Friday, June 01, 2012
Introducing Mood 24/7, a new tool that helps you track your mood from day to day using your mobile phone. Try it today!

Wednesday, July 14, 2010 kickstart asks

Q: Don't know what to do about live-in sister in law

Hi, I've been in a dilemma regarding my sister-in-law for several years. Let me start by saying, my husband and I live with his father and half sister. His father is in his 60s, obese, and has alot of back pains, so we live with him to do chores around the house, make sure the lawn is mowed, run various errands, so on. The half sister, "Heather," does nothing. She is 30 years old, six years older than us. My husband said that ever since she was a kid, she was a primadonna brat, but when she got into highschool, she started using crystal meth. This altered her behavior further and more negatively, and after a couple abortions and the death of her mother (they were on bad terms with eachother at the time of her passing), she is where she is today. She screams all day, screaming out things like, "GET OUT!!!" or talking as if she's having a violent and negative conversation with someone, lots of threats, cursing, etc. She slams doors. She's said there's a ghost in our house, and she thinks it's her and my husband's mother (to clear the air, no one else has never experienced anything remotely paranormal in our house). Heather's four year old son has no father, and she was stripped of her parental rights after my husband and I caught her beating on him a month before his third birthday. According to the police report, she told police she was "beating the devil out of him." She has been told by a judge that if she wants a chance at getting her son back, she will have to go to counselling at the mental health center and show progress on her condition. Instead, she sits in her room all day in the dark, watching television, screaming and carrying on despite my husband's father's efforts to get her to go to her appointments or get a job. I feel her lack of social interaction is making her condition worse, yet she refuses to do anything at all. I think the lack of social interaction has also affected her mentally in other ways, like common sense or reasoning. Just an example, she'll try to make kool-aid, but only mix the powder, no sugar. As far as her physical health, she's gained an enormous amount of weight by not doing anything physical, and I think her eyesight is getting worse from sitting in the dark, watching tv, as now she has to squint at all times to see. I have told my husband that he needs to talk to his father about Heather and what to do with her. I've tried to be sympathetic to her condition but it hasn't done any good. After having to deal with her habitual lying, mood swings, in addition to the screaming, child beating, and so on, I feel what's best for her and us is for her father to give her an ultimatum: Get help or hit the road. My husband doesn't want to even bring it up to his father, because he thinks I'm being too harsh. I do not know how else to deal with this?

Answer This
Answers (1)
Christina Bruni, Health Guide
7/17/10 7:00pm

Hello kickstart,

 

The father since she is an adult and living under his roof should have some kind of house rules in place.  Allowing the half sister to deteriorate physically, mentally and emotionally will enable her to NEVER RECOVER.

 

When I was diagnosed with schizophrenia at 22 years old, I attended a day program and was never at home because I was working on my recovery every day of the week.  i moved into a halfway house a year later.

 

It sounds like the half sister is not working on her recovery.

 

Since this is the case the father has the right to tell her that she needs to live elsewhere like in a halfway house or group home for people with mental illnesses.  I've gotten a lot of flak in the past for recommending parents set house rules and I've gotten a lot of flak also for telling people that parents have the right to require that their adult child is working on his or her recovery while living under the parent's roof.

 

The half-sister is not going to get better.  She is already barely able to function from what you've told us.  She is not going to get better if things continue the way they have been.

 

Shoudl you want to find a reputable mental health residence for the half sister I would recommend you call NAMI at (800) 950-NAMI (6264) to get the name and number of the local chapter in your city or town.  The family members of that chapter might be able to recommend a good living arrangement.  Alternately you can search for housing options with the link I just gave you.

 

Your code "several years" leads me to believe that whatever you've been doing up to this point hasn't been working.  You and your husband are not trained professionals who can adequately monitor the level of care it appears she might need right now.

 

To sum up: like I said the father has the right (and the duty to save his daughter's life) to put his foot down and expect that the half-sister commit to her recovery.

 

You deserve to have a life too.

 

Regards,

Christina

Reply
Answer This

Important:
We hope you find this general health information helpful. Please note however, that this Q&A is meant to support not replace the professional medical advice you receive from your doctor. No information in the Answers above is intended to diagnose or treat any condition. The views expressed in the Answers above belong to the individuals who posted them and do not necessarily reflect the views of Remedy Health Media. Remedy Health Media does not review or edit content posted by our community members, but reserves the right to remove any material it deems inappropriate.

Ask a Question

Get answers from our experts and community members.

Btn_ask_question_med
View all questions (1489) >
By kickstart— Last Modified: 12/26/10, First Published: 07/14/10