12 10:29am

Hi Amelia,

 

I don't treat or diagnose illnesses.  I'm the Health Guide here so what I can tell you is that something is very, very not right about what is going on, regardless of whether or not it turns out to be schizophrenia.

 

If your boyfriend does not get help or medical attention or at least counseling NOW, this behavior will be the rest of your life with him, and last for the rest of his life.

 

Playing the "normal" card and thinking he's fine because he can function does none of you any good.  He can't function if he's using street drugs or alcohol to self-medicate his symptoms.

 

I was diagnosed with schizophrenia when I was 22.  I take my medication every day as prescribed so that I'm able to live without any symptoms.  Plus, I no longer have side effects from the medication.

 

The failure to find a good professional to work with in the past is no reason why your boyfriend should refuse to continue to search until he DOES find a good professional.  His refusal to get help is just plain unhealthy if not totally wrong and it's up to you if you want to accept his behavior going forward.

 

He needs some kind of help, and he needs it now.  Before either he or you is put in further danger.

 

Regards,

Christina

Reply
10/ 5/12 2:46am

Can he get an EEG? An electric brain wave monitor. To see if he is having seizures.

Reply
10/ 6/12 8:47pm

I think he may have had one before, but he hasn't been getting professional help for years and refuses to now.

Reply
10/ 6/12 4:56pm

You've described some symptoms that seem to me to look like schizophrenia,  and also seizures of some sort.  

 

Certainly the seizures - when he's 'unresponsive' is it just like he's working at a desk and won't answer  your questions?  Or is he lying on the floor motionless, or convulsing, and even a slap on the face won't do anything?  If the latter, this one seems inescapably for a doctor.  Could be related to the rest.  

 

I see  no evidence  of  'multiple personality disorder'.   Actually a lot of people  confuse that with Schizophrenia - totally different - cuz some journalist screwed it up one day and everybody thinks the Schiz - split - means a split personality, when really it means a split from reality - hearing voices and thinking the CIA is out to get you.  Also 'multiple personality disorder' sortof became a big hoax as a result of the Sybil book in the 1970s and 1980s.  The book was baloney,  the doctor was baloney, but she went to her grave believing it.   Thousands of lawsuits later, there still is  a real "Dissociative identity disorder" but  it's rare and unlikely.   

 

I am not an MD or  a healthcare professional of any kind - just a well-read amateur.  

 

Reply
10/ 6/12 5:30pm

rereading, yeah, plenty of signs of depression in there, worth diagnosing.  

 

Part of the phony myth of multiple personality disorder was that you get it from abuse as a child; you're doing it to escape the abuse; the abuse wasn't even known about until the subject gets hypnotized to retrieve repressed memories.  

 

It turns out, hypnosis is a way to get people to believe things that are suggested to them, rather than a way to retrieve repressed memories.  Thousands of MPD people were hypnotized into believing that their parents or others abused them when nothing of the kind happened.   Parents and siblings were astounded when they were accused of abuse.  Families were torn apart;  lawsuits  erupted.  

 

Turns out,  hypnosis is a little bit like torture: you'll get the answers you ask for, all right, but they're not true.  If your BF's memory of abuse was retrieved by hypnosis, it's probably wrong.  If he's remembered it always since it happened, though, it probably happened.

 

I have sexual abuse in my family;  the victims remember every minute of  it without hypnosis.  They don't talk about it by habit,  but they remember it.   They did studies of children in 3rd world countries that witnessed their families getting killed;  they remember it all, no repressed memories.

 

If your BF really was abused by mom's boyfriend, probably mom will remember it, or will remember some  sort of clues.  A lot of the damage that was done was the idea  that Mom (or whatever grownups who knew about it) didn't come and save him, therefore he's "not worth saving", he "deserved" it, phony negative ideas like that,  that grind into your soul for decades.  

 

Reply
10/ 6/12 8:47pm

He wasn't hypnotized ever as far as I know, he remember the things that happened to him.  And yes, he does deem himself deserving to be sexually and physically abused by his mom's boyfriend, simply because it happened.  It seems impossible to convince him that sometimes bad things just happen to people, to which he replies 
"it happened, therefore I deserved it".   I understand after thinking that way for over a decade that it would be hard to reroute that chain of thinking, but is it impossible?  He never told his mom about anything that happened (she worked a lot all of his life and most of it happened while the BF was watching him) because he thought it would hurt her to know...which is probably true, but I wish he wouldn't have had to suffer alone for so long.  No amount of my wishing, hoping, or trying to talk him through what he is going through these days seems to help.  He doesn't want to get professional help.  I am at a loss.

Reply
10/ 6/12 8:51pm

I've never tried slapping him in the face, but yes, it seems to happen always when he is lying down to rest and then he will start shaking, his eyes roll around in his head, he doesn't respond to anything for some time.  I held his eyelids open once and his eyes didn't even register me moving in front of him.  

 

I think I made an error in recollecting the names of his diagnosis...it was actually Borderline Personality Disorder.  I wasn't familiar with it at all and got it confused. I've since done some research and it seems to fit his behaviors quite well. 

Reply
10/ 9/12 12:55am
My childs father had seizures. Mostly they are caused when he withdraw s from alcohol. Reply
1/19/13 10:15am

I am not a PH D Medical practioner, however, I have learned from personaly studies that the information that I am providing has helped me

 

He needs to breathe. He needs to breathe. As you can see I said that twice, because as I type this, one side of my brain is coming with the information that I've collected about my symptoms. It is my opinion that schizophrenia is NOT an actual disease, however it is a symptom of poor oxygen circulation to the brain that is caused by the lungs. A list of poor breathing can be attributed by lung diseases (asthma, COPD) or asphyxiation contributed by allergies such as food, pollen, etc. If your boyfriend has smoked marijuana. or cigarettes, he is at risk of poor oxygen circulation! He must focus on healing by strengthening his immune system. Now, he needs to meditate. I suggest using cannabis oil, or cannabis cooked in butter, in incraments, no more than half a gram a day, or fewer than that to help his brain oxegenate for therapy purposes, this can help him calm down, focus and meditate. You need to be there with him, because the first steps of this can be very painful both physically and emotionally. Serve him teas that help with breathing such as mint, eucaleptus. I hope this helps1

May Yah blass you guys

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

By Amelia— Last Modified: 01/19/13, First Published: 09/12/12