How Accurately Is Schizophrenia Portrayed In Movies?by Claire Gillespie Health Writer
Schizophrenia, a complex, chronic brain disorder that affects around 3.5 million people in the United States, is characterized by delusions, hallucinations, lack of motivation, and cognitive issues. It’s not talked about as much as other types of mental illness, such as anxiety and depression, and misconceptions are rife – which may be partly due to how it’s been portrayed in the media. So what movies get schizophrenia right, and what ones get it wrong?
A Beautiful Mind (2001)
Perhaps the best-known movie about schizophrenia, “A Beautiful Mind” is a powerful account of the life of mathematician and Nobel Prize winner John Nash (Russell Crowe). While those familiar with the schizophrenia might say Nash’s hallucinations are portrayed in a hugely exaggerated manner – apart from the fact the idea that willpower can overcome the illness is completely ridiculous – many mental health professionals praised the film for creating a better understanding of schizophrenia.
Savage Grace (2007)
Based on the true-life case of the infamous Baekeland family, “Savage Grace” features Eddie Redmayne as the troubled Tony, who has schizophrenia. However, his illness is merely hinted at until the shocking climax of the movie, which may leave some viewers feeling short-changed. It would be easy to watch this movie and be completely unaware that Tony is no more than just a guy with a quirky personality. That the film doesn’t do more to raise awareness of schizophrenia is disappointing.
Benny & Joon (1993)
On the surface, “Benny & Joon,” starring Mary Stuart Masterson, Aidan Quinn, and Johnny Depp, is a story of happiness and hope, showing the possibilities available to people with schizophrenia. However, viewers shouldn’t expect a realistic portrayal of the illness. Joon is simply given medication without any sort of cognitive or behavioral therapy, and she isn’t introduced to any positive examples of high-functioning schizophrenics. This results in the trivialization of serious, debilitating condition.
The Fisher King (1991)
“The Fisher King” features Robin Williams as Parry, who has schizophrenia. Or maybe he doesn’t. He suffered mental disturbance following the murder of his wife, which suggests post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), but his religious delusions and hallucinations are more characteristic of schizophrenia. The danger is that the viewer assumes that all PTSD patients have schizophrenia, or that schizophrenia can be triggered by traumatic events, neither of which is true.
An Angel at My Table (1990)
The film adaptation of author Janet Frame’s second autobiography examines one of the most relentless stereotypes of mental illness: the mad genius. Kerry Fox plays Frame, who was labeled as “different” throughout her life before receiving a misdiagnosis of schizophrenia and undergoing eight years of psychiatric treatment, including electric shock therapy. Aside from telling Frame’s fascinating story, the film demonstrates the inconsistency of psychiatric disorder classifications.
The Soloist (2009)
“The Soloist” is an adaption of the true story of Nathaniel Anthony Ayers (played by Jamie Foxx), a previous student at the Julliard School of Music, who has schizophrenia. He forms a life-changing friendship with a reporter, Steve Lopez (Robert Downey, Jr.). Generally, this movie is an accurate depiction of the prevailing ethical issues surrounding treatment of and attitudes toward those with schizophrenia and other forms of mental illness.
Take Shelter (2011)
The award-winning “Take Shelter” centers on Curtis (Michael Shannon), who believes he is in the early stages of schizophrenia, an illness his mother was diagnosed with. It’s true that schizophrenia can run in families, and Curtis’s behavior does fit with his self-diagnosis of schizophrenia. He questions this throughout and even at the end of the movie, and the viewer is left with unanswered questions. This highlights the diagnostic difficulties involved in assessing patients with delusions.
In “Spider,” Ralph Fiennes plays Mr. Cleg, a man with schizophrenia who is released from a psychiatric hospital after 20 years. By switching between the inner and outer worlds of Mr. Cleg, the viewer questions what is true and what isn’t — giving them a glimpse into the world of someone with schizophrenia. However, critics of the movie take issue with the portrayal of someone with mental illness as dangerous and violent — as is so common when schizophrenia is featured on the big screen.
Angel Baby (1995)
The brutally realistic, award-winning “Angel Baby” uses schizophrenia as the premise of a love story. Harry (John Lynch) and Kate (Jacqueline McKenzie), who both have the illness, move in together and decide to have a child, but in order to do that they must stop taking their medication and risk going back to a life of hallucinations and delusions. This movie manages to tell Harry and Kate’s poignant, complex story without resorting to many of the clichés often found in films about mental illness.