NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Sleepwalkers are rarely violent and do not seek out victims while they are in a sleep arousal state. If a sleepwalker does become violent, the victim is usually someone who just got in the way, rather than the target of premeditated violence, a sleep expert concludes after reviewing medical and legal literature on 32 cases.
"Sleepwalkers are not inherently violent," Dr. Mark R. Pressman of Lankenau Hospital in Wynnewood, Pennsylvania, the study's author, told Reuters Health. "Sleepwalking violence is quite rare." There's sort of a cartoon-like conception in the general public that sleepwalkers get out of bed with a knife and go looking for someone they're angry with.
But this perception is off-base, he added; sleepwalkers are functioning at a very low level, with the parts of their brains responsible for planning and socialization out of commission. "Legal cases in which the defendant supposedly went somewhere and sought out the victim are not likely to be true cases of sleepwalking," said Pressman, who has acted as an expert witness in such cases.
He undertook his review, published in the journal Sleep, to test the hypothesis that sleepwalkers may harm people who touch them or are close by, but they don't spontaneously attack other people. For centuries, he noted, there have been reports of violent acts by sleepwalkers, and even cases of people acquitted of murder because they claimed to have been asleep when they committed the act.
He divided the cases into three categories: sleepwalking; confusional arousal, a state identical to sleepwalking but the sleeper doesn't leave the bed; and sleep terrors, or sudden partial awakening due to a frightening stimulus, followed by sleepwalking.
In all of the confusional arousal cases, the victim of violence had been close to or touching the attacker, the researcher found, and the same was true in 81 percent of sleep terror cases and 40 to 90 percent of the sleepwalking cases. "Often the provocation was quite minor and the response greatly exaggerated," he noted.
